Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
35(35%)
3 stars
33(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 25,2025
... Show More

A Scandal in Bohemia


The Adventure of the Red-Headed League


A Case of Identity


The Boscombe Valley Mystery


The Five Orange Pips


The Man with the Twisted Lip


The Blue Carbuncle


The Adventure of the Engineer's Thumb


The Noble Bachelor


The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet


The Adventure of the Copper Beeches
April 25,2025
... Show More
“Life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent.”
April 25,2025
... Show More
A thoroughly enjoyable read - there's something about Sherlock Holmes's powers of deduction that manage to intrigue and entertain all the time. I love the oddness of the cases and the dynamic between Holmes and Watson in these stories.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Sherlock Holmes have always been my favorite. Love how he solves mysteries using deductive reasoning.

Blog | YouTube  | Instagram | Facebook | LinkedIn
April 25,2025
... Show More
n  n   
"Tan acostumbrado estaba yo a sus invariables éxitos que ni se me pasaba por la cabeza la posibilidad de que fracasara"
n  
n






Me gustaron algunas más que otras, pero lo que más me llamó la atención a leer cada historia fue el carácter de Sherlock, que al ser misterios cortos y que por ahí no generaban problemas para resolver, su personalidad e inteligencia es lo que más destaca.

Escándalo en Bohemia 5/5

n  "Para como un carácter como el suyo, una emoción fuerte resultaba tan perturbadora como la presencia de arena en un instrumento de precisión o la rotura de una de sus potentes lupas. Y sin embargo, existió para él una mujer, y esta mujer fue la difunta Irene Adler, de dudoso y cuestionable recuerdo"n


La liga de los pelirrojos: 3.5/5

n  "Si queremos efectos extraños y combinaciones extraordinarias, debemos buscarlos en la vida misma, que siempre llega mucho más lejos que cualquier esfuerzo de la imaginación"n


Un caso de identidad: 3/5

n  "Querido amigo. La vida es infinitamente más extraña que cualquier cosa que pueda inventar la mente humana. No nos atreveríamos a imaginar ciertas cosas que en realidad son de lo más corriente. Si puediéramos salir volando por esa ventana, cogidos de la mano, sobrevolar esta gran ciudad, levantar con cuidado los tejados y espiar todas las cosas raras que pasan, las extrañas coincidencias, las intrigas, los engaños, los prodigiosos encadenamientos de circunstancias que se extienden de generación en generación y acaban conduciendo a los resultados más extravagantes, nos parecía que las historias de ficción, con sus convencionalismos y sus conclusiones sabidas de antemano, son algo trasnochado e insípido"n


El misterio de Boscombe Valley: 3.5/5

n  "Las pruebas circunstanciales son muy engañosas. Puede parecer que indican claramente una cosa, pero si cambias un poquito tu punto de vista, puedes encontrarte con que indican, con igual claridad, algo completamente diferente"n


Las cinco semillas de naranja: 3.5/5

n  -He venido en busca de consejo.
-Eso se consigue fácilmente.
-Y de ayuda.
-Eso no siempre es tan fácil.
n


El hombre del labio retorcido: 4/5

El carbunclo azul: 4/5

La banda de lunares: 4.5/5

n  "Vivimos en un mundo malvado, y cuando un hombre inteligente dedica su talento al crimen, se vuelve aún peor"n


El dedo pulgar del ingeniero: 5/5

n  "Experiencia. En cierto modo, puede resultarle muy valiosa. No tiene más que ponerla en forma de palabras para ganarse una reputación de persona interesante para el resto de su vida"n


El aristócrata solterón: 4/5

La corona de berilos: 3.5/5

n  "Su silencio me parece un arma de dos filos"n


El misterio de Copper Beeches: 4.5/5

n  "El hombre que ama el arte por el arte suele encontrar los placeres más intensos en sus manifestaciones más humildes y menos importantes"n


n  n    "Ya sabe usted, Watson, que una de las maldiciones de una mente como la mía es que tengo que mirarlo todo desde el punto de vista de mi especialidad. Usted mira esas casas dispersas y se siente impresionado por su belleza. Yo las miro, y el único pensamiento que me viene a la cabeza es lo aisladas que están, y la impunidad con que puede cometerse un crimen en ellas"n  n


n  n    2015 Reading Challenge:n  n



April 25,2025
... Show More
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is a collection of twelve adventures and the most famous cases of the legendary Sherlock Holmes and his assistant Dr. John Watson, including the likes of A Scandal in Bohemia, The Boscombe Valley Mystery, The Speckled Band, The Five Orange Pips, and The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet, all created by revered author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I am looking forward to continuing with the series. These books have become true classics and one of the reasons why is best said by our esteemed protagonist as follows:

n  
"'My dear fellow,' said Sherlock Holmes as we sat on either side of the fire in his lodgings at Baker Street, 'life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind could invent. We would not dare to conceive the things which are really mere commonplaces of existence. If we could fly out that window hand in hand, hover over this great city, gently remove the roofs, and peep in at the queer things which are going on, the strange coincidences, the plannings, the cross-purposes, the wonderful chains of event, working through generations, and leading to the most outré results, it would make all fiction with its conventionalities and foreseen conclusions most stale and unprofitable.'"
n
April 25,2025
... Show More
Fun. The crimes in this book are more along the lines of puzzles to work out rather than realistic depictions of crime in late Victorian- early Edwardian England. Contrived, but enjoyable.

My favourite moment, I am not positive it is in this collection, is when Holmes and Watson are on a train steaming through the countryside and Watson makes an observation about the peaceful looking pretty cottages for which Holmes rebukes him 'no one knows what dark crimes are committed behind those doors' - reversing a view of the country as peace and the city as locus of iniquit,y instead the countryside is the place of dark Hardian misery (where engineers' thumbs may be cut off with impunity, and daughters forever imprisoned until some interfering busybody and his sidekick from the city turns up) while in the busy teeming city every crime will be found out and the brutal, or dishonest  or both perpetrator brought to justice. Enjoyably I love in the story of "The man with a twisted lip" the ever green urban legend that beggars are secretly rich men - hamming up their incapacity for work while earning piles of money by sitting on a street corner.
April 25,2025
... Show More
It's generally accepted that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was a much better short-story writer than he was a novelist, so it comes as no shock that The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, a collection of short stories involving the consulting detective, are a vast improvement over the previous two books.
n  "Women are naturally secretive, and they like to do their own secreting.n
A Scandal in Bohemia is a masterclass of a short story. In essence, Holmes is bested by a woman, Irene Adler, because he just can't escape his own woefully stereotypical views of women. Where a man can be defined by his social status, his personal habits and you know, by the rich tapestry of their humanity — woman is sufficiently explanatory of the opposite sex for Holmes.

Sherlock finally encounters a woman outside of the patriarchal roles assigned to them and is almost immediately humbled. Unfortunately, his takeaway isn't that, perhaps, women are as multifaceted as men, but that Adler herself is some kind of exceptional super-woman worthy of uncommon respect. A woman whose picture he'll paw at pathetically for decades to come. And for the Victorian recluse, that's a win.
n  "As far as you are personally concerned," remarked Holmes, "I do not see that you have any grievance against the extraordinary league. On the contrary, you are, I understand, richer by some thirty pounds, to say nothing of the minute knowledge which you have gained on every subject which comes under the letter A."n
Then there's The Red-Headed League, another banger. A man gets roped into a preposterously suspicious job due to him being a ginger, and is flabbergasted when the opportunity blows up in his face.

Watson and Holmes don't take him seriously for a minute, laugh in his face about his predicament, and its hilarious. Also, Watson ejaculates again, and Holmes does that irritating thing where he quotes something in a different language — which must have been especially irritating to readers at the time, sans Google.

A Case of Identity takes the What-the-Fuckery up to new, dangerously implausible heights. Disguises have always been like magic in the Sherlock Holmes universe. No amount of crack could explain the scene in The Sign of Four where Sherlock reveals himself to Watson by taking off his sailor wig and Watson, actually for-the-love-of-god, wonders where the sailor has gone?

So the story of a stepfather tricking his poorly-sighted stepdaughter that he's another man entirely — by only coming out in the evening, and wearing dark glasses, and murmuring throughout their courtship — is another hard sell, but its stupidity rebounds and becomes almost as funny as the last story. Especially as it ends with Holmes declaring, "Bitches be crazy," as to his reason for not revealing the truth to the stepdaughter.

The Boscombe Valley Mystery is a simple blackmail-turned-murder mystery that's main contribution is adding a fifth "ejaculation" to Watson's tally.

The Five Orange Pips deals with the KKK exacting revenge over their flagging organisation. Holmes solves the case but justice isn't served as the culprits are presumably lost at sea. The Man with the Twisted Lip: a man with a full-time job supplements his income by professional begging and accidentally stages his own murder.

The Blue Carbuncle stands out because at one point Holmes assumes a man's an intellectual because he has a big head. Annnd that his wife doesn't love him because his hat is dirty, which is obviously a loving wifely duty not to be undertaken by the man, himself, ever. Other than that, its a bonafide Christmas special.

The Speckled Band is another case of a stepfather trying to prevent his stepdaughters from marrying because of its impact on his finances. This time Holmes and Watson beat a snake alone in a dark room at night. Watson ejaculates again.

A personal favourite is The Engineers Thumb, which is the series first real foray into horror. Its genuinely scary and the ending gives no resolution to the killer. The poor engineers business is still failing, he's lost a thumb and gained significant trauma from the ordeal — but Holmes is quick to look on the bright side; it'll be a good story to tell at parties. Honestly, good point.

The Noble Bachelor is a boring runaway bride mystery that resolves with a shrug. The Beryl Coronet is forgettable. And, lastly, The Copper Beeches starts with a curious conversation between Holmes and Watson:
n  "Man, or at least criminal man, has lost all enterprise and originality. As to my own little practice, it seems to be degenerating into an agency for recovering lost lead pencils and giving advice to young ladies from boarding-schools."n
There are a few ways this sentiment can be interpreted, but I lean toward it being evidence of Doyle's own weariness for writing these mysteries and, perhaps, regurgitating common criticisms his stories have gotten. Other than that its another father-wants-to-keep-the-dowry story, and Watson shipping Holmes with Miss Hunter.
April 25,2025
... Show More
A Scandal in Bohemia: 4 stars
The Adventure of the Red-Headed League: 5 stars
A Case of Identity: 3.5 stars
The Bascombe Valley Mystery: 3 stars
The Five Orange Pips: 3.5 stars
The Man with the Twisted Lip: 4 stars
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle: 4.5 stars
The Adventure of the Speckled Band: 5 stars
The Adventure of the Engineer's Thumb: 4 stars
The Adventure of the Nobel Bachelor: 4.5 stars
The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet: 5 stars
The Adventure of the Copper Beeches: 5 stars
April 25,2025
... Show More
3.5 stars
Short stories don’t seem fit to show (off) Holmes’ qualities as a detective. They seem hurried, especially at the conclusion. Enjoyed it quite enough but I appreciate the longer stories better. Will therefore round the 3.5 stars down to 3.


12. The Adventure of the Copper Beeches
3.5 stars
Obvious from the start but fun nonetheless!

11. The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet
3.5 stars
Holmes at his best.

10. The Adventure of the Noble Bachelor
3 stars
An ok story showing off Sherlock’s deductive reasoning skills without much active detective work.

9. The Adventure of the Engineer’s Thumb
3 stars
An interesting story.

8. The Adventure of the Speckled Band
3.5 stars
An interesting, slightly creepy story with Holmes doing his thing.

7. The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle
3.5 stars
A typical story with Holmes doing his thing.

6. The Man with the Twisted Lip
3.5 stars
A fast and enjoyable read with a little twist.

5. The Five Orange Pips
3.5 stars
Interesting short story.

4. The Boscombe Valley Mystery
3.5 stars
A typical story with Holmes doing his thing.

3. A Case of Identity
3 stars
One of the short stories I liked less, a bit too obvious and I didn’t like the ending.

2. Red Headed League
3.5 stars
An entertaining short story. I do prefer the longer ones though. Though I love to read about Holmes and dear Watson, short stories are just too short for me to truly get involved.

1. Bohemian Scandal
3.5 stars
Introduction of Irene Adler. I can fully empathize with Holmes, the story left me a bit unsatisfied. Not only because of the partly unresolved ending but also because I find it hard to believe that Holmes wouldn’t be on to her (or wouldn’t take the photo with him right that evening). I know that’s because he’d found his match but still...
April 25,2025
... Show More
3.75 Stars
An episodic collection of stories told through the eyes of Watson as he follows Sherlock Holmes one of the most brilliant and well-loved detectives in literature. Sherlock Holmes is undeniably one of the most intelligent, quick-witted, characters I have ever read about. My first Sherlock Holmes book was this one so I was interested to see that this story isn't told through his perspective but Watson.

A Scandal in Bohemia
4.5 Stars
"To Sherlock Holmes she is always the woman."
At first glance without knowing much about Sherlock Holmes character I would— and many others would probably assumed this quote was meant in a romantic way. What makes this quote so powerful and intriguing is that Irene Adler is always the woman to Sherlock Holmes but not in the way I expected. A Scandal in Bohemia is my favorite story out of the collection, because there was such a powerful star-quality in it. The King of Bohemia approaches Sherlock, begging that he finds the photo that contains evidence of his past relationship with Irene Adler before his new engagement. Sherlock underestimates Irene, leading to a series of mind games and brilliant foreshadowing. I loved to see that Arthur Conan Doyle showed that woman are as capable as men, even a man as smart as Sherlock, to be an intelligent equal to Sherlock's intelligence. Irene was brilliant, witty, and both her and Sherlock's attempts to outsmart each other was so memorable even if it wasn't a full-length novel. Phenomenal.

The Red-Headed League
2 Stars
Weak compared to it's precursor. Watson and Sherlock still managed to pique my interest in a otherwise gimmicky tale.

A Case of Identity
3.5 Stars
Miss Sutherland is looking for her lover Hosmer Angel who disappeared mysteriously, only to find that her stepfather, James Windiback might be involved. I loved this story because it shows how the innocent could in fact be the perpetrator. What the antagonist of this specific story does is not outside the law but something that Sherlock and Watson both agree is cruel and undeniably wrong. It only goes to show how Sherlock finds answers through little clues and details, his thought process/intelligence transcends most human ability to think in such a way yet how interesting it would be if we saw the world and studied it the way he did. I'm only more fascinated about the brilliant mind behind these stories—Arthur Conan Doyle.

The Boscombe Valley Mystery
3 Stars
My feelings for this aren't strong. As always Arthur Conan Doyle still managed to keep things captivating with Watson's interesting inner monologue accompanied by Sherlock's precise observations. This was just seemed dim in comparison to the others but still had a fun twist.

The Five Orange Pips
3.5 Stars
The villain in this story is the Ku Klux Klan as John Openshaw becomes their next target. This story kept my alert the entire time from the constant tension in John's story as he talked about the death of his uncle and father, five orange pips left behind. As John progressed further in his story, Sherlock found the true murderer. It only goes to show that time is of the essence, as Watson and Sherlock find their enemy may be harder to stop than first expected.

The Man with the Twisted Lip.
4.5 Stars
Brilliantly executed, The Man with the Twisted Lip is a stratified story, each moment alight in anticipation. The story starts off with Sherlock in disguise in a opium den; much to Watson's surprise. The two have a unplanned meeting as Watson works alongside Sherlock to find out whose responsible for Neville St. Clair's disappearance. His main suspect is a man with a twisted lip, a man known for his twisted lip yet his actions are obscure. I must admit that it feels a lot like Sherlock is the one really solving everything . . . and using all the brain-power while Watson is like us readers—observing while Sherlock explains things. Still its interesting to see that a man as intelligent of Sherlock who distances himself to certain human emotion finds much pride and respect in his relationship with Watson. That being said Watson is still very intelligent, and its a nice dynamic between the two as they clash and collaborate. The ending to this story was so well-done I loved it!

The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle
3.25 Stars
Sherlock Holmes deduces so many clues just from looking at a man's hat. Wow. A diamond is stolen but who is the one responsible? Red herrings, methodic false trails, and a valuable diamond stolen the mystery all leads to one person. This was interesting because it showed that Sherlock is as human as all of us, capable of showing compassion. Sherlock may fight things that go against the law but at the same time he commits the acts as well just going to show he is not working for the money or fame but for his own individual interest.

The Adventure of the Speckled Band
4 Stars
In this story Sherlock meets a woman named Helen Stoner whose twin sister Julia Stoner was murdered. The last word she uttered was ". . . it was the speckled band." Confused and lost Helen finds Sherlock who analyzes her detailed story and comes up with a hypothesis. Then he begins to explore it, turn it this way and that before finally confronting the truth. It's one hiding in plain sight yet so exciting especially when a action scene is present. Sherlock Holmes actions are no doubt outside of the law, but the greater question for me was whether they could be justified as justice for Julia or perceived by Watson as unnecessary. Still, it was interesting to see how the situation catapulted into a crime in order to solve one.

The Adventure of the Engineer's Thumb
4 Stars
This story had such high-stakes, the atmosphere filled with a thrill as a man comes to Sherlock, his thumb cut off. When Victory Hatherley goes to the country side to assist another person but ends up getting his thumb cut off he almost uncovers a dangerous secret but flees. As Watson treats the stump of his thumb he later brings the man to Sherlock. Then the story spirals as Sherlock discovers something dangerous to many . . . but will they be able to capture the culprit in time? It was action-packed with great story-telling.

The Adventure of the Noble Bachelor
4 Stars
I felt bad for Lord St. Simon but at the same time glad at the conclusion as this story details the disappearance of his bride. Sherlock and Watson discover why his bride disappears with a story of unrequited love and past love that comes together. Loved how this one had some drama with a different tone then the two stories before this one. This was was pure entertainment and for some reason I found it hilarious . . . still was a good read.

The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet
4.5 Stars
Sherlock tries to prove the innocence of the main suspect rather than solve the case, but the two go hand-in-hand when he discovers both. When Arthur Holder wakes up one night to find that the beryl coronet is has gems missing, and his son is the one holding it. Distrustful of his son he is now the main suspect, but Sherlock observes, watches, listens, thinks, before figuring out who is really responsible. Sherlock always finds the answers in the details not in what everyone assumes—because the answers are more complicated.

The Adventure of the Copper Breeches
2.5 Stars
After the succession of exciting mysteries this one admittedly fell flat. I have not many strong thoughts about this. I enjoyed the way Violet told her story as well as her attention to detail, but this one didn't feel as important as the other stories.
☑️PLOT
☑️CHARACTERS
☑️PLOT TWISTS
April 25,2025
... Show More
Me declaro fanática absoluta de Sherlock Holmes... creo que es la mejor opinión que puedo dar.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.