...
Show More
This book could be divided into three parts: Crichton's time as a medical student at Harvard; his travels; and his foray into psychic stuff, so I'll divide my review up the same way.
➽ n Harvard Medical Schooln
I love this book so much, and I haven’t even reached the part that I picked the book up for (the travels, of course). In this first part, Crichton describes his time as a medical student at Harvard and what lead him to quitting medicine just as he graduated to become a writer instead. (And side note: this is making me question my life choices all over again. Between Crichton’s disillusionment with medicine and a conversation with my brother I had yesterday about life in the hospital and how being a doctor isn’t all that fulfilling, I’m re-thinking everything I’ve wanted to do in my own life. Ugh.) But back to the book. It was so interesting to see how differently medicine was practiced nearly fifty years ago.
➽ n Travelsn
It starts in LA where Crichton had moved to be in the movie business. In the apartment complex he moved into, the manager listed “MD” after the title because he thought it added more prestige to the place, so every time there was a medical emergency, the doorman would end up calling Crichton, who wasn’t licensed to practice medicine. And a series of funny events ensued (well, they were funny when they weren’t sad).
Psychiatry In the next chapter, Crichton starts seeing a psychiatrist because his wife wants to get back together, but he doesn’t. She uses reverse psychology to get him to start seeing one when he doesn’t want to by telling him, this doctor is so busy he probably won’t be able to see you anyway. He takes that as a challenge and immediately makes an appointment. They start talking and he helps Crichton realize that he’s rather insecure about his life despite all his successes. He helps talk him through several of his next dating relationships as well. But my favorite part is just that someone so successful as Crichton needed help and reached out too. It’s okay to be in therapy and it doesn’t make you any less of a person.
In Thailand, he discovers that despite how much he’s traveled throughout his life, he isn’t very culturally aware and actually hasn’t seen most of the world outside of North America and Western Europe and he decides to change that. This chapter may have also contained my least favorite part of the book when they go to visit a "whore house". I was so disgusted and sad he would have even stepped foot into that place in the first place.
In Shangri-la, he visits the people of Hunza where he claims that people live to be 140 years old on a diet of apricots and are immune to disease.
Upon doing some research, it turns out that Shangri-la is just a ficitional place mentioned in a 1933 novel by James Hilton. As for the Hunza valley, it’s a real mountainous valley in Pakistan. This is the only scientific article I could find about the matter, and it turns out this claim is not exactly true. This journal article also touches on the matter.
And I won't summarize the rest of it because it's definitely worth a read!
➽ n Psychic stuffn
This is the part of the book that I could have done without, but he does make a good case for it at the end of the book in his postscript.
In conclusion, I’ve had this on my TBR for like 10 years now. Not sure how I even first heard of it, but I’m so so so glad I finally decided to pick it up. <3 I want more books like this in my life. Random ones you won’t see any book bloggers or bookstagrammers talking about, ones that were published decades ago, ones without pretty covers, but ones that mean so much to me.
Random stuff I learned:
➽ "During the Korean War, post-moretms on young men had shown that the American diet produced advanced arteriosclerosis by the age of 17.
➽ “I demonstrated a great value to keeping a diary, and have kept one even since. I reread Franklin’s Autobiography, and noted that he kept a record of himself, as I did, for exactly the same reasons. This most practical and observant of men had decided that careful record-keeping was the only way to find out what he was really doing.”
➽ “The creator of Sherlock Holmes was a Scottish physician, a lapsed Catholic, a vigorous athlete, and a Victorian gentleman. Although he is most closely associated with the cool, deductive mind of his fictional detective, Conan Doyle showed an interest in spiritualism, mysticism, and metaphysics even in medical school. His stories frequently contained a strong element of the supernatural; in such works as The Hound of the Baskervilles there is a continuous tension between a supernatural and a mundane explanation for events.”
➽ “Unaccustomed to direct experience, we can come to fear it. We don’t want to read a book or see a museum show until we’ve read the reviews so that we know what to think. We lose the confidence to perceive for ourselves. We want to know the meaning of an experience before we have it.
We become frightened of direct experience, and we will go to elaborate lengths to avoid it.
I found I liked to travel, because it got me out of my routines and my familiar patterns."
➽ “Has anyone in this room had their tonsils and adenoids removed? Has anyone had a radical mastectomy for breast cancer? Has anyone been treated in an intensive care unit? Has anyone had coronary bypass surgery? Of course, many people had.
I said, Then you’re all knowledgeable about superstitions, because all these procedures are examples of superstitious behavior. They are procedures carried out without scientific evidence that they produce any benefit. This society spends billions of dollars a year on superstitious medicine, and that is a problem—and an expense—far more important than astrology columns in daily newspapers, which are so vigorously attacked by the brainpower of CSICOP.
And I added, Let’s not be too quick to deny the power of superstition in our own lives. Which of us, having suffered a heart attack, would refuse to be treated in an intensive-care unit just because such units are of unproven value? We’d all take the ICU. We all do.
I then went on to mention the many cases of fraud in research science. Isaac Newton may have fudged his data;4 certainly Gregor Mendel, father of Mendelian inheritance, did.5 The Italiano mathematician Lazzarini faked an experiment to “determine the value of pi, and his result went unquestioned for more than half a century.6 British psychologist Sir Cyril Burt invented not only his data, but research assistants to gather it.7 In more recent years, there were cases of fraud involving William T. Summerlin of Sloan-Kettering, Dr. John Long of the Harvard Medical School, and Dr. John Darsee of the Harvard Medical School.”
➽ “There are, in fact, well-studied subjects who appear to defy scientific explanation—in particular the famous medium of the last century, Mrs. Piper, who was championed by William James, professor of psychology at Harvard. Mrs. Piper was subjected to intense scrutiny for nearly a quarter of a century, but no skeptic was ever able to demonstrate fraud or trickery.”
➽ n Harvard Medical Schooln
I love this book so much, and I haven’t even reached the part that I picked the book up for (the travels, of course). In this first part, Crichton describes his time as a medical student at Harvard and what lead him to quitting medicine just as he graduated to become a writer instead. (And side note: this is making me question my life choices all over again. Between Crichton’s disillusionment with medicine and a conversation with my brother I had yesterday about life in the hospital and how being a doctor isn’t all that fulfilling, I’m re-thinking everything I’ve wanted to do in my own life. Ugh.) But back to the book. It was so interesting to see how differently medicine was practiced nearly fifty years ago.
➽ n Travelsn
It starts in LA where Crichton had moved to be in the movie business. In the apartment complex he moved into, the manager listed “MD” after the title because he thought it added more prestige to the place, so every time there was a medical emergency, the doorman would end up calling Crichton, who wasn’t licensed to practice medicine. And a series of funny events ensued (well, they were funny when they weren’t sad).
Psychiatry In the next chapter, Crichton starts seeing a psychiatrist because his wife wants to get back together, but he doesn’t. She uses reverse psychology to get him to start seeing one when he doesn’t want to by telling him, this doctor is so busy he probably won’t be able to see you anyway. He takes that as a challenge and immediately makes an appointment. They start talking and he helps Crichton realize that he’s rather insecure about his life despite all his successes. He helps talk him through several of his next dating relationships as well. But my favorite part is just that someone so successful as Crichton needed help and reached out too. It’s okay to be in therapy and it doesn’t make you any less of a person.
In Thailand, he discovers that despite how much he’s traveled throughout his life, he isn’t very culturally aware and actually hasn’t seen most of the world outside of North America and Western Europe and he decides to change that. This chapter may have also contained my least favorite part of the book when they go to visit a "whore house". I was so disgusted and sad he would have even stepped foot into that place in the first place.
In Shangri-la, he visits the people of Hunza where he claims that people live to be 140 years old on a diet of apricots and are immune to disease.
Upon doing some research, it turns out that Shangri-la is just a ficitional place mentioned in a 1933 novel by James Hilton. As for the Hunza valley, it’s a real mountainous valley in Pakistan. This is the only scientific article I could find about the matter, and it turns out this claim is not exactly true. This journal article also touches on the matter.
And I won't summarize the rest of it because it's definitely worth a read!
➽ n Psychic stuffn
This is the part of the book that I could have done without, but he does make a good case for it at the end of the book in his postscript.
In conclusion, I’ve had this on my TBR for like 10 years now. Not sure how I even first heard of it, but I’m so so so glad I finally decided to pick it up. <3 I want more books like this in my life. Random ones you won’t see any book bloggers or bookstagrammers talking about, ones that were published decades ago, ones without pretty covers, but ones that mean so much to me.
Random stuff I learned:
➽ "During the Korean War, post-moretms on young men had shown that the American diet produced advanced arteriosclerosis by the age of 17.
➽ “I demonstrated a great value to keeping a diary, and have kept one even since. I reread Franklin’s Autobiography, and noted that he kept a record of himself, as I did, for exactly the same reasons. This most practical and observant of men had decided that careful record-keeping was the only way to find out what he was really doing.”
➽ “The creator of Sherlock Holmes was a Scottish physician, a lapsed Catholic, a vigorous athlete, and a Victorian gentleman. Although he is most closely associated with the cool, deductive mind of his fictional detective, Conan Doyle showed an interest in spiritualism, mysticism, and metaphysics even in medical school. His stories frequently contained a strong element of the supernatural; in such works as The Hound of the Baskervilles there is a continuous tension between a supernatural and a mundane explanation for events.”
➽ “Unaccustomed to direct experience, we can come to fear it. We don’t want to read a book or see a museum show until we’ve read the reviews so that we know what to think. We lose the confidence to perceive for ourselves. We want to know the meaning of an experience before we have it.
We become frightened of direct experience, and we will go to elaborate lengths to avoid it.
I found I liked to travel, because it got me out of my routines and my familiar patterns."
➽ “Has anyone in this room had their tonsils and adenoids removed? Has anyone had a radical mastectomy for breast cancer? Has anyone been treated in an intensive care unit? Has anyone had coronary bypass surgery? Of course, many people had.
I said, Then you’re all knowledgeable about superstitions, because all these procedures are examples of superstitious behavior. They are procedures carried out without scientific evidence that they produce any benefit. This society spends billions of dollars a year on superstitious medicine, and that is a problem—and an expense—far more important than astrology columns in daily newspapers, which are so vigorously attacked by the brainpower of CSICOP.
And I added, Let’s not be too quick to deny the power of superstition in our own lives. Which of us, having suffered a heart attack, would refuse to be treated in an intensive-care unit just because such units are of unproven value? We’d all take the ICU. We all do.
I then went on to mention the many cases of fraud in research science. Isaac Newton may have fudged his data;4 certainly Gregor Mendel, father of Mendelian inheritance, did.5 The Italiano mathematician Lazzarini faked an experiment to “determine the value of pi, and his result went unquestioned for more than half a century.6 British psychologist Sir Cyril Burt invented not only his data, but research assistants to gather it.7 In more recent years, there were cases of fraud involving William T. Summerlin of Sloan-Kettering, Dr. John Long of the Harvard Medical School, and Dr. John Darsee of the Harvard Medical School.”
➽ “There are, in fact, well-studied subjects who appear to defy scientific explanation—in particular the famous medium of the last century, Mrs. Piper, who was championed by William James, professor of psychology at Harvard. Mrs. Piper was subjected to intense scrutiny for nearly a quarter of a century, but no skeptic was ever able to demonstrate fraud or trickery.”