...
Show More
Heya folks! Thanks for stoppin’ in to this re-read review of American Gods. With the upcoming Stars TV show, I thought it would be a good time for me to revisit a book I read almost 7 years ago before diving into an entirely new interpretation. Here are a few helpful review pointers for first-time readers/viewers and the more seasoned American Gods’ fans.
1.tThis review is SPOILER-FREE. American Gods is an enigmatic story, so I won’t even discuss anything other than the most cursory of plot details. Anything revealed herein is minor, revealed on the back of the book, or vague enough to keep you fresh for a read or the season premiere of the new show.
2.tThis is my first re-read review. So, I’ll be talking a bit about what I remember of my initial impression as well as how I feel about the book now.
3.tI’m trying to read a bunch of Neil Gaiman in 2017. You can see my reviews for n The View From the Cheap Seatsn and n Norse Mythologyn in the links!
American Gods is really the book that's got all that you'd expect from an investigation of Americana. There's a road trip, murder mystery, all kinds of crime, sex, violence, love story, and more motels and hotels than you could ever have imagined.
When I read American Gods in the summer of 2010, I remember being fairly unimpressed with it. I had just come off reading the entirety of Gaiman’s Sandman in four, door-stopping volumes that together took a few weeks’ pay from my summer job. Still, I was snapping at the bit for more Gaiman, and I was told by many Internet resources that American Gods was the way to go. Ultimately, I was disappointed by the book, though I rated it four stars when first signing up for Goodreads in an ill-conceived attempt to look cool.
In many ways, my re-read has allowed me to forgive and understand my lack of appreciation for American Gods on my first go-around. In many ways it’s a book that wouldn’t have scratched the itch I had for adventure and was, indeed, a much more complex novel than I was used to dealing with at the time. This read had me astonished more often, more appreciative at the craft, and really digging the mythological deep-cuts that Gaiman leaves around the novel like gumdrops for the mythology nerds. Having said that, some of the problems I remember having with American Gods cropped up again on this read.
Though I remembered some of the plot, I discovered that I had forgotten a great deal about it. A scattered scene was seared into my brain, the big twists and turns I remembered, but there was a great deal more that I had forgotten. In broad strokes, American Gods follows newly released convict Shadow Moon who is offered a job by a mysterious stranger on the night of his wife’s funeral, and a road-trip across America ensues. The road-trip, I should mention, happens to be more fantastical in nature than Shadow initially suspected it would be and mythological madness adapted to the American countryside ensues.
Some non-spoiler-y stuff that still pestered me through this read: Shadow, a meandering plot, mythology reference-laden scenes. Shadow turns out to be one of the most appealing parts of the book as it goes on, but at first he’s a bit of a bore. He doesn’t reveal much about himself, he doesn’t react to much, and he is somewhat a passenger on a ride for more than half the book. This ride, it turns out, actually is a bit tedious to follow in its first few crests and troughs. The novel keeps its cards so close to the chest for such a long time that the most compelling reason to go on is just to know, What the fuck is going on here? Either of these issues on their own wouldn’t be too bad, but when it’s tough to get a handle on the plot AND the main character? It makes for a bit of a plodding opening despite some really good scenes.
The peculiar scenes that pepper the novel appealed more to me now than they had in the past, but they also frustrate. Having recently read Gaiman’s Norse Mythology, I was well-primed for the nitty-gritty of the Norse references throughout American Gods. Even though I got a lot more on this read than I could have possibly gotten on my first round, there was still a lot of Gods, folk heroes, and the like that I didn’t recognize. It makes for scenes that have cool visuals, but more often than I’d like to admit I was like, Am I supposed to know this goddess? However, it might be fun in another almost-decade to come back to this novel and see what other new stuff I can find.
Oh, and I loved discovering the Sandman Easter eggs littered through the novel that I missed on first pass. I heard a rumor that all the Endless make an appearance? I spotted two!
The ending, and the twists that precede it in the final 200 pages, I appreciated much more this time around. I remember being frustrated and thinking that all the cool stuff littered throughout was for naught. This time I appreciated the conclusion a lot more. It provides an ending that is true to its themes and, in my opinion, nails the character arcs in a way that is really satisfying. Also, I was less focused on the overall mysteries that drive the novel on this read, which let me appreciate all the smaller scenes along the way.
I’m really glad I decided to re-read American Gods. It’s an American novel written by a British lad. I was impressed to read that Gaiman had changed his writing to better suit the American style. I think that the story is an important one in these times too: it is a story, inherently, about immigrants, immigration, and the boiling pot of America. It’s a novel that’s got a lot of depth to it, and I’m really glad I was able to explore those depths on this second go-around.
I may have initially given American Gods four stars to look good, but this time the novel earned it.
NOTE ON TV SHOW: Here's me returning with my promise to offer some thoughts on the show!
1) Brian Fuller was an inspired and powerful choice. This adaptation is the perfect follow up to Hannibal: Fuller is able to go weirder and it works every time.
2) The casting is sublime! Does Shadow not look and sound like you'd expect him to? Is Wednesday not exactly the grifter you pictured?
3) Deviations from the novel are welcome and the fourth episode shows that the writers have a handle on the world and characters and can expand appropriately.
1.tThis review is SPOILER-FREE. American Gods is an enigmatic story, so I won’t even discuss anything other than the most cursory of plot details. Anything revealed herein is minor, revealed on the back of the book, or vague enough to keep you fresh for a read or the season premiere of the new show.
2.tThis is my first re-read review. So, I’ll be talking a bit about what I remember of my initial impression as well as how I feel about the book now.
3.tI’m trying to read a bunch of Neil Gaiman in 2017. You can see my reviews for n The View From the Cheap Seatsn and n Norse Mythologyn in the links!
American Gods is really the book that's got all that you'd expect from an investigation of Americana. There's a road trip, murder mystery, all kinds of crime, sex, violence, love story, and more motels and hotels than you could ever have imagined.
When I read American Gods in the summer of 2010, I remember being fairly unimpressed with it. I had just come off reading the entirety of Gaiman’s Sandman in four, door-stopping volumes that together took a few weeks’ pay from my summer job. Still, I was snapping at the bit for more Gaiman, and I was told by many Internet resources that American Gods was the way to go. Ultimately, I was disappointed by the book, though I rated it four stars when first signing up for Goodreads in an ill-conceived attempt to look cool.
In many ways, my re-read has allowed me to forgive and understand my lack of appreciation for American Gods on my first go-around. In many ways it’s a book that wouldn’t have scratched the itch I had for adventure and was, indeed, a much more complex novel than I was used to dealing with at the time. This read had me astonished more often, more appreciative at the craft, and really digging the mythological deep-cuts that Gaiman leaves around the novel like gumdrops for the mythology nerds. Having said that, some of the problems I remember having with American Gods cropped up again on this read.
Though I remembered some of the plot, I discovered that I had forgotten a great deal about it. A scattered scene was seared into my brain, the big twists and turns I remembered, but there was a great deal more that I had forgotten. In broad strokes, American Gods follows newly released convict Shadow Moon who is offered a job by a mysterious stranger on the night of his wife’s funeral, and a road-trip across America ensues. The road-trip, I should mention, happens to be more fantastical in nature than Shadow initially suspected it would be and mythological madness adapted to the American countryside ensues.
Some non-spoiler-y stuff that still pestered me through this read: Shadow, a meandering plot, mythology reference-laden scenes. Shadow turns out to be one of the most appealing parts of the book as it goes on, but at first he’s a bit of a bore. He doesn’t reveal much about himself, he doesn’t react to much, and he is somewhat a passenger on a ride for more than half the book. This ride, it turns out, actually is a bit tedious to follow in its first few crests and troughs. The novel keeps its cards so close to the chest for such a long time that the most compelling reason to go on is just to know, What the fuck is going on here? Either of these issues on their own wouldn’t be too bad, but when it’s tough to get a handle on the plot AND the main character? It makes for a bit of a plodding opening despite some really good scenes.
The peculiar scenes that pepper the novel appealed more to me now than they had in the past, but they also frustrate. Having recently read Gaiman’s Norse Mythology, I was well-primed for the nitty-gritty of the Norse references throughout American Gods. Even though I got a lot more on this read than I could have possibly gotten on my first round, there was still a lot of Gods, folk heroes, and the like that I didn’t recognize. It makes for scenes that have cool visuals, but more often than I’d like to admit I was like, Am I supposed to know this goddess? However, it might be fun in another almost-decade to come back to this novel and see what other new stuff I can find.
Oh, and I loved discovering the Sandman Easter eggs littered through the novel that I missed on first pass. I heard a rumor that all the Endless make an appearance? I spotted two!
The ending, and the twists that precede it in the final 200 pages, I appreciated much more this time around. I remember being frustrated and thinking that all the cool stuff littered throughout was for naught. This time I appreciated the conclusion a lot more. It provides an ending that is true to its themes and, in my opinion, nails the character arcs in a way that is really satisfying. Also, I was less focused on the overall mysteries that drive the novel on this read, which let me appreciate all the smaller scenes along the way.
I’m really glad I decided to re-read American Gods. It’s an American novel written by a British lad. I was impressed to read that Gaiman had changed his writing to better suit the American style. I think that the story is an important one in these times too: it is a story, inherently, about immigrants, immigration, and the boiling pot of America. It’s a novel that’s got a lot of depth to it, and I’m really glad I was able to explore those depths on this second go-around.
I may have initially given American Gods four stars to look good, but this time the novel earned it.
NOTE ON TV SHOW: Here's me returning with my promise to offer some thoughts on the show!
1) Brian Fuller was an inspired and powerful choice. This adaptation is the perfect follow up to Hannibal: Fuller is able to go weirder and it works every time.
2) The casting is sublime! Does Shadow not look and sound like you'd expect him to? Is Wednesday not exactly the grifter you pictured?
3) Deviations from the novel are welcome and the fourth episode shows that the writers have a handle on the world and characters and can expand appropriately.