Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
37(37%)
4 stars
29(29%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
DE QUÉ TRATA

Amberton es un pueblo pequeño y pintoresco, ubicado en un valle cercano a las Rocosas, en EE.UU. Su historia cuenta con un evento trágico: en 1910 un grupo de mineros murió en lo que era la fuente de riquezas del lugar, una mina de carbón. Desde entonces, y por medio siglo, la mina estuvo cerrada y las murmuraciones en torno a ella abundaron, otorgándole cierto aire de espacio maldito. Entre las narraciones contadas en voz baja, se destaca la de «los niños del agua», que asegura que las poblaciones indias de siglos anteriores llevaban a las montañas a sus hijos que nacían muertos, para dejarlos ahí. Más tarde, esos mismos niños volvían a reclamar la vida de los vivos que osaban molestarlos.

Durante cincuenta años, las historias fueron sólo eso, historias. Pero ahora, Elliot Lyons es sacado de la mina muerto, después de visitarla con la intención de abrirla nuevamente. Christie, su hija, y huérfana ya que su madre también había fallecido años atrás, es conducida a la casa de la anciana señora Edna Amber y de su hija de cincuenta años, Diana, últimos eslabones de la familia fundadora del pueblo (de ahí el nombre de Amberton, claro). Christie se quedará con ellas hasta que pasen los funerales y encuentre una familia con quien vivir. A partir de ese momento, Christie y Diana entablarán una estrecha relación, que por parte de Diana no sólo buscará consolar a la pequeña por la muerte de su padre, sino también protegerla de la sangre fría de su propia madre. El único problema radica en que, cuando sopla el viento, es la misma Diana la que pierde el control de sí misma. De hecho, es capaz de hacer cualquier cosa y después no recordar nada. Así, Christie se enfrentará a una verdadera pesadilla, que a veces parecerá provenir de las montañas en forma de viento y llanto, y, a veces, surgirá de su mismo entorno, entre las mismas cuatro paredes que, se supone, la están cobijando.

En este contexto, la muerte vuelve a golpear al pueblo de Amberton. Al momento de buscar una respuesta, no se podrá más que mirar hacia la mina o, en su defecto, cerrar los ojos para escuchar el soplo del viento, que trae consigo el sonido de los que, aunque sin vida propia, todavía lloran.


UNA OPINIÓN

John Saul tomó notoriedad con el libro DEJAD A LOS NIÑOS (1977). Desde entonces, ha publicado más de treinta novelas, todas ellas de suspenso y terror, aunque no todas traducidas al castellano. CUANDO SOPLA EL VIENTO (1981) es su quinta novela. La ambientación en el pueblo ficticio de Amberton, con su mina maldita y su cantera, es perfecta para generar un (micro)clima opresivo. Algunos de sus personajes, como los de Edna y Diana Amber, el doctor Bill Henry o Esperanza Rodríguez, no carecen de atractivo. Sin embargo, la historia no termina de convencer. Es lenta, y parece demorarse siempre en torno a lo mismo, sin avanzar demasiado. Y cuando lo hace, cuando avanza, se tiene la sensación de estar ante escenas forzadas, como cuando en el capítulo 21 se revela que el personaje de Eddie Whitefawn conoce datos sumamente importantes sobre lo ocurrido en torno a la muerte de otro personaje, información que, para que sea honesta en términos narrativos, tendría que haber sido mencionada antes. Además, la desprolijidad de la edición, con gran cantidad de erratas y de errores cohesivos, hace que la lectura se vuelva accidentada. Un ejemplo de esto es la falta de marcas gráficas que indiquen las divisiones entre escenas, obligando al lector a interrumpirse para poder organizarse en el devenir de la historia. Por supuesto, esta es una falta que (podemos suponer) tiene que ver más con una edición barata de bolsillo que con las capacidades del escritor.

En conclusión, CUANDO SOPLA EL VIENTO de John Saul es una novela que no llega a ser lo suficientemente buena como para recomendarla, pero que tampoco es tan mala como para que evitemos volver a probar suerte con otra novela del autor.
April 17,2025
... Show More
There is one to say about John Saul's early novels (this is my 5th) is that he certainly has a style. They may be billed as horror stories but this one is more a psychological mystery story than anything. The only 'supernatural' element is the references to the Water Babies who are supposed to cry when the wind blows. Once again we have young girl (Chrissy) who ends up living in a creep house, this time with an old lady how belongs to the family who have been the power in their small town and her somewhat damaged middle aged daughter (Diana). As the story unfolds we get glimpses into the terribly abusive household that Diana was bought up in and how in some strange way it is linked to the wind that makes the Water Babies cry. We watch on in consternation as she starts bringing up Chrissy in the same way. Can the locals who are started to get worried about the set up prevent a major disaster?
April 17,2025
... Show More
I'd probably give this more like a 3.5 star rating. This is definitely a strange one, but I guess that's what you get from John Saul. If you're looking for something that makes you go "what the?" then this is a story for you.
April 17,2025
... Show More
La historia me ha gustado bastante, pero tiene un par de detalles flojos y ambos acaban arruinando el final:
- Uno de los personajes no llega a expresar lo que puede pasar si ocurre X, y sus balbuceos torpes (porque es en lo que quedan, muy triste teniendo en cuenta que al principio parecía que este personaje iba a ser fuerte y a tener un papel crucial) no hacen más que provocar el efecto contrario de lo que pretende. Si al menos hubiera dado alguna pista, algo que pudiera atarse con el final, el personaje no habría resultado un bulto.
- De repente resulta que lo que hemos visto de Tal personaje es mentira, porque cada vez que Y resulta que Z. Esto no se ha visto, así que puede o ser un error por parte del autor o tratarse de un caso de "zas, sorpresa, ahora Tal es igual que Cual y por tanto Tal 2 es como Tal antes". Ocurre tan rápido que la única explicación que se me ocurre que no sea que el autor ha querido (en vano) meter un finalazo es que la casa esté encantada. Y eso en ningún momento se ha visto. Lo siento por el pequeño spoiler, pero esta no es una historia de una casa encantada.
April 17,2025
... Show More
John Saul was one of my favorite authors when I was a teen. I came across this paperback at a library sale and thought I’d check out an old friend.
This was a fun and scary book when I was 15-17. Nothing graphic or gross, just ‘old lady in the house on a hill’ spooky.
The characters are a little bit out of Hollywood casting. “Blond beautiful girl in danger”, “Battleaxe old lady in old house”, “Superstitious Mexican Woman”, etc. Fairly easy to follow and a quick read.
April 17,2025
... Show More
READ:

11/18/'2020

I have done some Saul rereads. This was not a favorite although I seem to remember liking it more as a young one! But some of Saul's books have held up so good over time. I did not feel this one did.

But....

It still has the crept factor..greatly.

Oh wow was this book creepy! Trust good Ole John Saul to scare the living daylights out of me once again!

So as I said, this was a reread. I grew up with Saul and some of his books just never lose their scare power. This is one of them.

This book is about Cristy. She is an orphan and put into the care of Diana and her mother Edna. This is in a small and rural community in Colorado.

Cristy is scared. She does not fel comfortable in her new home. And she especially doesn't feel comfortable when the wind blows...

Like I said this is a creepy read. But it is also frustrating and never really captured me in the way some of Saul's others like Punish The Sinners and Comes the Blind Fury did.

Gave me a new take on the wind blowing. Even know when I hear it blow I am reminded of this book.


Honestly? This book probably deserved a 4 but the ending was odd. I did not actually understand it then nor do I now. I do not usually have that issue with Saul's books. This was a major frustration.

End spoilers:

So if babies die, why didn't Christy take off..immediately?

Is Christy supposed to have become Diana now?

There was so much about the ending I did not get. If YOU understood it, please explain because even with the reread..I simply did not understand it.

But the book is a creeper! I wish I'd loved this but it was still an OK read for me. Worth a read if you are looking for a scare fest. You will never look at the wind blowing in the same way again, trust me!
April 17,2025
... Show More
El prólogo me atrapó por completo, y como esta, hubieron altas escenas en las que el John (del que no tengo el más mínimo dato aparte de su nombre [pedí prestado el libro, y solo porque me atrajo la edición]) establece muy bien la tensión. Y hasta ahí se queda lo bueno, en mi opinión.
Luego, el resto de las escenas son repetitivas entre sí, además de que la historia hace foco en los personajes que menos me interesan; literalmente, en diez páginas protagonizadas por los secundarios, se avanza más la trama y se conoce más acerca de las propias protagonistas que en cien páginas con
estas. Más específicamente, no pude empatizar en lo más mínimo con la Diana (y a veces dudé de si ese era el objetivo del John, o quería que nos caiga mal).
Por último, menciono el hecho de que, si bien muy bonita la portada, lomo, y contratapa, la traducción es re tosca. Me cago en Raúl Acuña.
Al menos me sacó de un bloqueo lector.
April 17,2025
... Show More
There is just something fun about John Saul novels. They are always far fetched and have supernatural elements, there is a flavor of predictability, but they are well written enough to keep me entertained.

I remember this book from ages ago, when I used to read lots of Saul. I found it somewhere and reread it. It's honestly better than I remember it being. The supernatural element is barely there, in fact, I almost wish the epilogue wasn't included. Without that, this book is really the story of an abused kid who grows up into a crazy abused woman.

I found it weird that I started appreciating and kinda liking the old lady, Edna, until she started trying to kill people. She was the clear villain from the start, yet as she reviewed her own crazy daughters history, I found myself kinda liking her and rooting for her. Then she whacked a kid in the head and I decided she wasn't that great :)

Anyways. I enjoyed this book. There may be a nostalgic element to that for me, but i still think the book holds up well and is a decent read.
April 17,2025
... Show More
This was the first book i ever read from John Saul and i was hooked ive read all his collections and purchased most of them
April 17,2025
... Show More
After reading John Saul's, When the Wind Blows, I can't say that I'm a fan of his but I'm not putting him down for the count. When it comes to being a reader, I can't say that I'm specific to any genre. If I had to pick one it would be children's or YA, not mystery, suspense, horror or thriller, all of which this novel could be classified under. Since none of the above is my forte, so to speak, I feel as if I must tread lightly when judging a book by an author who is much loved by many. Almost, like judging King while saying, "I never read horror." or Tolkien while claiming that you don't care for fantasy, never even touched the stuff. I won't say that I've never read in these genres, I've for sure have "touched the stuff", but I'm not joining the mystery readers guild or anything of that sort.

But though I may not be an expert in the matters of such, I can say that I do believe that I have come to some understanding about such genres. I believe that some mysteries, suspense and horror books fall just like comedies. How many comedy movies have you watched in which you thought to yourself, "This is funny?" or said, " I thought this was once funny but now..."? Over time the jokes are no longer funny. Horror and the such falls much the same way. Over time, years later when one picks it up and reads or watches it, the scenes of blood and the lines, "The stairs creaked underfoot." no longer have the same effect.

In this case, for John Saul, I think this has happened.

In no way does this make the book a "bad" read. Actually it is decent, it's just that you are comparing 1980's main stream fiction to our time. It is just like music, some is unforgettable, some you wish to forget and others you only remember fondly when you catch a jingle of it on "VH1's I Love the 80's". This book would be the latter. If I had read it in 1980 (when I was only about...2 months old) I would be looking fondly back at this book and in my mind I would be saying, "Oh I remember how that book scared the crap out of me!" But I'm not and it did not.

In today's world all I can say is that the book held my attention from beginning to end. It was predictable but I was okay with that because the way it was written, I wanted to keep on reading. I became attached to characters and the setting and I had to find out who stayed and who didn't. While I knew who the killer was, I wanted to know why. In the end, I wanted to know who the next killer would be. And, when I finished the book, I looked fondly at it and said, "Hmmm, I wonder if there was a sequel?"

John Saul's, When the Wind Blows, is not a classic in its genre, but that doesn't mean that it's not worth reading, especially if you are a die hard Saul fan or fan of the genre.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Once again, John Saul does what he does so well. He will get all of your emotions in gear and then drive you over the cliff. I’ve read his works for decades and he never lets you down. I guess I’ll take a few minutes to get over this one and then see where I go from here.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.