Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
32(32%)
3 stars
36(36%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
I absolutely do love love love Lucy Maud Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables series, and indeed, especially the third book, in particular her Anne of the Island is and always will be a total favourite, and yes, a very special and personal favourite that I have in fact and actually read more than ANY of the other series books, including the first novel, including Anne of Green Gables (with my conservative guesstimate being that my reading amount for Anne of Green Gables is probably around ten times but that I have read, laughed and cried over Anne of the Island probably twenty times and perhaps even considerably more than that).

Honestly and truth be told, I definitely and certainly massively both adore and appreciate absolutely everything about Anne of the Island. Anne Shirley finally going to Redmond College to get her BA, her rather humorous but also a bit frustrating travails trying to learn how to write proper and not too exaggerated, too overwrought fiction, her on and off again romantic entanglements with Gilbert Blythe and yes, even poor Ruby Gillis' death from consumption (although part of me has always chafed that L.M. Montgomery could not have let Ruby live), all of these (and of course many many more) episodes and anecdotes, they always make me feel comforted, and like a hot cup of tea, Anne of the Island is to and for me a panacea to and for both my and the world's ills and woes. But still and nevertheless, even though totally like a blanket of loveliness and softly positive wonder, Anne of the Island also portrays sadness (and even tragedy) at times, albeit always in a manner that is easily digestible and tolerable, acceptable, perhaps even necessary and required, and with the glowing and very much appreciated fact that L.M. Montgomery makes most of her characters, makes Anne, Stella, Priscilla, Philippa, Diana etc. appear, act as realistically conceptualised individuals with both positive and negative characteristics, and also has them make their share of mistakes (such as for example how Anne Shirley at times a bit callously approaches and deals with Gilbert Blythe, and her acceptance and then rather harsh refusal of Roy Gardiner before finally managing to realise that Gilbert truly is the one for her) being the absolute icing on the cake for me (even though I do sometimes tend to find that episode of Gilbert being ill with typhoid before Anne realises how much she loves him just a bit too much). For what makes the Anne of Green Gables series as a whole and what in my opinion makes especially Anne of the Island so delightfully wonderful and readable, relatable, is how deeply developed and nuanced Montgomery's characters for the most part are, how none or at least how the vast majority of them are never one-sided, are both lovable and sometimes indeed most annoyingly infuriating (that the characters who inhabit the pages of Anne of the Island have been rendered by Montgomery as basically real and breathing, living human beings, individuals whom one can both like/love but also occasionally not stand, a wonderfully both imaginative and realistic reading experience that is like a breath of fresh air and a total personally enchanting and endearing comfort whenever I decide to reread).
April 17,2025
... Show More
"I don't want sunbursts and marble halls. I just want you."

Just going to say right up front: absolutely none of the books in this series can come close to the beauty of the first Anne book. It's a slice of magical, golden childhood and I will defend that book with my life. :')

Secondly: I've literally been shipping Anne & Gilbert since before I even knew shipping was a thing. And they fINALLY have their Moment!!!

"There was nobody else--there never could be anybody else for me but you. I've loved you ever since that day you broke your slate over my head in school."

Oh look, that's me dissolved in a puddle of happy feels.

Other things I liked:

- The writing style is soft & unassumingly lush. It's such a comforting & homey thing to get lost in.

March came in that winter like the meekest and mildest of lambs, bringing days that were crisp and golden and tingling, each followed by a frosty pink twilight which gradually lost itself in an elfland of moonshine.

- Avonlea is like a second home to me now.

- Phil is a riot and she injected so much life into this story.

- All the college/change-related stuff was super relevant to my life right now. I know exactly how Anne feels watching all her old friends get in relationships and feeling left out. It's so hard to articulate, but this has been happening to me a lot & I relate to Anne's dread of changing relationships. You desperately want things to remain the same, familiar way they always did. But people (and relationships) change . . . and that's a hard thing to accept.

- Patty's Place is the coziest little home imaginable. I want that to be my new dorm room, please and thank you.

- Marilla getting all sentimental and nearly making me C R Y. (Also, I still miss Matthew, terribly. <3)

- I know I already mentioned this, but Anne and Gilbert. They were probably my first OTP, and they finallyyyyyyyyyy get together by the end of this book. I wanted to shake some sense into Anne because it took her the entirety of college to figure out she liked him. *facepalm*

- I just feel so light and happy reading L.M. Montgomery's books. I'm sure this doesn't need any explanation.

Things I didn't like:

- Not enough of all the "classic" Avonlea characters (Marilla, Diana, Gilbert, etc.). They're like family to me, and I missed them. I like the new "school chums" that Anne makes, but I almost feel like Anne's friendship with Diana is forgotten. :/

- OKAY. So. Rant time. This is the major reason I docked off an extra star. I'm a huge animal lover, so the one chapter where they try to freaking chloroform a cat they couldn't take care of??? I. Was. So. Upset. I don't care that it's a different time period. I don't even care that they were "trying to not cause the cat pain." THAT'S NO EXCUSE.

I know people are probably rolling their eyes right now. Like, "Seriously, Mary, it's supposed to be funny. Stop making such a big deal out of nothing."

Well, I'm sorry, but I fail to see any humor in the fact that they actually tried to kill an animal they couldn't take care of. That's never okay, and it made me so furious & disturbed. It seemed so out of character for Anne, and worse, it was never portrayed in a negative way.

If you can't keep an animal . . . find someone who will be able to. I don't know how anyone can justify this.

*deep breath* I'm sorry, but despite how much I love these characters, that chapter was sickening.

- It could get a little boring at times & it lacked the magic of the first book. But that's mostly just because I was pining for all of Anne's hilarious antics and adventures with the classic Avonlea gang.

Overall? This was a delightful, transportive experience. L.M. Montgomery never fails to make my heart thrill with nostalgia and happiness. This may not be the standard of golden perfection that Anne of Green Gables is, but it was a much-needed book for this period of my life.

3.5 stars
April 17,2025
... Show More
I just love this one! The last scene has got to be my favorite of all!!
April 17,2025
... Show More
Reread for a reading vlog: https://youtu.be/Z-1p0hIp-Ng (watch for both a spoiler free and spoiler filled review of each of the eight books in the series - spoilers are all clearly marked and easily skipped!)


Written review to come ❤️


You can find me on...

Youtube | Instagram | TikTok

You can join our book club over on Patreon...

PBB Book Club
April 17,2025
... Show More
This is going to be short and sweet. As with the previous two books, I thoroughly enjoyed this installment in the story of Anne Shirley’s life. Here, we see Anne attending college and fighting against the assumptions of others regarding her love life. She makes new friends and a new home and watches as old friends and Green Gables begin to change. It’s hard growing up and seeing that life doesn’t stay the same, and Anne struggles with this. She also struggles with her love life. There’s a bit of a love triangle here, which I always hate, and Anne is downright silly and ignorant in her desire to not love a particular someone, but everything works out right in the end. As with all of these books, there’s lots of humor, and a multitude of profound statements. I love the mix of depth and levity Montgomery is able to produce with such deftness. Although I didn’t enjoy this book quite as much as the two before it, it’s still a lovely story. I’ve never made it beyond this book in the eight-book series, so I’m excited to see what happens next!
April 17,2025
... Show More
خوندن از زندگی دخترای جوون پر شور و حالِ دانشجو برای آدمی که دلتنگ دوره ی دانشجوییشه یه لذت دیگه‌ای داره.
قشنگ مزه اش زیر زبونمه. چقد خوبه که برای چند سال هم که شده تجربه ی دور از خونه بودن رو تو کارنامه دارم و با خوندن این کتاب تک تک روزای خوشش جلوی چشمم اومد. تموم اون دور همی‌ها، گردش‌ها، درس خوندن های شب امتحان توی سالن مطالعه ی شلوغ خوابگاه

چ لذتی داشت همسفر شدن با آنی توی ایام تحصیلش توی ردموند. و درک کردن همون حد از شادی آنی وقتی تعطیلات به گرین گیبلز برمیگشت با یادآوری خاطره های سفر های چند روزه ی دوماه یک بار به خونه‌ ی خودم

مونتگومری، چقدر خوب شد که فهمیدی باید قلم دستت بگیری و شخصیتای توی ذهنتو زنده کنی. لطف زیادی به آدمایی مثل من کردی که عاشق چشیدن همین لذت های کوچیکن.
April 17,2025
... Show More
It's a sad reminder how times change when you approach the bookstore with a gleam in your eye of rediscovering a childhood favorite only to find that they no longer carry it. That was my recent experience where instead of finding Laura Ingalls Wilder and L.M. Montgomery I found vampires, sorcery, and scantily clad teenagers glaring at me from overly bright and shiny bookcovers.
I will not claim that the Anne series is monumental fiction but it was too me. I wonder if youth today are getting in their own reading what I so very much treasured in the books of my childhood. In twenty years will they fondly remember those manga (?) books or recall the great vampire trend? Will they be the ones saying how times have changed? Probably.
I love Anne. She is simple and complex she is delightful and innocent. I would love to be just like her minus the red hair. She lives in beautiful environments and has an amazing time wherever she goes.
I guess there will always be crud sold as literature which is what I called all those books taking over the precious spots my Anne should have been in, but wasn't it I who loved R.L. Stines Fear Street series twenty years ago too? And isn't it I who have wonderful memories of reading that crud as a kid? I guess so.
April 17,2025
... Show More
5 / 5 ⭐

totalny Comfort read, nie dziwie sie, że tyle osób wychwala ten tom. Kocham Anie, kocham Diane, Gilbert to mój książkowy crush. Ta książka jest tak pełna ciepła, przygód i pięknych myśli!
April 17,2025
... Show More
Anne of the Island - LM Montgomery - #3 in the Anne of Green Gables Series - 5 Stars

Ya'll I loved this one so much! Anne goes on a new adventure as she packs her bags and heads for Redmond College. We see Anne really making her own choices and living life with friends and I just loved seeing her realize there was still good things to come in her next stage of life. I love the secondary characters and Davy made me laugh so much with his questions to Anne. I also love Anne and Gilbert SO much! Excited to read the next one.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.