Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
33(33%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Since the sixth installment of "A Song of Ice and Fire" has not yet been released, I delved into its beginnings with these excellent science fiction tales. And it's no wonder they won the Hugo Award.

In each of them, we are quickly immersed in well-constructed stellar worlds. But moreover, the stories are not only exciting for their fiction but also handle the emotional planes. It speaks of love, but under metaphysical conceptions and explained under criteria that within the story, humans fail to understand. It speaks of other solitudes, of magic and the belief in strange events... It speaks of everyday feelings but transported to other worlds.

These tales offer a unique blend of imaginative settings and profound emotional explorations. They take us on journeys beyond our own reality, allowing us to experience new perspectives and emotions. Whether it's the wonder of discovering a new planet or the heartbreak of a lost love in a distant galaxy, these stories have the power to captivate and move us.

Overall, they serve as a reminder of the limitless possibilities of science fiction and its ability to touch our hearts and minds.
July 15,2025
... Show More

I think it is a good book. However, since it is a compilation of stories, it is clear that there will be some better than others. In my opinion, the best one was the one that gave the title to the book. It had a unique charm and a captivating plot that kept me engaged from start to finish. The characters were well-developed and the writing style was very流畅. I also liked the other stories in the book, but this one stood out the most for me. It made me think about life and爱情 in a different way. Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys reading short stories.

July 15,2025
... Show More
It's a rite of passage for all young science fiction writers to take on a few well-known tropes. The loneliness of the universe can drive men crazy. The mutated aftermath of nuclear war is another common theme. And then there's space football.

George R.R. Martin adds his own unique touch to these tropes (and also includes a few surprises) in this collection. While not all the subject matter is entirely groundbreaking, the stories are well-written and generally inventive. Some of the standouts are:

"With Morning Comes Mistfall" - This is a parable about the human desire to either solve or disprove all the mysteries of life. It might be a bit obvious, but the subject matter really speaks to me. And as I mentioned, Martin's writing is excellent.

"Override" - This story is about a workforce of zombies and the men who love, or rather, maintain them. It's an exciting action-packed tale.

"A Song for Lya" - This story is both poignant and thought-provoking. It's a great exploration of a trope that I didn't mention earlier: telepathy.

To be honest, this collection is probably a solid 3.5 stars. But I'll give it a boost if only because of that magnificently strange and psychedelic cover.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Cuentos de la edad de oro de la ciencia ficción. Pero no los mejores. Estos cuentos son una muestra de la riqueza y la diversidad de la ciencia ficción en aquel período.


Aunque no sean los mejores, todavía tienen mucho que ofrecer. Algunos cuentos presentan ideas innovadoras y fascinantes, mientras que otros exploran temas clásicos de la ciencia ficción de una manera única.


Además, la escritura en la edad de oro de la ciencia ficción era a menudo muy buena, con una narrativa atrapante y personajes bien desarrollados. Aunque no todos los cuentos son perfectos, son una parte importante de la historia de la ciencia ficción y merecen ser leídos y disfrutados.

July 15,2025
... Show More
He has good stories, but there are 3 that almost put me to sleep:

1) And seven times I say: Thou shalt not kill man

2) The black darkness of the tunnels

3) Nor the multicolored flames of a stellar ring

The rest are indeed entertaining.

However, it's important to note that everyone has different tastes when it comes to stories. What one person finds soporific, another might find fascinating. Maybe these particular stories didn't resonate with me due to their themes or writing styles. But that doesn't mean they're not good stories in general. It's just a matter of personal preference.

Nonetheless, I still appreciate the author's effort in creating these stories. There are always elements that can be learned from, even in the ones that don't quite hit the mark for me. And who knows, maybe upon a second reading, I might discover something new and interesting in those "soporific" stories.
July 15,2025
... Show More
For the first time in Spanish, we can enjoy those short works of Martin venturing into science fiction, with no less success than he did in epic fantasy.

Each of the stories in this anthology is a profound philosophical and existential debate, in the best style of Isaac Asimov. The metaphysical analysis of the human species reaches a density that is only possible in the genre of science fiction due to its power of abstraction, whether in alien, robotic, or inexplicable science forms, which generate a wonderful, contrasting otherness, and that Martin exploits wonderfully (especially in "A Song for Lya", the short novel that gives the book its title), moving us to tears, knocking down structures, mobilizing, and inviting the most intimate reflection.

Martin's foray into science fiction is a welcome addition to his already impressive body of work. His ability to craft complex and thought-provoking stories is on full display in this anthology, and readers are sure to be captivated by his unique vision of the future. Whether you're a fan of science fiction or just looking for something new and exciting to read, this book is definitely worth checking out.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The stories presented in this history are extremely great and also predictable.

However, it is not the kind of prediction that makes you bored to know, but rather the kind that makes you terrified to know. Sometimes it happens, sometimes it doesn't happen, and that makes the story very exciting.

In addition, social issues of our world are inserted into the science fiction worlds that Martin created. Sincerely, it is exceptional. I really loved it a lot.

The way Martin weaves these elements together is truly remarkable. His ability to create vivid and engaging fictional universes while also addressing real-world concerns is a testament to his talent as a writer.

The predictability aspect adds an interesting layer to the stories, keeping the reader on the edge of their seat, wondering if and when the predicted events will actually occur.

Overall, this history is a must-read for anyone who enjoys science fiction and thought-provoking storytelling.
July 15,2025
... Show More
George always presents remarkable ideas in his work. However, these ideas may not resonate with everyone.

I find myself unable to resist appreciating the elements in Sci-Fi books that have nothing to do with Sci-Fi itself. For instance, the exploration of relationships, be they platonic or romantic, is truly captivating.

Admittedly, some parts might seem rather corny. But considering the scope of the story, it's hard to envision how else these aspects could have been explored.

I also ponder the extent of overlap between the Grieshka of this world and the Children of the Forest in ASOIAF. This comparison offers some fascinating perspectives that I intend to apply when rereading that series in the future.

Overall, it's a solid read, deserving of a 4/5 rating.

July 15,2025
... Show More

La neblina se pone por la mañana. I really loved it. I found it to be very sensitive. It's about the contrast between science and the mysteries of life. 4/5


Por un solo ayer. It was beautiful. I think it's one of my favorites. I could feel the sadness of the character. 5/5


Ni las llamas multicolor de un anillo estelar. At first, it was a bit difficult for me, but when I understood it, I found it to be profound and very touching. 4/5


Una canción para Lya. It was impactful and disturbing. I finished it and it left me full of questions and reflections. Did I enjoy reading it? Not so much because I suffered a lot while reading it, but the quality of the story deserves a 5/5


El héroe. It was predictable. I didn't feel any compassion for the character. 2/5


Y siete veces digo: al hombre no mataras. I think it tried to cover too much and that's why it didn't work. I liked the story of the jaenshi and the seller more than the other one. I got bored and lost at times. 2/5


Esa otra clase de soledad. It was beautiful, about solitude and everything else. 4/5


La presentación. It was boring. I don't even remember how it ends. 2/5


La negra oscuridad de los túneles. I would have given it more development. I don't know, it didn't engage me. 2/5

July 15,2025
... Show More
I really like stories like the first one in this collection.

There are also a couple more that are a wonder.

The first story captured my attention from the very beginning. It had a unique plot and interesting characters that made me want to keep reading.

As for the other stories, they too had their own charm.

Some had beautiful descriptions that painted vivid pictures in my mind, while others had unexpected twists that kept me on the edge of my seat.

Overall, this collection of stories is a great read.

It offers a variety of different types of stories that are sure to appeal to a wide range of readers.

Whether you're a fan of mystery, romance, or adventure, there's something in this collection for you.

I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good book to read.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Pues... esperaba más de estos relatos.

I had high expectations for these stories. However, I have been quite disappointed because the endings are not very good. They are predictable and almost all end without surprises.

Out of all of them, only one appealed to me, "Esa otra clase de soledad" (That other kind of loneliness), precisely because the ending was a rather good twist and in line with what a short story should be.

The ones in "Una canción para Lya" (A song for Lya) and "Y siete veces digo: Al hombre no matarás" (And seven times I say: You shall not kill a man) seemed long and heavy to me.

Nevertheless, Martin's writing is simple and agile, and it leaves you wanting more. A lot more. It's a pity about the abrupt endings with so little charm.

In the end, 2 stars out of 5 and thank you.

Overall, I had hoped for more engaging and unexpected stories. While Martin's writing style has its merits, the lackluster endings really detracted from the overall experience. I will still keep an eye on his work in the future, hoping for better things.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Once again: stories are not really my thing.

Leaving aside Lya's story, which I quite liked despite the usual clichés and the CF, the level seemed weak to me compared to others by Martin. Out of the 10 stories, in fact, I liked four or five.

Well, that's it, to read more about Martin. I already said that Lya's story is very good, I would read it even if it were only that one.

However, I still feel that Martin's other stories lack a certain depth and originality. Maybe it's because I have read too many of his works and have become a bit jaded. But I do hope that in the future, he can come up with something more innovative and exciting to keep his readers engaged.

Overall, while I enjoyed some of the stories in this collection, I don't think it's one of Martin's best works. But I will still continue to follow his writing and see what he has in store for us next.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.