Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
37(37%)
4 stars
25(25%)
3 stars
37(37%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 16,2025
... Show More
Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum. Shiver me timbers!

This is THE PENULTIMATE pirate adventure, me mateys!

Never mind that it's written for a 12-year-old or that practically every aspect of this adventure has percolated through our collective zeitgeist.

Here it is! The YA to eat ALL YA. Or the tale to drown your young one in so much rum that he or she expires by the bloody knife he or she didn't see while inebriated or by the blasted drink itself.

Pure escapism? No. There's a bit of a heart in here and mercy is not the least of it. But even mercy has a very keen edge.

Pirates, mutiny, dastardly villainy, greed, and democratically elected captaincies.

Wait... WHAT?

*slips quietly out the back door*

Where's Sparrow?


Even so, this was quite a fun diversion. :)
April 16,2025
... Show More
I remember reading this when I was young (probably 10) and reading it again resonated like a true adventure story should. It took me back to when I was young and first became an avid reader. The English is a little difficult to follow. Pirate-speech almost like a distinct language will do that to you, but the plot is great. Language is all about following the idiomatic expressions and unless there is a shared culture some of the idioms will fall flat. The story will not appear original, because it’s been borrowed from so liberally. (Practically EVERY pirate movie has swiped elements of this particular story.) Still great with scary dangerous parts. The characters are larger than life and might be read as caricatures by a modern audience. (Very Pirates of the Caribbean for instance.) I loved it back then. Love it even more now. Truly a classic because it meets the three criteria of longevity (more than 50 years of greatness), exceptional (5 stars, duh), and paradigm creating (meaning it is the standard emulated and flat out copied.)
April 16,2025
... Show More
I last read Treasure Island as a child. So glad I reread it. It’s a wonderful pirate adventure story. Jim Hawkins, Long John Silver, Blind Pew, the squire, Ben Gunn and the others.

The eccentric angry Captain staying at Jim’s fathers inn the Admiral Benbow and being discovered by his estranged companions. The black spot. The discovery of the treasure map and the voyage out. Then the betrayal, fights, Jim always in the thick of it either in an Apple barrel, up a mast or wondering what Silver will do next. He swaps sides more than a liberal democrat on speed.

Treasure Island is a true classic and I plan to watch the 1934 black and white movie on YouTube in the near future.
April 16,2025
... Show More
Fifteen men after a dead man’s chest
Yo, ho, and a bucket of blood

What do pirates do? They drink one bottle of rum after another. They kill each other and anyone else they desire. They are also greedy and will steal the shirt off your back and the gold in your teeth.
They are vulgar in speech but forget the sex, because they are too busy drinking themselves to death. And they say that this is a children’s book.

I tried reading this book way over two years ago, and while I loved the beginning chapters, those at the Admiral Benbow Inn. After Jim and company arrived at Treasure Island and there was a mutiny, I put the book down. I hate battle scenes. Yet, I never forgot the scenes at the
Inn, which I thought contained the best writing of any author. I wanted to read it again, because it kept nagging at me to do so. This time I decided that I had to finish the book, battles and all.

It began with an old captain dragging a chest into the Admiral Benbow Inn, placing it in his room and hiding its key. The Inn was operated by Mr. and Mrs. Hawkins with the help of their young son, Jim. The captain asked Jim to keep an eye out for a one-legged man and to let him know immediately if he sees him. Next, the captain is creeping around, trying to see who is at the Inn at any given time. And he is eating large amounts of food and drinking rum, enough to fill a large barrel. You know, you have seen them at wineries, only those are not filled with rum. And what is it with rum? I thought that it was only good for making Rum Balls, those rum cookies that they make at Christmas, the ones that can also make you drunk. Or, perhaps, rum is used in fruit cakes to make them taste great. Of course, you add the rum after the cake is baked, and of course, and you do not bake the cookies at all.

This time around, I am not reading this book, instead I am listening to it on my BARD app, and the narrator is great. His name is Erik Sandvold and not the same narrator as who you get on Audible. on. He sounds like a pirate when speaking those parts, I should say, what people imagine pirates to sound like. I found myself almost as fascinated with his different voices as I did with the book. Not really. And what is more, I could see the Inn, the island, and the skeletons, even the buckets of blood. I could even almost hear the captain singing “Fifteen men on a dead man’s chest, Yo, ho, and a bottle of rum.” Well, now that I think of it, it was sung aloud by the narrator. Last of all, I even saw the ships shelves with bottles of rum and wanted to grab a few to make Rum Balls.

So now, you know that I have read the battles on the island, and I learned its secrets, but if I tell you anymore, you will have the story spoiled for you. So, I will leave you with this recipe:

No Bake Rum Balls

1 cup finely crushed vanilla wafers
1 cup powdered sugar
1 cup finely chopped walnuts or pecans
1 cup, rum, bourbon or brandy
2 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
2 tablespoons light corn syrup

Mix all in a bowl and shape into balls. Store in an air tight container. Makes 3 dozen.
April 16,2025
... Show More
Original rating: 3 stars
Updated rating: 3 stars (yup, no change)

I originally read this book when I was 12 or 13. I wrote a book report on it for a middle school English class. I also remember that I read it while on Spring Break in Florida - so it was kind of cool to read this while in a somewhat tropical climate. I remember that I liked it okay, but when you are reading it for school, you sometimes cannot trust a lukewarm memory of a book.

In this case, my memory was spot on!

I can describe this book two ways:

- An okay seafaring/pirate tale that will probably be loved by hardcore pirate fans and people who like nautical tales
- Tedious

When I mentioned it was tedious to my wife, she asked if it was repetitive. But, repetitive is not quite right. More like each scene/part of the book is drawn out to the point I was relieved when it moved on. Kind of surprising as it is not all that long of a book. If you are anything like me you will spend a lot of your time thinking "Get on with it!"

One interesting "Ah-ha" moment I had: As you may know, this book features Long John Silver. In my mind, and probably most peoples' minds, he is a famous pirate from a famous pirate book and there is a seafood chain named after him. The ah-ha, and maybe this was not intentional, is that his cover in the book is that he is a cook on the boat. So, naming a restaurant after him makes perfect sense!
April 16,2025
... Show More
Treasure Island is one of those stories that is so famous you already know it prior to reading the book.

It’s the tale of teenage Jim Hawkins who discovers a treasure map and sets sail as a cabin boy along with Long John Silver and the rest of the crew as they embark on their quest for treasure.

The book is predominantly narrated by the teen which is the perfect entry point for younger readers.
I liked that the story was split over five parts, a great way to dip in and out of the story over multiple days.

The story can be a little slow by today’s standards, but it’s a testament to how many elements introduced my Stevenson have become common tropes in all pirate stories!
April 16,2025
... Show More
Unforgettable Classic..

This is the story of a boy 'Jim Hawkins'. His adventure from a simple innocent boy to a mature experienced one is all this story about. I have always been fantasized by the Pirates stories, but reading ‘Treasure Island’ once, had been a long awaiting quench. These was a daring and courageous boy inside the innocent face of Jim. His innocence was his key to success. Even when the pirates of various kinds, good and bad and even worst, are there but still Jim dealt with them like they were just neighbors. From ‘Billy’ to ‘Long John’, he managed to find solution with everyone out there. Dr. Livesey, his neighbor and Magistrate, along with Squire Trelawney, supported him throughout the adventure, to & fro by Hispaniola.
Captain Flint’s Treasure was living in the mind of Jim, Dr., Squire, John, Billy, and all rest crew of the Hispaniola and relevant persons. ‘Black Dog’& blind ‘Pew’ were also the part of the same search party.
I liked the rhythm of;
“Fifteen men on the dead man's chest
—Yo-ho-ho, and a bottle of rum!”

Most interesting chapter was the first one, that not only created craze and curiosity to read further but also the plot was way better than the other chapters in the whole story. I really enjoyed the plot at ‘Admiral Benbow’. Next to it was the last one. The way Author chose his cast and use them in his plot on Island is exemplary. ‘Ben Gunn’ added as wild card proved his worth at last. His support to Jim even when he had whole treasure, shown his good character and mental health even though he was left alone on the Island with no one around. To be stable in such a condition is quite not expected. Trusting anyone in that situation was tough for Jim but he somehow made his way out.
This whole adventure with all interesting cast made this work more memorable and enjoyable. Though it dips in between while the changing of the narration from Jim to Dr. Livesey bit the again it gained strength and finally the last chapter held grip like the first one. This whole sailing adventure created by ‘Stevenson’ will always be the most enchanting one of all the Pirates’ Stories ever. However, I wish this 300+ Pages of story could be more full of content to it than just the chit-chat between characters in-between.

For me its 4.0/5.0
April 16,2025
... Show More
No había leído este clásico de las novelas de aventuras y reconozco que ha sido interesante. Es una novela muy amena, fácil de leer, de ritmo rápido y que consigue introducirte en la historia.
Lectura recomendable para lectores que necesiten algo suave y sin complicaciones.

----------------------

I hadn't read this classic adventure novel before and I must admit that it was interesting. It is a very enjoyable novel, easy to read, fast paced and manages to draw you into the story.
Recommended reading for readers who need something smooth and uncomplicated.
April 16,2025
... Show More
The first time I read Treasure Island, I was 11 or 12, and although it is a challenge for a child whose literary excursions confining to the Famous Five, I loved every page. There is an adventure, violence (hilly), boats, good and bad guys, maps, treasure, and pirates! At that age, there is something profoundly evocative in words like a pirate, ambush, musket, and so forth, and I have remembered Jim's adventures with great pleasure over the years.
I decided to reread it in a fit of nostalgia, even though I was genuinely worried that I would enjoy it again. However, it is even better, as have all the elements I remembered from childhood. Still, now I can appreciate it on a different level and see that it is not all adventure on the high seas, and Treasure Island is a book with live and complex characters. Long John Silver continues the charismatic bandit I remember, and although he is a villain who cheats on Jim, we can not help liking him.
You might say that Treasure Island will not be accessible to toddlers today, but this book is immediately available to any child with imagination and attention for over 2 minutes. In the same way, grown children will also like it because they can revive their childhood a little.
April 16,2025
... Show More
In one of Manny's 1,682 reviews - no, I can't remember which one** - he says that it must have been incredibly exciting being an avid reader of modern novels in the 1880s and 1890s. Not only were they churning out great classics at a rate of knots, they were inventing whole genres - Dracula, Sherlock Holmes, Picture of Dorian Gray, HG Wells - and Treasure Island is one of those, a novel which invented a whole a-harr talk like a pirate genre. Stevenson's prose is quite magical, he absolutely convinced me with his descriptions of winds and seas and gunnels and jibs and booms and mizzenmasts and fo'c'sles (it's okay, you can print the whole word - forecastle - there - the printer won't charge you any more) and all of that. Plus, some of the ripest dialogue anywhere -

"If that ain't to your fancy, some of my hands being rough, and having old scores, on account of hazing, then you can stay here, you can. We'll divide stores with you, man for man; and I'll give my affy-davy as before to speak the first ship I sight, and send 'em here to pick you up... Refuse that, and you've seen the last of me but musket-balls."

"There!" he cried. "That's what I think of ye. Before an hour's out, I'll stove in your blockhouse like a rum puncheon. Laugh, by thunder, laugh! Before an hour's out ye'll laugh on the other side. Them that die'll be the lucky ones.





Cap'n Flint says : As well as a ripping yarn, it's also a nifty dissection of the concept of being a "gentleman" which you may take sociologically, politically or psychologically, as suits ye best, ye lubbers. Squaaawk! Pieces of eight! A tot of rum would go down a treat! Skwawwwk!


**Update : I found a previous note I'd already written so I can confirm that it was Manny's review of A Rebours where he says :


It must have been so exciting to be a novelist in the second half of the nineteenth century. You weren't limited to just creating a novel; if you were talented, you could create a whole new kind of novel.

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...


1883 : Treasure Island – Robert Louis Stevenson
1885 : Germinal : Emile Zola
1886 : The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde : R L Stephenson
1891 : The Picture of Dorian Gray – Oscar Wilde, 1891
1892 : The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes : Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
1895 : The Time Machine : H G Wells
1897 : Dracula : Bram Stoker
1898 : The Turn of the Screw : Henry James
1898 : The War of the Worlds – H G Wells

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.