...
Show More
don't like it. full stop.
i have nothing against Dekker really. but i would suggest him to really study the religion before he tries to write about it. nothing in the book shows the way a Muslim live.
first, Muslims take each of the five pillars seriously. not one is less important than the other.
second, no religious man would have commit violence against woman. if he do, that means he is not a religions man. simple. (an uncle kicking his niece until she is being admitted into the hospital for a week, where are her parents anyway?)
third, no Muslim woman (a good one) will touch a man (which she is not married to, unless it is her father, brother or son), yet alone kiss him. (Miriam had done with her boyfriend and Seth)
forth, a Muslim is not allowed to and won't drink wine, scotch or any alcoholic drinks. period.
fifth, Muslims won't sentence a punishment on anyone without proof or witness. to blindly punish others is just plain ridiculous. no one with wits will do that.
sixth, everything that is being portrayed in the story is the lifestyle of the Arabs thousands years back. it does not show the current Arabs at all.
seventh, no Muslim woman would be able to feel comfortable without her veil let alone wearing a fitted dress.
so in conclusion, miriam does not portray islam at all. she acts more like a filthy rich teenage american girl whom run away across the globe using the first flight when she disagrees with her parents.
i admit that Dekker wrote the story with just the right choice of words and suspense. he is a good story teller. i guess being a Muslim I couldn't help feeling uncomfortable being stereotyped that way. worse, the wrong way. it'll be nice if he could write the story with less ethnocentrism.
Seth. i like Seth. despite his refusal to admit God, i like his wit. i was feeling, if he really is a genius, why is it so hard for him to see that God exists? it is a simple math. we have a smart phone, wouldn't the smart phone creator would be smarter? he is a genius. why couldn't he figure it out? he even had came out with a mathematical equation which supposed to convince him that God exists.
anyway, i have a complicated feeling about this book. it is a mess of frustrating ideas and content. but i'll give thumbs up for the pace and diction.
i have nothing against Dekker really. but i would suggest him to really study the religion before he tries to write about it. nothing in the book shows the way a Muslim live.
first, Muslims take each of the five pillars seriously. not one is less important than the other.
second, no religious man would have commit violence against woman. if he do, that means he is not a religions man. simple. (an uncle kicking his niece until she is being admitted into the hospital for a week, where are her parents anyway?)
third, no Muslim woman (a good one) will touch a man (which she is not married to, unless it is her father, brother or son), yet alone kiss him. (Miriam had done with her boyfriend and Seth)
forth, a Muslim is not allowed to and won't drink wine, scotch or any alcoholic drinks. period.
fifth, Muslims won't sentence a punishment on anyone without proof or witness. to blindly punish others is just plain ridiculous. no one with wits will do that.
sixth, everything that is being portrayed in the story is the lifestyle of the Arabs thousands years back. it does not show the current Arabs at all.
seventh, no Muslim woman would be able to feel comfortable without her veil let alone wearing a fitted dress.
so in conclusion, miriam does not portray islam at all. she acts more like a filthy rich teenage american girl whom run away across the globe using the first flight when she disagrees with her parents.
i admit that Dekker wrote the story with just the right choice of words and suspense. he is a good story teller. i guess being a Muslim I couldn't help feeling uncomfortable being stereotyped that way. worse, the wrong way. it'll be nice if he could write the story with less ethnocentrism.
Seth. i like Seth. despite his refusal to admit God, i like his wit. i was feeling, if he really is a genius, why is it so hard for him to see that God exists? it is a simple math. we have a smart phone, wouldn't the smart phone creator would be smarter? he is a genius. why couldn't he figure it out? he even had came out with a mathematical equation which supposed to convince him that God exists.
anyway, i have a complicated feeling about this book. it is a mess of frustrating ideas and content. but i'll give thumbs up for the pace and diction.