...
Show More
“Carrie took all their pictures from Jamaica (how happy they looked, just discovering each other), and cut out the ones of Mr. Big smoking his cigar. She thought about what it was like sleeping with him, how she would sleep curled around his back. She wanted to take the pictures and glue them to a piece of construction paper and write “Portrait of Mr. Big with His Cigar,” across the top and then, “I miss you,” with lots of kisses at the bottom. She stared at the pictures for a long time. And then she did nothing.”
I was expecting this book to be fun. Instead, it was strangely depressing. And I'm pleasantly surprised.
Plenty of people seem to have hated this book. But I gotta say I really liked it. I liked a lot of things about it.
I liked the cynical view of Manhattan and its dating landscape. Well, at least for the very limited social class it depicted. It really worked as a somber portrait of a city that, much like its people, was glamorous and extravagant on the outside, but completely hollow inside, with an emptiness that seemed to take up all the space.
I loved the writing style. There was a sort of detached, subtle quality to it that just accentuated the themes of the book. It contained a sense of helplessness, a distance from its characters, which worked well with the fact that these are are real people, living their real lives.
I found it really interesting how the author slowly became less and less present in her own book and turned into little more than an omniscient narrator by the end, while the book started containing more of an overarching story and less autoconclusive chapters with specific anecdotes and reflections.
I liked the characters. Yes, they weren't as defined and their personalities weren't as clearly outlined as their counterparts in the show. But honestly, did you expect something different? The show is a comedy. This is about real people.
And yes, it was problematic. But I enjoyed every second of it. It impartially showcased the opinions of its characters, which were... Questionable, to say the least. Just read the chapter on threesomes and you'll understand. And that's the reason why it works as a portrait of its setting and time. I think there's value in that. I think we could all take something from it.
My favourite chapters were chapters 10 and 11 (downtown babes meet old Greenwich gals & babes flee land of wives for night of topless fun); chapter 14 (portrait of a bulgy underwear model: the Bone pops out of his giant billboard); chapter 22 (bone and the white mink: Carrie's Christmas Carol); chapter 24 (Aspen); and chapter 25 (the last chapter). Oh my god, these titles are long.
So yeah. If you're looking for a fun book, this might not be it. But I think there's something really great about it.
I was expecting this book to be fun. Instead, it was strangely depressing. And I'm pleasantly surprised.
Plenty of people seem to have hated this book. But I gotta say I really liked it. I liked a lot of things about it.
I liked the cynical view of Manhattan and its dating landscape. Well, at least for the very limited social class it depicted. It really worked as a somber portrait of a city that, much like its people, was glamorous and extravagant on the outside, but completely hollow inside, with an emptiness that seemed to take up all the space.
I loved the writing style. There was a sort of detached, subtle quality to it that just accentuated the themes of the book. It contained a sense of helplessness, a distance from its characters, which worked well with the fact that these are are real people, living their real lives.
I found it really interesting how the author slowly became less and less present in her own book and turned into little more than an omniscient narrator by the end, while the book started containing more of an overarching story and less autoconclusive chapters with specific anecdotes and reflections.
I liked the characters. Yes, they weren't as defined and their personalities weren't as clearly outlined as their counterparts in the show. But honestly, did you expect something different? The show is a comedy. This is about real people.
And yes, it was problematic. But I enjoyed every second of it. It impartially showcased the opinions of its characters, which were... Questionable, to say the least. Just read the chapter on threesomes and you'll understand. And that's the reason why it works as a portrait of its setting and time. I think there's value in that. I think we could all take something from it.
My favourite chapters were chapters 10 and 11 (downtown babes meet old Greenwich gals & babes flee land of wives for night of topless fun); chapter 14 (portrait of a bulgy underwear model: the Bone pops out of his giant billboard); chapter 22 (bone and the white mink: Carrie's Christmas Carol); chapter 24 (Aspen); and chapter 25 (the last chapter). Oh my god, these titles are long.
So yeah. If you're looking for a fun book, this might not be it. But I think there's something really great about it.