Starting with the beginning, I was truly confused as to what was going to unfold in the story. I didn't expect in the first few chapters what I would actually be reading. From the outset, I liked Matt's character. She managed to capture the imaginative mind of a child, but that seems to be all that she can relate to, which is likely why the writing is rather terrible. As Matt grows older, everything becomes obvious. His character also begins to turn into somewhat of a jerk, and I despised his character throughout the rest of the book.
Once Matt is brought to the Big House, everything becomes clear. Especially when El Patron treats Matt like a savior, because that's precisely what Matt is. It's evident from the moment you meet El Patron that he is a manipulative dictator, and you know he will die. You can anticipate him saving Matt and then expecting Matt to save him. I knew which characters were going to die, and I knew what the characters were going to do. I even caught on to the poisoning and understood why when Celia began poisoning Matt. And throughout the book, the evident manipulation was all that fueled my frustration at the dumb character who might as well be another brainless clone.
I did, however, enjoy that the book was written in the third-person narrative. Simply because it provided me with more details as to how Matt's brain was developing from a psychological point of view, given the treatment he received from the simply boring family members. Additionally, Matt is the only character that receives any kind of development throughout the book. Sure, Tam Lin has his back story, but he remained the same throughout the entire novel. This lack of development creates a boring and uneventful atmosphere that makes everything predictable, resulting in a bad plot. While I will admit that the elements of dystopia, manipulation, power, and the overall theme of stereotypes help the plot, it's all ruined by the lack of excellent writing that should have been the cherry on top.
One can tell that the author did her research. The intertwined cultural thematics thickened the world that was created, giving it a sense of realism. However, it's sad to see something with so much potential turn out to be as bad as "House of the Scorpion" was. I hope that I never have to see another great story thrown away due to bad writing and an unadvanced plot. Also, there were so many instances where there were deaths or events that in no way made any difference to the book. Like Tam Lin's death was no sort of sacrifice; it was pure suicide. There was also no reason to write the dialogue in Spanish and then write the same thing in English. That isn't realistic as no one just speaks the same thing in multiple languages for no reason, and it's extremely aggravating. I'm disappointed that I had to waste my time on this for school, and I hope that someone will realize what a waste of time this novel truly is.
Woah!
I know I was supposed to finish this book during fall break, but I'm actually really happy that I didn't put this book down. It was so engaging and captivating that I just couldn't stop reading.
The story was full of excitement, adventure, and interesting characters. I was completely immersed in the world that Nancy Farmer created.
Now that I've finished the book, I'm eagerly looking forward to reading the sequel. I can't wait to see what happens next to the characters and how the story will unfold.
Thank you, Nancy Farmer, for writing this awesome book. It has truly been a great reading experience.
Ok, first off this book was really weird. It gets a 4.5 stars rating. When it came to picking out our science fiction book, this one really stood out. A clone developing inside a cow's womb? What on earth? It took us quite a while to get into the book, trying to figure out exactly what was going on. Matt's adventure was both heartbreaking and heartwarming. Some people loved him, but that number was very few, and others downright hated him.
Throughout the book, someone was always out to get Matt. Once one threat stopped, there would always be someone else. At his age, this really shouldn't be happening, but since he's the clone of the most powerful drug lord, he's born with these rivals and opponents. He was beaten and starved when he was about 5-6, all because he was a clone. Even though this is set in a completely different world, human feelings on certain subjects never change. The family that Matt is trapped in was raised to hate clones and treat eejits with disrespect as if they weren't human as well or at least once human.
For those of you who have read this, you know what I'm talking about. (WARNING - This part will only be understood by those who read The House of the Scorpion. If you find yourself confused, read the book. If you are also afraid that you will find spoilers, I've done my best to not say any, but if you find any of this (which I promise you isn't), don't say I didn't warn you).
1. The feelings in this book are all over the place. The ones you really want to hate (like El Patron), you can't, but then you know when you hate a certain someone (Tom) because there is no reason to like them. Whatever Matt felt was reflected onto me and most of the time it was pain or a mix of feelings. In fact, unlike most books, you don't have one or two feelings on the events, this one had several. Every time we talked about the book, we would all mentally scream about what just happened and how to feel about it.
2. The characters were phenomenal and never disappointed. They played their parts perfectly and at some points were confusing to understand their intentions. Most of our discussions were about the relationships between two characters and how they developed or how we thought they would develop. Some of the characters even surprised us with something new.
3. You never knew what was going to happen next. There were plot twists everywhere and as much as some were like "Oh My God, why didn't I think of that", others were like "Wait What???" Even as a group, our lit circle group couldn't predict what was going to happen next. It was perfect.
4. Everything fell into place. Like I said in number 3, there was always twists and turns, but that never meant that everything didn't fall into place after the fact. For one thing, we never expected Felicia or Tam Lin to do what they did, yet it all makes sense in the end. There wasn't any cliffhangers that left you in the dust, but it still makes me want to read the sequel none the less.
5. This has to be the strongest kid to ever live. How on earth did Matt survive for that long living in such a horrible world? It was the worst environment for a child to grow up in, yet I think Matt turned out just fine. He had to go through being starved and beaten, and then moved up a little to constant remarks that he's just livestock. Plus with everyone around him that not only hate clones, but also hate who he was cloned from. So he's born with not only people fearing him, but also out to get him. Matt was just strong through the entire thing. How did he do it? Well, I still have no clue.
Okay, let's all be honest here. Who else was annoyed by Maria in most of the book? She had her good times of course. (Especially when she told Matt that she loved him) But that was towards the end. At the beginning, she liked Matt then she hated Matt and didn't want to talk to him. It does all come down to Tom though, and everyone hates him. Yet even after he beat Matt, who was left defenseless, with a peashooter and she still forgives him, that's a problem. I was so happy when she finally realized what a horrible person Tom was because if she didn't, I would have slammed my head into the desk and thrown my book at the wall.
Nobody likes Tom, and if you do, well please reconsider.