Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
40(40%)
4 stars
32(32%)
3 stars
27(27%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
Capolavoro. Una grande rilettura del personaggio di Paperone, fedele ma originale.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Ett av om inte 1900-talet absolut mest perfekta verk! Det har verkligen allt! Don Rosa ❤️
April 17,2025
... Show More
Meglio conosciuto come "La Saga di Paperon De Paperoni".
Avventuroso, malinconico, struggente e a tratti poetico.
Molto è stato detto a proposito della Saga, e poco ho io da aggiungere, se non che davvero può essere considerato come un romanzo di formazione, e anche come un romanzo d'avventura.
E' adatto e approcciabile anche a chi si affaccia per la prima volta nel mondo del fumetto Disney e a chi per qualsiasi ragione finora si è tenuto lontano dalla famiglia dei paperi & co.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Hilarious and thorughly enjoyable..really gives an insight into the life of Uncle Scrooge when he wasnt the richest duck in the world...
April 17,2025
... Show More
Nějak tomu ani s odstupem nedokážu odpustit to velmi zfušované české vydání. To, že se nedrží překladů jmen zajetých v kačeřím universu je pro mě samo o sobě těžko skousnutelné, ale to, že neudrží konzistení překlad jednoho jména ani na rozsahu dvou stran… to už je vysloveně nactiutrhání.

Jinak jsem samozřejmě nadšená, že můj hrdina Don Rosa zpracoval ucelenou a podrobnou biografii Skrblíka McKváka, navíc napěchovanou easter eggama pro lidi jako já. Je úplně super, jak drží i naprosto minoritní detaily napříč příběhama. Tady tu biografii vyloženě protkal vším možným, co se pak náhodně zjevuje v jeho klasických příbězích (třeba dělo z búrské války <3).

Zároveň ale prostě Don Rosa stvořil i mnohem větší pecky. Tady to nutně trochu trpí tím, jak tam potřeboval a chtěl napasovat maximum biografických informací a spojit je do nějakého serióznějšího celku. Postrádá to pak tu jeho typickou lehkost a vypointovanost, a teda žel, i humory, vtípky a moje nejmilovanější donrosovské mikropříběhy.

Ale i tak je to samozřejmě zcela zásadní dílo světové literatury a jako takové musí být oslavováno!
April 17,2025
... Show More
Huaaaa... pengen banget buku ini... *liat label harganya*

Ternyata ini buku termahal yang pernah saya baca.

*diulang ah, harapan setelah selesai membaca buku ini*

Huaaaa... pengen banget buku ini...

*liat label harganya lagi*

Huaaaaa... sangat pengen banget punya buku ini.... *makin mupeng tapi ga mau beli sendiri*

Balikin ke perpus, ga yaaa...???
April 17,2025
... Show More
Je z toho vidět nadšení Dana Rosy pro Barksův kánon a pro Skrblíka celkově. To, že se do příběhů snaží vecpat co nejvíce narážek, tomu často neprospívá (na pár panelech se občas snaží odvyprávět příliš moc). Celkově ale velmi povedené.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Απλά δε γίνεται να είσαι φαν των παπιών και να μη σου αρέσει αυτό το αριστούργημα.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Salah satu Buku Wajib kalau kalian menyukai Kisah² Masa Lalu Paman Gober, satu²nya Milyader terkikir, terpelit, egois di Kota Bebek. Buku yang di Bundel menjadi 498 Halaman ini Berisi 12 Chapter + 3 Tambahan Cerita Spesial tentang Petualangan Paman Gober semasa Mudanya. dari dia mendapatkan Keping keberuntungannya yang pertama kali, menjadi Koboi di Montana, menjaga Kastil Keluarganya dari para Tukang Pajak, berpetualangan ke Jawa, bertemu orang² yang akan menjadi Rival²nya kelak (Roker, Gover, Gerombolan Siberat) hingga mendapatkan Emas di Klondike. semuanya dirangkum sangat rapi dan penuh intrik didalamnya, kita sebagai Pembaca juga akan dibawa Haru, tawa, senang akan Petualangan Sang Gober Muda ini
Tentu saja tidak lupa setiap Cerita yang ada juga ngga sekedar bikin tertawa, namun tersirat Pesan² didalamnya yang membuat kita mengerti mengapa Gober yang kita kenal sekarang ini menjadi Pelit, Pemarah, dan Egois.

Buku ini juga Pernah terbit sebelumnya tapi dalam versi Reguler (Majalah) 7 Edisi. namun yang membedakan dari versi lama dan versi Bundel ini adalah tidak adanya cerita tambahan dalam versi lama, selebihnya sama saja. mungkin kalian bertanya, apa Cerita Favorit saya di buku ini, Jawabannya adalah Cerita waktu Gober Muda pergi ke Klondike
disitu dia mati²an mencari Emas dan disitu pulalah dia bertemu Cinta Pertamanya, namun ada cerita Favorit juga ketika Gober mendapatkan Satu Juta Pertamanya dan Menjadi Egois dan Pelit, ini juga yang menjawab pertanyaan kenapa Adik² Paman Gober tidak pernah muncul di Majalah/Komik².

Terakhir, Buku ini sangat² direkomendasikan kalau kalian beneran ingin tahu kisah masa mudanya Paman Gober, dijamin ngga bakal ketiduran atau bosan, semua ceritanya Seru!
April 17,2025
... Show More
What can I say? This simply remains amazing. Keno Don Rosa has always been and remains to be one of my favourite authors of all time.

I've read the stories in this saga so many times I couldn't possible count them, but it's probably been about a decade since the last time. Still, I could tell you almost exactly what was about to happen from start to finish.

Don Rosa is a master story teller, and it's even more impressive if you know that he went out of his way to ensure most of it adheres to the smallest details that his hero Carl Barks put into his original stories.

I've always loved his art style, but it's the combination of the art work and the intricate storytelling that makes this a masterpiece. Awe-inspiring.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I've never read a Duck comic before. In fact, outside of "Mickey's Christmas Carol," I'm reasonably sure that I have had virtually no contact with the character Scrooge McDuck (and for the Ducks fans out there, yes, it was strange reading in the end-notes about how popular the Ducks, particularly Scrooge, are in other countries).

Now I'll definitely like to read more. Beyond being a quality read, Life & Times is a huge undertaking. Due to being busy and the sheer amount of material (8-10 panels per page seems pretty standard, and almost none of them are silent), it took me over a week to read this entire book, but every page made the effort completely worth the time.

Each chapter is a largely stand-alone story, detailing an event in Scrooge's life that turned him into the man that he would become in the later Carl Barks-written Scrooge classics, yet each chapter builds on the last, carving young Scrooge into the icon that he would become. Only one chapter really left me feeling flat, and a few laid on the gags a little bit too thicker than I would've liked for such an exciting, adventurous tale of coming of age and finding your fortune. But overall, almost every chapter hit the nail on the head, moving the story forward, giving the reader a few laughs, and showing off the clarify and beauty of Rosa's cartooning.

Highly recommended.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Ερωτευμένη με το στόρυ του Βίου και της Πολιτείας του Σκρουτζ Μακ Ντακ από το 1997,όταν δημοσιεύτηκε το πρώτο μέρος στο περιοδικό ΚΟΜΙΞ τ. 100, επιτέλους τόσα χρόνια μετά έχω στα χέρια μου την ειδική έκδοση με συγκεντρωμένα τα 12 επεισόδια της σειράς! Εξαιρετικό έργο, μοναδικό, δουλεμένο μέχρι τη λεπτομέρεια, σχεδιασμένο με αγάπη και σεβασμό προς τον "παπιάνθρωπο" και δημιουργό του ήρωα Carl Barks αλλά και όλους εμάς που λατρέψαμε το έργο του και βεβαίως λατρεύουμε τον τσιγκούνη αλλά αξιαγάπητο Σκρουτζ, ο Βίος και η Πολιτεία του Σκρουτζ Μακ Ντακ, το σημαντικότερο και βραβευμένο έργο του Don Rosa, δεν πρέπει να λείπει από τη βιβλιοθήκη κανενός κομιξολάτρη!!!
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.