...
Show More
There were some interesting facts but mainly a dry, boring read. Which is unfortunate, because I read the book in the hopes of getting some ideas or discussion topics for Harry potter week at my library.
Ease Reading-Find Your Next Favorite Book
Continuum Contemporaries
J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter Novels: A Reader's Guide
...
Show More
Continuum Contemporaries will be a wonderful source of ideas and inspiration for members of book clubs and readings groups, as well as for literature students.The aim of the series is to give readers accessible and informative introductions to 30 of the most popular, most acclaimed, and most influential novels of recent years. A team of contemporary fiction scholars from both sides of the Atlantic has been assembled to provide a thorough and readable analysis of each of the novels in question. The books in the series will all follow the same structure:a biography of the novelist, including other works, influences, and, in some cases, an interview; a full-length study of the novel, drawing out the most important themes and ideas; a summary of how the novel was received upon publication; a summary of how the novel has performed since publication, including film or TV adaptations, literary prizes, etc.; a wide range of suggestions for further reading, including websites and discussion forums; and a list of questions for reading groups to discuss.
-
Genres
nonfiction
96 pages, Paperback
First published October 26,2001
This edition
- Format
-
96 pages, Paperback
- Published
-
September 26, 2001 by Continuum
- ISBN
-
9780826452320
- ASIN
-
0826452329
- Language
-
English
About the author
...
Show More
Books include Keywords for Children's Literature Second Edition (co-edited with Lissa Paul and Nina Christensen, NYU Press, 2021), Was the Cat in the Hat Black?: The Hidden Racism of Children's Literature and the Need for Diverse Books (Oxford UP, 2017), Crockett Johnson and Ruth Krauss: How an Unlikely Couple Found Love, Dodged the FBI, and Transformed Children's Literature (UP Mississippi, 2012), Keywords for Children's Literature (co-edited with Lissa Paul, NYU Press, 2011), Tales for Little Rebels: A Collection of Radical Children's Literature (co-edited with Julia Mickenberg, NYU Press, 2008), The Annotated Cat: Under the Hats of Seuss and His Cats (Random House, 2007), Dr. Seuss: American Icon (Continuum, 2004), The Avant-Garde and American Postmodernity: Small Incisive Shocks (UP Mississippi, 2002), J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter Novels: A Reader's Guide (Continuum, 2001), and Crockett Johnson's Barnaby (five volumes, co-edited with Eric Reynolds, Fantagraphics, 2013-2024).
Readers also enjoyed
Community Reviews
Rating(3.7 / 5.0, 7 votes)
5 stars
2(29%)
4 stars
1(14%)
3 stars
4(57%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
7 reviews All reviews
...
Show More
It only covers books 1-4, but this is an early attempt by a professor of Children's Literature to examine the literature and cultural phenomenon of Harry Potter. The compendium of reviews he gleans are shocking in their blatant ignorance and the main point that Nel argues forcefully for is that Harry Potter is not solely children's literature, despite prestigious prizes such as the Whitbred designating it as such. The point is only hammered home by the fifth through seventh books, which are defiantly adult literature.
...
Show More
I found this on the shelf in our library and saw that Philip Nel wrote it. His critiques and analyses of children's literature are interesting and understandable which is why I grabbed it. Because only books 1-4 are covered in this reader's guide, it feels incomplete. The last two chapters I skimmed as well because are somewhat outdated looking at reviews. The copyright is 2001. Of course, if you want a snapshot in the midst of Pottermania, then it gives just that. As in the past, I liked Nel's analysis as I knew I would. His writing is clear and well-supported. The beginning gives personal background information on Rowling and shows how her early activism can be seen in the books, as well as, having to deal with a mother that had multiple sclerosis. Rowling was influenced by different authors growing up and Nel shows their influences in the Potter novels. The different people who influenced her life over the years also make an appearance in various characters and these are pointed out.
While I appreciated the mystery elements when I first read the series I didn't tie it into activism. The power that the characters wield comes through "unofficial networks" while the media or government officials tend to be corrupt. As the books continue Nel points out how the question of power becomes more complex as characters explore the morals of power positions and the exercising of authority. When Harry chooses not to kill Pettigrew after learning he killed his parents, there is the morality of Harry's choice that makes his decision more complicated and wrought with emotion.
I particularly liked how Nel articulated the ambiguity of the characters in the books. It is one of the appealing aspects and gives characters more complexity. Even Severus Snape, who seems like a one dimensional villain, shows depth by the last book. There is no index in the book and it is short, only 96 pages. If you are teaching the books or having a book club then it would help with discussions.
While I appreciated the mystery elements when I first read the series I didn't tie it into activism. The power that the characters wield comes through "unofficial networks" while the media or government officials tend to be corrupt. As the books continue Nel points out how the question of power becomes more complex as characters explore the morals of power positions and the exercising of authority. When Harry chooses not to kill Pettigrew after learning he killed his parents, there is the morality of Harry's choice that makes his decision more complicated and wrought with emotion.
I particularly liked how Nel articulated the ambiguity of the characters in the books. It is one of the appealing aspects and gives characters more complexity. Even Severus Snape, who seems like a one dimensional villain, shows depth by the last book. There is no index in the book and it is short, only 96 pages. If you are teaching the books or having a book club then it would help with discussions.
...
Show More
Interesting analysis of the Harry Potter novels. Although I still don't think they are best written or the best I've read in the genre, I have a new-found appreciation for them.
...
Show More
a few nice titbits here
...
Show More
I found this in the library by accident. Although it was published so early only to discuss Harry Potter books 1 to 4, it was really interesting to read about both the books, and the novelist, and the impact of the books. It gave me so new good ideas.
...
Show More
Some useful insights and a decent set of further reading recommendations (particularly of fantasy and children’s fiction that may have influenced or with which the HP series appears to have parallels).
There are a few errors (factual and typos) and a lot of references to crap newspaper reviews discussing the ‘phenomenon’ of the series and its potential for longevity in readership. The scholarly analysis is rather limited but it is a decent introduction to some overarching themes in books 1-4.
There are a few errors (factual and typos) and a lot of references to crap newspaper reviews discussing the ‘phenomenon’ of the series and its potential for longevity in readership. The scholarly analysis is rather limited but it is a decent introduction to some overarching themes in books 1-4.
Leave a Review