Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
37(37%)
3 stars
32(32%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

Demian is a remarkable semi-autobiographical novel penned by Hermann Hesse. By fusing his own personal experiences with the theories of psychoanalysis put forth by Carl Jung, the philosophy of Nietzsche, and the tenets of Eastern Mysticism, Hesse crafts a captivating tale of Emil Sinclair's arduous journey from the "world of illusion" to the "world of reality".


Emil Sinclair endures a naïve childhood in a world of illusion, wholeheartedly believing in the conventional morality he was indoctrinated with. A simple childish lie subjects him to the cruel clutches of a bully, who forces him to commit acts that are considered "crimes" according to Christian morality. Sinclair leads a wretched existence, constantly repenting for his sins. However, his encounter with Max Demian, an older student at his school, alters the course of his life forever. For the remainder of Sinclair's life, Max Demian becomes a powerful influence and guide. He not only liberates Sinclair from the bully's grasp but also frees him from the constraints of conventional morality, teaching him to embrace unconventional thoughts (the "world of darkness") as an integral part of human nature. Demian imparts to Sinclair the profound lesson that both God and Demon reside within a man, and it is up to the individual to grapple with the inner Demon and strive to raise the self towards God. This teaching challenges the notion that a man can be governed solely by external forces such as good and evil as defined by conventional morality, and instead emphasizes the importance of the deeper inner spirit.


Sinclair's path to discovering the "real world" is fraught with difficulties. It is obscured by the illusory world dictated by conventional morality. These social rules, deeply influenced by Christianity, bind humans so tightly that breaking free seems almost impossible. Demian's teachings shatter Sinclair's once-secure world of illusion, leaving him confused and rebellious. He embarks on a self-destructive path but is ultimately saved by two intermediate mentors. Demian's return to Sinclair's life marks his ultimate salvation, and together with his mother, Frau Eva, Demian awakens Sinclair's mind to the possibility of self-realization.


The story abounds with symbolic representations. Hesse's vivid description of psychoanalytic theories comes alive through a symbolic narrative inspired by Christian theology. Even the characters of Max Demian and Frau Eva can be seen as symbols. In numerous instances, Demian is depicted as Sinclair's deep inner self, while Frau Eva represents his feelings of love and longing for physical intimacy, symbolizing Sinclair's sensuality. Another possible symbolic interpretation is that Demian and Eva represent Sinclair's masculine and feminine elements respectively. In ancient times, it was believed that achieving harmony between the masculine and feminine aspects of oneself was essential for supreme spiritual attainment. I believe that both Demian's death and his kiss to Sinclair on behalf of his mother at the moment of his death symbolize the attainment of complete masculine and feminine harmony within oneself. When one achieves this inner harmony, the door to self-realization swings open.


The novel is replete with thought-provoking philosophical content. The themes explored are truly impressive. The experimental writing style, with its symbolic narrative, is beautiful yet not the easiest to understand. I cannot claim that the story was particularly engaging from start to finish. Nevertheless, it possesses the power to elevate the readers' minds to new heights and dimensions.


More of my reviews can be found at http://piyangiejay.com/

July 15,2025
... Show More
Nobody told me this would be kinda gay?


This simple sentence holds a certain sense of confusion and surprise. It seems that the speaker had an expectation that was not met, and they are expressing their shock or disbelief.


Perhaps the situation they are referring to was something they thought would be different. Maybe it was an experience, a relationship, or even a task that turned out to be not what they anticipated.


The use of the word "gay" in this context might not necessarily refer to sexual orientation. It could be used in a more colloquial sense to mean something that is unexpected, strange, or not quite right.


Overall, this sentence leaves us wondering what exactly the speaker is talking about and what led them to have this reaction. It also makes us think about how our expectations can sometimes be disappointed and how we need to be open to new experiences and perspectives.

July 15,2025
... Show More
There are two worlds: the world of good and the world of evil.

The world of light and the world of darkness.

We are constantly bombarded with stories of the lost boys, the prodigal sons, who have strayed from the path of good. I devoured these tales, fascinated by the idea of a return to the father, to what was right and good. In these stories, the liberation that came with repentance was always magnificent.

However, I also found myself drawn to the part of the story that took place among the lost and evil souls. There was something exciting about that world, something that made me reluctant to see the lost soul repent and be found again.

We live in a world of duality. Dichotomy is present in everything. There is the apparent world and the secret world. The world of pride and the world of humility. The world of Cain and the world of Abel.

One day, on a walk with my father, I asked him about the people who thought Cain was better than Abel. He was surprised by my question and explained that this interpretation was not new. It had emerged in the earliest centuries of Christianity and was taught in various sects, one of which called itself the “Cainites.”

But, he said, this teaching was insane and nothing but the devil’s attempt to destroy our faith. If we believe that Cain was in the right and Abel in the wrong, then we are saying that God was in error, which means that the God of the Bible is not the one true god.

There is the world of creators and the world of creatures. We dwell in the material world and abide in the world of psyche. There is the world of verity and the world of hypocrisy.

At the end of class, Demian said something that made me think. “There’s something I don’t like about that story, Sinclair. Read it through again and test it out on your tongue. There’s something about it that leaves an insipid taste in your mouth.”

He was talking about the story of the two thieves. He thought that the part about the good thief was a sanctimonious fairy tale, treacly and dishonest, insipid and sentimental and obviously didactic.

There are two worlds: the world without and the world within. We must learn to navigate both if we are to find true meaning and purpose in life.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Hermann Hesse, aside from my admiration for him, this book on the other hand... Demian is an extraordinary book, a novel! To tell such an interesting and unique feeling so qualitatively throughout 200 pages, to immortalize such a deep feeling that I thought was mine in my youth and that I experienced with my close friends, to tell it with such a quality language, fluency and clarity should be the nirvana of writing. I highly recommend that you read it. It made me even more of a fan of Hermann Hesse, made me reexamine my humble writing efforts, and made me think hard about how to reach these levels, the summit.

This book truly has a profound impact. It takes the reader on a journey through the complex emotions and experiences of youth. The way Hesse crafts the story and the characters is simply masterful. The language he uses is both beautiful and accessible, making it a pleasure to read.

I believe that anyone who reads Demian will be touched by its message and will come away with a new appreciation for the power of literature. It is a book that will stay with you long after you have finished reading it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Herman Hesse's classic 1919 bildungsroman is a captivating tale. It tells the story of a young boy who, with the help of a mysterious friend, over the years, achieves self-realization and a form of spiritual enlightenment. This is the kind of book that Hesse's fans have cherished for generations.

On a good day, I can walk across the room without dragging my knuckles, and thus, Hesse's ubiquitous themes of Jungian duality and psychoanalytical philosophy can be explored and appreciated. In fact, Demian might be more accessible than Hesse's other classics like Siddhartha and Steppenwolf, which both delve into similar themes. Demian is representative of Hesse's canon as we witness a protagonist grappling with his own identity and his place in a society that is either hostile or ill-suited for his individuality.

Although it may be a stretch, I also noticed comparisons with the 1996 Chuck Palahniuk novel Fight Club. I couldn't help but wonder if Palahniuk drew inspiration from Hesse. While Max Demian is a unique character, in both works, we see the central protagonist being strongly influenced by a more worldly mentor, almost like a metaphysical guide to the real world.

For Hesse's fans, this book is a delight, and it could also serve as a great introduction to his work for new readers.

description
July 15,2025
... Show More
Demian is a remarkable bildungsroman that delves deep into Jungian concepts. It explores the collective unconscious and how religion and spirituality are its ancient relics. The major archetypes are not only applied to selfhood but also to the broader aspects of social thinking and behavior. Hesse's masterful handling of these themes results in a narrative that is both captivating and complex. As a psychology graduate, I was truly fascinated by this book. After learning more about Hesse's life and works, I was even more in awe. If I have the time and motivation, I will write a separate discussion on how analytical psychology is integrated into the text.

This book forces us to look inward and question our long-held beliefs and conformist behaviors. It challenges traditional nationalism and myopic interpretations of religious dogma. Through the process of individuation, it shows that good and bad are not separate but part of a whole. Hesse's prose is simply stunning, being both hypnotic and natural, and as rhythmic as a heartbeat. There were many times when I was left breathless by a particular passage or paragraph that spoke to me on a deep level. It's that feeling when your eyes seem to move on their own, greedily devouring the words and savoring every bit of insight and emotion they evoke.

View this review on my booksta!

\\n  “The more single-mindedly the world concentrated on war and heroism, in honor and other old ideals, the more remote and improbable any whisper of genuine humanity sounded.”\\n


4.5 but an easy round up to 5.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A book that matures the central hero through inner struggle, through light and darkness, through what one must and what one wants.

It is a story with a first-person narrative and inner monologues that somehow reminded me a lot of the wizard of Fouls.

The hero in this book embarks on a journey of self-discovery and growth. He faces numerous challenges and obstacles that force him to confront his deepest fears and desires.

As he navigates through the complex web of light and darkness, he begins to understand the true nature of himself and the world around him.

The first-person narrative and inner monologues add a layer of depth and authenticity to the story, allowing the reader to truly connect with the hero's experiences and emotions.

Overall, this is a highly recommended book that offers a unique and engaging exploration of the human psyche.

It is a must-read for anyone interested in stories of personal growth and transformation.

Highly recommended without hesitation.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Demian is truly an incredibly beautiful book!!!

It contains profound and thought-provoking ideas that have the power to change one's perspective on life.

The quote "If you hate a person, you hate something in him that is part of yourself. What isn't part of ourselves doesn't disturb us" is just one example of the deep wisdom found within its pages.

It makes us reflect on our own emotions and relationships, and forces us to confront the parts of ourselves that we may not want to see.

Demian takes the reader on a journey of self-discovery and personal growth, and it is a book that can be read and reread, each time revealing new insights and understandings.

Whether you are looking for a beautiful and engaging story or a book that will challenge and inspire you, Demian is definitely worth reading.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I bought it and read it more than ten years ago. At that time, I didn't understand it well and it remained on the shelf for a long time, hoping that the day would come when I would read this work again and understand what I hadn't understood for more than a decade.

And that day finally came. Do you think I understood it? Never, by my condition and by God.

Despite that disappointing result, I am fully aware of the uniqueness and distinctiveness of this work. The idea of the struggle of man between good and evil amazed me. But the idea was presented in a more symbolic and serialized form than I could grasp.

And after that, please talk like the ones in the parentheses if you don't mind
July 15,2025
... Show More
Hesse writes a story about the adolescent Sinclair who has a friendly relationship with Demian - as the book is titled.

Demian presents the adolescent with a different world that deviates from the one he knew until now. The reevaluations as well as the concerns regarding the Good and the Evil begin. The hero is led to self-awareness and lays the foundation for the transition from adolescence to adulthood.

Hesse is influenced by Analytical Psychology and examples of it can be found on the pages of his work. This book, as I mentioned at the beginning, I liked quite a lot both because I came into contact with the thoughtful writer and because I read a book that presents the difficult stages of adolescence with all its problems such as the use of alcohol, the questioning and rejection of the family environment, sexuality.

It is a profound exploration of the human psyche during a crucial period of life, offering valuable insights and引发读者对自身成长经历的思考.

The vivid descriptions and the complex characters make the story engaging and thought-provoking, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The book started off well, but as time passed, its charm and appeal diminished in my eyes.

Perhaps the author's emphasis on highlighting the non-domestic aspects of the work, such as the importance of self-awareness, the conflicts a young person experiences between family life and what they encounter in society, the absence of absolute good and evil, and so on, made me not enjoy reading it as much.

I dare to claim that I had a hard time reading the last 50 pages.

Perhaps if I were to read this work in a different time and period, it would have been a different experience for me.

July 15,2025
... Show More

So Hesse has the remarkable ability to initially seize your attention with an extremely captivating, interesting, and promising start. It's as if he casts a spell that draws you in, making you eager to explore further. However, somewhere in the middle, he seems to manage to lose you. The story that once held such promise starts to meander or perhaps becomes a bit too convoluted. And as for the ending, I suppose it'll either leave you completely mesmerized, in awe of his genius, or disappoint you, leaving you with a sense of unfulfilled expectations.


The thing is that I couldn't relate after a certain point. Trust me, I had every kind intention to love this book since I had adored Steppenwolf. But Demian was nothing like it. It was different not only in regards to the prose, which lacked the same lyrical beauty and depth that I had found in Steppenwolf. But also in terms of the theme and context. It felt like a completely different world, one that I struggled to connect with on a deeper level.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.