...
Show More
What can you say about this book that has not already been said? What a huge creative power Tolkien had, that he could create such beautiful worlds (especially the Elves and the Ents are sublime). Basically, of course, it's about the classic struggle between good and evil, about real friendship and sacrifice, perseverance and courage. But it remains well-balanced and beautifully laced with a layer of sophisticated humor and introspection, a blissful panoramic epic that in many ways is reminiscent of the Iliad and the Odyssey, but with its own, slightly medieval references.
Some minor critical comments?: 1. the many songs of course are specific to those imaginative worlds, but unfortunately "work" not so well in ours; 2. women hardly come into the picture and if they do, they hardly transcend the archetype of the virtuous courtly Lady; only in the annexes Tolkien corrects this image slightly.
Ultimately, it is the diversity in the world of the Ring that most enchanted me: all those kinds of people, elves, hobbits, orcs, wizards, etc. with their own language, customs and history, their great and small flaws and defects. It's a rich variety which engenders wonder and interest. The most hopeful message the book gives is that Tolkien illustrates that even those different types beings can find "common ground" and make life more livable. What a glorious performance!
Some minor critical comments?: 1. the many songs of course are specific to those imaginative worlds, but unfortunately "work" not so well in ours; 2. women hardly come into the picture and if they do, they hardly transcend the archetype of the virtuous courtly Lady; only in the annexes Tolkien corrects this image slightly.
Ultimately, it is the diversity in the world of the Ring that most enchanted me: all those kinds of people, elves, hobbits, orcs, wizards, etc. with their own language, customs and history, their great and small flaws and defects. It's a rich variety which engenders wonder and interest. The most hopeful message the book gives is that Tolkien illustrates that even those different types beings can find "common ground" and make life more livable. What a glorious performance!