Community Reviews

Rating(3.8 / 5.0, 59 votes)
5 stars
15(25%)
4 stars
20(34%)
3 stars
24(41%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
59 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly appreciate his viewpoint. The emphasis on high quality ingredients is of utmost importance as it significantly impacts the taste and overall experience of the dish. The interesting matches he presents add a unique and exciting element to the cooking process. Additionally, the concept of seasonal eating is not only beneficial for the environment but also ensures that the produce used is at its freshest and most flavorful. The simplicity of his approach is also quite appealing, as it allows for a more natural and uncomplicated cooking style.

However, it must be noted that achieving these ideals can come at a significant cost. This makes it difficult for me to use this cookbook on a regular basis. Nevertheless, I still thoroughly enjoyed reading it as it provided me with valuable insights and inspiration for my own cooking adventures.

Overall, while this cookbook may not be practical for my daily use, it has certainly left a lasting impression on me and has broadened my perspective on cooking.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have rather mixed feelings about this book.

On the one hand, Colicchio is indeed a great chef. His intention of getting readers to think less about specific recipes and instead focus on the ingredients, flavors, techniques, and compositions behind them is quite admirable. It encourages a more in-depth understanding of the art of cooking.

However, on the other hand, I couldn't help but feel that the book was too cursory to achieve complete success. At times, it lacked specificity, and the recipes seemed almost compulsory. As Colicchio himself admits, "my idea of hell is writing down a recipe." That sentiment, in my opinion, is quite evident on the pages.

Moreover, there are editing errors in the e-book, and the photography often employs an extremely shallow depth of field, which can be a bit distracting. Overall, it must be said that food publishing has advanced significantly since this book was released in 2000.

Nevertheless, despite these shortcomings, it is still worth reading, albeit with the sense that it feels somewhat half-baked.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Neither of my library systems has this particular item.

It's quite frustrating as I really need it for my research or personal interest.

I'm wondering if I could borrow it from someone.

Maybe a friend, a colleague, or someone in my social circle might have it and be willing to lend it to me.

I could reach out to them and explain my situation.

It would be great if I could get my hands on it without having to purchase a new copy.

Borrowing from someone not only saves me money but also allows me to access the resource I need in a timely manner.

I'll start making those inquiries and hope for a positive response.

If not, I might have to explore other options such as looking for it in other libraries or online platforms.

But for now, my focus is on finding someone who can lend me this item.

July 15,2025
... Show More
For some reason, I seem to have a great interest in the histories of famous chefs. Therefore, I really liked the first part of this book a lot.

I also read the recipe and teaching content, and it seems quite good. There is definitely some excellent advice and valuable insights. However, I need to have sufficient time in the kitchen to give all of it a try.

I believe that by spending more time with this book and actually putting the recipes and teachings into practice, I will be able to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation of cooking.

So, I will be working with this book more in the future to enhance my cooking skills and knowledge.
July 15,2025
... Show More
To my friends and schoolmates who wonder how I know what I know about cooking:


This book came to me as a present from my brother-in-law. When we're not arguing over baseball and politics, we fight over how to properly braise a roast. I'll only concede defeat in the latter.


Collicchio covers the full range of basic techniques, from roasting and braising to blanching foods. He also shows how to utilize in-season vegetables and unlikely cuts of meat. He explains some great base-recipes for vinaigrettes, fondues, and soup stocks. Further, he reveals how salt, herbs, and proper heat can bring out the best flavor from a dish.


This guy writes like he presents himself on TV. He's a guy who loves to cook as much as he loves beer and motorcycles. But somehow, he finds himself surrounded by gay men, which he takes in stride and as a compliment.


I use this book all the time, and the meals I've prepared have always been crowd pleasers. It's a great starting point for any curious deli enthusiast in the making.


Never eat alone, and only experiment on those you love.


JDC
July 15,2025
... Show More
This book contains a lot of interesting stuff and presents new ways of thinking about using ingredients. It offers unique perspectives that can inspire readers to explore different culinary possibilities.

However, I have to admit that I do find his absolute certainty on some things rather questionable. For example, his insistence on never using high oven heat seems wrong or at least too narrow-minded. There are many recipes and cooking techniques that require high oven heat to achieve the desired results, such as getting a crispy crust on a pizza or a golden-brown exterior on a roast.

By dismissing high oven heat altogether, he may be limiting the creativity and flexibility of the readers. It's important to keep an open mind and consider all the available options when it comes to cooking. While his ideas may have some merit, it's also necessary to question and challenge them to find the best approach for each individual dish.

In conclusion, although this book has its interesting aspects, it's important to approach it with a critical eye and not blindly follow all of the author's opinions.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I am truly enjoying this book and am making steady progress through the roasted tomato recipes.

However, it is important to note that this is not just an ordinary book of recipes. Fans of Top Chef should be aware that this is a cook book that delves deep into the imagination of a cook.

It goes beyond the realm of a standard cook book, offering unique insights and creative approaches to cooking.

The author's imagination shines through in every page, inspiring readers to think outside the box and experiment with new flavors and techniques.

This cook book is not just about following instructions; it is about unleashing your own creativity in the kitchen and discovering new culinary delights.

So, if you're looking for a cook book that will激发 your imagination and take your cooking to the next level, this is the one for you.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is NOT a cookbook.

Yes, it has recipes in it, but that's not the point.

For those of you who can follow recipes well but need help taking your cooking to the next level, this is a good starting point.

Here, you can start creating meals based on what you have available or what looks fresh, and without a set recipe.

Cooking should be more organic and less like chemistry.

This book helps you "think" in a more freestyle/improv way.

Of course, the only way to really learn improv is to do it, do it, do it.

You need to practice constantly to become proficient in creating unique and delicious dishes without relying solely on written recipes.

By following the guidance in this book and actively engaging in the process of freestyle cooking, you can enhance your culinary skills and creativity.

Soon, you'll be able to whip up amazing meals that are tailored to your own tastes and the ingredients at hand.

So, don't be afraid to step out of the cookbook and embrace the world of freestyle cooking.

Let your imagination run wild and see where it takes you in the kitchen.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The great approach to teaching cooking is truly remarkable.

It offers a wealth of valuable information and techniques that can enhance one's culinary skills.

However, having an entire chapter dedicated solely to ramps and morels might seem a bit excessive.

While these are interesting and unique ingredients, devoting such a large portion of the book to them could potentially overshadow other important aspects of cooking.

Perhaps a more balanced approach would be to include ramps and morels within a broader context, along with other seasonal and regional ingredients.

This way, readers can gain a more comprehensive understanding of how to incorporate these special items into their cooking, while also learning about a wider variety of ingredients and cooking methods.

Overall, the teaching approach has its merits, but a slight adjustment in the focus on specific ingredients could make it even more beneficial for aspiring cooks.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I would say that apart from "Cooking By Hand" by Bertolli, this book has had a greater impact on my cooking style than any other book I have ever read. The reason for this is straightforward.

The entire book is centered around techniques rather than recipes. It's not the kind of book where you can simply pick it up, look up a particular ingredient like "lobster," and then immediately start following the recipe. Instead, you need to read the entire first part of the book, which focuses on cooking techniques. This way, when Tom instructs you to "pan roast" the lobster, you will have a precise understanding of what he means.

You will be guided through each technique step by step, and he even provides some troubleshooting tips for you, warning you about potential common mistakes that could occur during the process.

If you are looking to enhance your home or professional cooking skills and truly take your cooking to the next level, I cannot recommend this book highly enough. It offers a comprehensive and detailed exploration of cooking techniques that will undoubtedly help you become a more confident and skilled cook.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I just received this wonderful gift for my birthday, and I have to say that I am truly enjoying it so far :D.

It's like a little treasure that has brought a lot of joy to my life.

Every time I use it or look at it, it makes me smile.

I can't wait to explore all the features and possibilities that it offers.

Whether it's for entertainment, work, or just to pass the time, this gift has already become an important part of my daily routine.

I'm really grateful to the person who gave it to me and I know that I will cherish it for a long time to come.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This is not so much a book filled with Tom Colicchio's recipes as it is a book that delves into how he thinks about food, or more precisely, how he combines ingredients to create delicious dishes.

There is a section dedicated to technique, another on making stocks and sauces, and then comes the really interesting part. One section poses questions about what to do with roasted tomatoes, mushrooms, and artichokes. He asks these questions to illustrate the process of taking a single ingredient and transforming it into an entire meal.

The next section showcases three examples of how three ingredients that are in season at the same time can work together harmoniously: asparagus, ramps, and morels; lobster, peas, and pasta; duck, roast vegetables, and apples.

Following that is a section on what Colicchio refers to as "components," in which he elaborates on those vegetables that pair best with particular proteins.

The last short chapter is a sort of miscellaneous collection that includes lemon confit. I once published a recipe for Mulligatawny soup to be made the day after Thanksgiving by simmering the turkey carcass to make stock and salvage the remaining meat from the bones. I detailed how to strain the stock, cool the carcass, and pick off the remaining meat to build the spicy soup. However, a good friend, Bernie Faubel, gently pointed out that the recipe failed to mention adding the shredded turkey meat back into the soup. How embarrassing! Alas, it seems that Tom has a similar issue with his recipe for lemon confit. It lists the ingredients and provides instructions for using each one except for the extra-virgin olive oil. It is unclear what one is supposed to do with it or at what stage in the several-day recipe it should be added. Also, the photographs of the chef/author on the dust jacket make him look a lot younger than the person who hosts "Top Chef" on television.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.