...
Show More
Four stars might seem a bit on the generous side, but overall, I truly liked the story and never once felt the urge to give up on it. Although, to be honest, when I first started reading, I wasn't entirely sure if I'd be able to get fully engaged.
I have lived in the NYC area for a significant portion of my life, and I must say that the settings in this book were extremely well done. Even though I haven't actually been to Montauk, the author's description made me feel as if I was experiencing a visit there during the off-season. It's a definite plus that a large part of the action takes place outside of Manhattan.
Discussing the characters is a rather tricky task. Her parents have been long dead, and her sister never makes a direct appearance in the story. It's perhaps a bit of a spoiler, but it's unavoidable to mention. It's fair to say that what Suzy believes she knows about them is shown to be shockingly incomplete. Later information fills in the gaps that never made sense to her before. The relationships with married older men, in my opinion, were a bit tedious, although they weren't the central focus of the main plot. The secondary characters, on the other hand, were well-developed and not reduced to cardboard stereotypes.
For me, it was quite difficult to fully separate the setting from the plot in this book. However, the author does an excellent job of using the former to advance the plot from one location to another. Watching the mystery unfold is a bit like those crime shows with their whiteboards filled with notes and pasted clues that gradually become cluttered. Here, though, they all come together almost suddenly, like a lightbulb going off, near the end. In retrospect, the book is almost like two stories: an immigrant saga followed by a suspense thriller.
I want to offer a piece of advice to future readers. If you find the slow pace of the story frustrating, keep in mind that Suzy's sister, being older, was more aware of what was going on, which helps to explain her rebelliousness and hostility.
So, would I recommend this book? Yes, but only if it's approached as a novel first and foremost, rather than a full-length suspense thriller.
I have lived in the NYC area for a significant portion of my life, and I must say that the settings in this book were extremely well done. Even though I haven't actually been to Montauk, the author's description made me feel as if I was experiencing a visit there during the off-season. It's a definite plus that a large part of the action takes place outside of Manhattan.
Discussing the characters is a rather tricky task. Her parents have been long dead, and her sister never makes a direct appearance in the story. It's perhaps a bit of a spoiler, but it's unavoidable to mention. It's fair to say that what Suzy believes she knows about them is shown to be shockingly incomplete. Later information fills in the gaps that never made sense to her before. The relationships with married older men, in my opinion, were a bit tedious, although they weren't the central focus of the main plot. The secondary characters, on the other hand, were well-developed and not reduced to cardboard stereotypes.
For me, it was quite difficult to fully separate the setting from the plot in this book. However, the author does an excellent job of using the former to advance the plot from one location to another. Watching the mystery unfold is a bit like those crime shows with their whiteboards filled with notes and pasted clues that gradually become cluttered. Here, though, they all come together almost suddenly, like a lightbulb going off, near the end. In retrospect, the book is almost like two stories: an immigrant saga followed by a suspense thriller.
I want to offer a piece of advice to future readers. If you find the slow pace of the story frustrating, keep in mind that Suzy's sister, being older, was more aware of what was going on, which helps to explain her rebelliousness and hostility.
So, would I recommend this book? Yes, but only if it's approached as a novel first and foremost, rather than a full-length suspense thriller.