Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 98 votes)
5 stars
28(29%)
4 stars
38(39%)
3 stars
32(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
98 reviews
April 25,2025
... Show More
She gave him her 'girdle', did she? A little something to remember her by, hmmmm? Personally, I found it rather hard to believe that a hound dog like Gawain would pass up the opportunity, but I did ultimately enjoy this humorous tale of chivalry and self-imposed cockblockery. Green Knight rules!
April 25,2025
... Show More
Though I have read this little tale twice now, and have been enchanted both times, I fear I have very little to say about it. The plot combines traditional tropes together in such a way that the story is instantly memorable; and the double action of the knightly pact and a bedroom temptation seems to neatly summarize the twin pillars of chivalric morality—manly combat and womanly tenderness. Literature professors can argue endlessly about the finer symbolism of the book; and general readers can, with a suitable translation, enjoy an adventure story. Both camps are satisfied, and the book’s place as a classic is thus guaranteed.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a rich and beautiful work. This chivalric romance kept me guessing and made me ask questions. That's something I always appreciate in any work of literature. I remember many of its scenes vividly, but some aspects of it are blurred in my mind. If I remember well, I read more than one version of this work and found different renderings interesting. Whose version did I prefer? What copy was my favourite one? Did I attempt to read it in original? Sadly, I don't remember. I did enjoy it a lot and I even wrote papers on it. That much I do remember. Another classic I clearly need to reread before attempting a longer review. I need to dig up my old textbooks and handbooks, I know I will find at least one copy of this chivalric romance in some of them.
April 25,2025
... Show More
A foundational legend that has influenced many other works. One of the best examinations of what chivalry was meant to represent...and for that reason a very important work. One has to marvel at the time and effort that was spent pursuing knighthood; one wonders what Europe would look like if this group had not shaped sociopolitical issues associated with the formation of nations.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is another great read for one of my English classes. I honestly love being able to read classic literature and hearing someone else's thoughts on it. I like seeing if I had the same understanding or if I was "way off" (per say, literature can be subjective).

This one was not my favourite but it was pretty cool. I always wanted to venture into some King Arthur and Camelot stories, so this one fit the bill. While it's not my favourite, it was very interesting to read it!

There's a lot going on in this book depending on how you read it. Sir Gawain maybe being a coward or following the time's ideal hero trope. The sexual aspect of it. The ties of animals and how the heroes and villains act. Throw in the cool alliteration (depending on the translation you get), and it makes for one epic tale. It's all so interesting. And then, you know, maybe it was just meant to be a story and all of the themes weren't intended to be there?

Either way, I found Sir Gawain to be a more humanistic character than in other classic hero fiction. Sir Gawain seems like he fought for Arthur because he was the only one who had the guts to do it - not because he wanted too. He almost chickens out, avoids his problems for a bit and is actually scared. This romance doesn't feel as epic because he isn't the warrior prince we are all expecting, but instead he's a scared knight just doing his best. That's what I find super interesting about it. I didn't enjoy it as much, and maybe that's because he was... human? He acted reasonably and how we expect people to act? It's so strange.

If you get the chance, I recommend reading this and then finding some translations or explanation videos. Seeing all the different ideas about this work really made it stand out for me and make me enjoy it more!

Four out of five stars.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a medieval poem by which a one of the stories of Arthurian legend is told. It concerns Sir Gawain, youngest Knight of the Round Table who is also King Arthur's nephew. On a New Year's Eve, a strange green knight enters the court of King Arthur and challenges the knights in to a "beheading game" which challenge, sir Gawain accepts. According to the challenge by the green Knight he was to be beheaded by his axe and whoever accepts the challenge to expect the same return in a year and a day. Sir Gawain beheads the green Knight and he retreats with his severed head informing sir Gawain to meet him in the green chapel on the stipulated day. The story progresses as sir Gawain journeys to the green chapel to meet his fate. And on this journey, his honour and loyalty is tested.

I'm interested in the legend of King Arthur and his Round Table but cannot recall to have read any other than childhood fables; so this work really piqued my interest. I read the poetic translation and it was quite interesting to read the verses while a story of courage, strength of character, honesty and loyalty is unfolded. The story was good enough though not great as I expected. But I'm happy to have read a proper Arthurian story after all.
April 25,2025
... Show More
n  Shame be to the man who has evil in his mindn

Written c. 1375, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is an Arthurian quest fantasy. It has all the elements that make such a fantasy work, the brave and redoubted knight, the alluring lady, the magical and mysterious stranger (after all, the Green Knight is able to have his head removed and then hold it in his hand while it talks to you), the ranging quest and the moment of truth.

The poetry is so beautifully written; it sings. I do not know, but I imagine, this poem being recited to a gathering, perhaps at court, much as Homer sang his poems to the Greeks. To the possible chagrin of my husband, I read this aloud to myself. It seemed to demand it.


April 25,2025
... Show More
Well, I might be a little cruel in this review, but I truly have not enjoyed this work at all. I am aware that it is popular and that I should take into consideration the context at the time of its publication and how it stands in comparison to its contemporaries, but that does not mean I cannot criticize a few things.

I have encountered many problems while reading it and almost dropped it. For starters, the plot is boring and could have been way shorter. Also, the introduction of characters is not interesting and kind of awkward. Neither the protagonist, Sir Gawain, nor the antagonist, The Green Knight, has caught my attention. I really could not care if they live or die.

Moreover, the challenge that The Green Knight has put on the table—that is, daring the knights to ax him and be axed by him—is foolish to even think of accepting, yet Sir Gawain does because it would be an act of cowardice not to do so. Anyway, The Green Knight lives after being beheaded (because of some magic as we later learn) and the"bold" protagonist travels to the place in which he would be killed by The Green Knight.

On his way, he finds a castle out of nowhere and stays there for some time before traveling to his final destination. When he arrives, however, The Green Knight does not kill him (surprise, surprise! Here I had to act as if I were shocked). Now, do you know why he does not behead him in return? Well, it is because Sir Gawain has not slept with The Green Knight's wife, who also turns out to be the very same lord of the castle! Yet, The Green Knight does give him some beating for not giving him a green girdle which he received from The Green Knight's wife.

Well, why would The Green Knight expect something from Sir Gawain? Good question! The answer is because he decided to play a game with Sir Gawain in which the lord would go hunt and give whatever he gets to Sir Gawain who in return should give him whatever gift he gets during his stay at the castle. Now, what did Sir Gawain give him most of the time? Kisses! He kisses the lord because the lord's wife kisses him after rejecting her endless approaches to seduce him!

I know that epic poems and any work at the time, in general, focused on morality and that this epic poem is no exception and is supposed to teach us about the importance of loyalty and "chivalry", but it is not for me (I could not believe it when I finally reached the final page! What a torture!). The role of women here is one of the worst I have read and the characters, overall, are dumb.

All in all, I believe that this literary work is overrated. I thought of giving it 2.5 out of 5, but no. I do not think it deserves more than 2.

April 25,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight by an anonymous late 14th Century author is a chivalric romance written in Middle English. But you don’t have to be proficient in Middle English to read it as there are several excellent translations available, including some on line.

This is a delightful Medieval poem about the adventures of Sir Gawain, King Arthur’s nephew. The events occur during two consecutive Christmas seasons and involve a jolly green giant, a beheading, a quest, a journey into the wilderness, a magic castle, a beautiful lady, a couple of delightful seduction scenes, a ruse, an unexpected twist, and probably the biggest oops blunder in English literature.

The poet gently exposes the foibles of human nature and the difficulty of living up to courtly ideals with their concomitant code of chivalry. And he does so with sympathy and humor neatly gift wrapped in eloquent diction to celebrate the season.

Highly recommended.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Ahhh this fucking ruled. Gawain was the Green Knight all along––yes that's a spoiler but the book is 600 years old. Wicked hunting scenes and that game with the axe is a real oh shit moment.

Not really an Arthuriana guy, weirdly enough, but wanted to get this one under the belt before that A24 flick drops. Still, maybe they could take a break from making a King Arthur movie every five years and do one (1) movie based on the chansons de geste. Seriously if you liked this shit go dig up a copy of Raoul of Cambrai. I recommend the Michael Newth translation. You can thank me later.

Also highly recommend the BBC In Our Time episode on The Green Knight, which features Simon Armitage, whose translation I read. Link: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000...
April 25,2025
... Show More
145th book of 2023.

Goodreads didn't like me trying to distinguish the translations of this. Firstly, I read Armitage's translation. A few days ago I finished the Burrow edited, but not translated, version of the poem. I found it difficult to get a hold of a copy of the poem that isn't translated into modern English, so the copy I did eventually find in the basement of a library was ugly-covered, but just what I wanted. The edits to the text are merely standardisations of letters. Otherwise, it's original. As a comparison to the original text and Armitage's translation I have chosen one of the passages in which the Green Knight and his steed are described.

n  
And all graythed in grene this gome and his wedes:
A strayt cote ful streght that stek on his sides,
A mery mantyle above, mensked withinne
With pelure pured apert, the pane ful clene
With blithe blaunner ful bryght, and his hode both,
That was laght fro his lokkes and layd on his schulderes,
Heme wel-haled hose of that same grene
That spend on his sparlyr, and clene spures under
Of bryght gold upon silk bordes barred ful rich,
And scholes under schankes there the schalk rides;
And all his vesture verayly was clene verdure,
Both the barres of his belt and the blithe stones
That were richly rayled in his aray clene,
Aboute himself and his sadel upon silk werkes.
That were to tor for to telle of trifles the halve
That were enbrawded above with bryddes and flyes,
With gay gaudi of grene, the gold ay inmyddes.
The pendauntes of his payttrure, the proud cropure,
His molaynes and all the metail anamayld was then,
The stiropes that he stode on stayned of the same,
And his arsouns all after and his athel skyrtes,
That ever glemered and glent all of the grene stones.
The fole that he ferkes on fyne of that ilk,
Sertayn,
A grene horse grete and thik,
A stede ful stuf to strayne,
In brayden brydel quik,
To the gome he was ful gayn.

-

And his gear and garments were green as well:
a tight-fitting tunic, tailored to his torso,
and a cloak to cover him, the cloth fully lined
with smoothly shorn fur clearly showing, and faced
with all-white ermine, as was the hood,
worn shawled on his shoulders, shucked from his head.
On his lower limbs his leggings were also green,
wrapped closely round his calves, and his sparkling spurs
were green-gold, strapped with stripy silk,
and were set on his stockings, for this stranger was shoeless.
In all vestments he revealed himself veritably verdant!
From his belt-hooks and buckle to the baubles and gems
arrayed so richly around his costume
and adorning the saddle, stitched onto silk.
All the details of his dress are difficult to describe,
embroidered as it was with butterflies and birds,
green beads emblazoned on a background of gold.
All the horses's tack - harness-strap, hind-strap,
the eye of the bit, each alloy and enamel
and the stirrups he stood in - were similarly tinted,
and the same with the cantle and skirts of the saddle,
all glimmering and glinting with the greenest jewels.
And the horse: every hair was green, from hoof
to mane.
A steed of pure green stock.
Each snort and shudder strained
the hand-stitched bridle, but
his rider had him reined.
n


126th book of 2023.

This is a wonderful, poetic and lively translation by Armitage. I know the story well enough, so I was really reading for the translation and the poetic licenses. Well worth it. Even just the journeying parts of the poem are written beautifully. I've got a few other translations kicking about that I'll read soon and then return here to compare them. This is an excellent place to start.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.