I read it simply because Kevin Smith was the writer. The man is undoubtedly a die-hard comic fanboy. However, his tribute to a character who was killed off years ago is astonishingly rich and full of depth. I read it from cover to cover twice in a row. It's really that good.

Of course, like almost any comic book, it has its typical flaws. But it seems to be an inherent part of the medium. Only the darkest story lines seem to be immune (such as Dark Knight Returns and A Death in the Family). Then again, it's been years since I read them, so perhaps there are pages or panels that would make me wince nowadays!

I do have some complaints. But I find that I can't express them without also demanding significant changes in the structure and moral of the story arc. I'm not the biggest enthusiast of hell dimensions and alternate realities (like those in Doctor Strange). But to tell this story, they seem to be essential elements. The writing is rather wordy. But if you didn't anticipate that, you probably shouldn't have picked up the book in the first place.

As a non-Green Arrow fan initially, I can truthfully say that I was engrossed in the story within just a few pages. And now I'm curious about how many other works he appears in. I vividly remember his appearance in 'Dark Knight Returns' with what seems to be a different outcome regarding the whole decision of cutting off his arm to disarm the bomb on the airplane, which plays a crucial role in this book.

I've been intending to read this book for approximately a decade now. A comic book by Kevin Smith - what could be better? However, this book was somewhat dated by two factors: pop culture references and the New 52. Regarding the first aspect, although some of the references might seem a bit passé, at least I can claim that I think I understood all of them. As for the New 52, well, this book was written about 8 or 9 years before the DC reboot. Many of the characters are both mature in age and within their storylines. By this, I mean that numerous things have occurred, including "being bad" and "dying" for many, many heroes. Since almost all of my recent reading has been within the New 52 universe, this book has to rely more on its own merits rather than being part of a larger universe (unless I can discover other DC books from the early 2000s).

This book contains everything one would anticipate from a Kevin Smith project - both the good and the bad. I truly appreciate how Queen's life is not only more intricate but also more complex, giving the impression that this is indeed a book for adults. The main drawback is that Smith can be overly verbose. After all, this is a superhero story, and it would be nice if there were more action to accompany all of the oratory.

While the story was somewhat interesting,

it failed to truly engage on a deeper level. The art, unfortunately, was lacking,

lacking the finesse and detail that could have brought the scenes to life.

The villain, too, was somewhat uninteresting,

lacking the complexity and charisma to make him a truly memorable antagonist.

Moreover, the entire experience was pretty short, easy, and simple.

It seemed to exist in a vacuum, in no way connected to the real world.

As a result, I probably wouldn't recommend it.

There are simply too many other options out there that offer a more fulfilling and engaging experience.

Whether it's a story with a more intricate plot,

artwork that leaves you in awe, or a villain that you love to hate,

this particular offering just doesn't measure up.

It may have its moments, but overall, it fails to make a lasting impression.

This thing really goes off the rails completely quite quickly.

It seems as if everything just spirals out of control in an instant. There is no warning, no hint of what is about to come.

However, on a positive note, the Phil Hester art is really great.

The details in the illustrations are remarkable, bringing the story to life in a vivid and engaging way.

The colors are also well-chosen, adding to the overall atmosphere and mood of the piece.

Despite the chaos that unfolds in the story, the art manages to hold it all together and keep the reader interested.

It's a testament to the talent of Phil Hester and his ability to create something truly special.

Overall, while the story may take some unexpected turns, the art makes it all worth the ride.

GreAt reAd

I vividly remember the moment when this book first hit the shelves. I was so excited that I immediately purchased it. However, as the years passed by, it got lost in the clutter of my bookshelf and I hadn't picked it up to read for a long time. Just recently, I rediscovered it and decided to give it another go. To my pleasant surprise, it was even better than I had remembered. The story was so captivating and the characters were so well-developed that I couldn't put it down. In fact, this book had such a profound impact on me that I named my son Ollie after one of the characters in the book. It's truly a great read that I would highly recommend to anyone.

Lots of fun although dialogue-heavy, and weirdly paced in places. The story plays with some dark themes, but in ways that are often clumsy. At times, it even dips into tastelessness. However, it has enough heart to convince me that it was ultimately well-intended. It's a bit too edgy, in that 90's comic book sort of way.

The excessive dialogue can be a bit overwhelming at times, but it also adds to the charm and authenticity of the characters. The pacing issues, while noticeable, don't completely derail the overall experience. The exploration of dark themes, although not always executed perfectly, shows an attempt to delve into deeper and more complex emotions.

Despite its flaws, there is something endearing about this work. It has a certain energy and spirit that makes it engaging and worth watching or reading. It may not be a masterpiece, but it has enough redeeming qualities to make it an enjoyable and memorable experience.

The majority of this ten-issue run is centered around Green Arrow's return from the dead.

At that time, it was apparently a significant event. However, two decades later, in the post-52 and post-Rebirth eras, it has lost much of its luster.

In a fictional world where characters can come back to life due to rather far-fetched plot devices like "Superboy punches," spending ten issues attempting to justify Green Arrow's resurrection seems like a lot of unnecessary effort.

It's as if the creators were simply going through the motions without adding much real substance or excitement to the story.

Perhaps in the context of the time, it made more sense, but from a modern perspective, it comes across as a bit dated and uninteresting.

Overall, while Green Arrow's return from the dead was a big deal then, it fails to hold the same level of interest in the present day.

Well, THAT was an extremely wild ride.

I couldn't help but laugh almost throughout the first few issues. They were truly hilarious, and then it took an even wilder turn.

I had read some snippets of this before, but uncovering the entire story was just fantastic.

It most likely merits a big red content warning because in the old days, the Green Arrow comics really delved deep into the nitty-gritty details.

It can be quite confusing at times and has more dialogue than action, except when they're fending off demons.

However, all those Batman jokes? They were absolutely priceless.

(And I will never, ever, be able to get over Supes' 90's hair. It's just too memorable.)

This comic truly offers a unique and entertaining experience, with its blend of humor, confusion, and action-packed moments.

It's a must-read for any comic enthusiast looking for something a little different.

Whether you're a fan of Green Arrow, Batman, or just great comics in general, this one is sure to leave you with a smile on your face.

So, sit back, relax, and enjoy the wild ride that is this amazing comic.

I have a certain fondness for Green Arrow. He may not hold the top spot as my absolute favorite superhero, but I have always regarded him as being really cool in that unique crazy eco-warrior liberal sort of way.

I think that Smith did a rather decent job when it came to bringing him Back From The Dead. After all, one has to consider that it couldn't possibly be all that straightforward, right? It wasn't a story that was so incredibly awesome that it completely blew me away. However, there were a sufficient number of funny quips scattered throughout to keep my attention diverted from the more crazy aspects. And make no mistake, there are indeed some crazy parts. Nevertheless, I have reached a point where I have come to anticipate the crazy from DC. It's almost become a part of their charm, in a strange sort of way.

I continue to be intrigued by Green Arrow and his adventures, and I'm curious to see what other twists and turns his story will take in the future.

This graphic novel

encompasses the first 10 issues of the newly reinvented Green Arrow. It is written by the talented actor/director Kevin Smith.

Previously, Oliver Queen, the first Green Arrow, was killed while attempting a rescue. This book delves into his death and subsequent return.

Kevin Smith skillfully blends urban grit, the supernatural, and the spiritual, creating a unique and engaging narrative.

There is a plethora of other DC heroes making cameo appearances, such as Batman, Etrigan, Black Canary, and The Spectre. Their presence adds depth and excitement to the story.

Kevin Smith also infuses his trademark humour into the book. Some of the dialogue could easily be mistaken for lines from his other works like Mallrats or Dogma.

The story commences with the death of Oliver Queen and then briefly follows Parallax (Hal Jordan) just before his heroic sacrifice to save the world.

Without revealing too much more, it is safe to say that this graphic novel is definitely worth checking out. It offers a fresh take on the Green Arrow character and a captivating storyline that will keep readers hooked from start to finish.

Maybe a 1.5?

Oh boy. I'm 2 for 2 in not liking highly praised, "quintessential" Green Arrow runs. So maybe I just don't like Green Arrow? Or I only like him when he's written by certain writers.

Smith's writing is just way too wordy. It's filled with an excessive amount of quippy remarks and is overall self-indulgent. (I’ve never seen Batman talk and make so many wise cracks in my life. Smith really should not be writing Batman.) In many places, it definitely feels dated. The so-called gay "jokes" and the way the women are written and talked about are quite off-putting. The pacing is also rather slow, probably because of how self-indulgent the writing is. It shouldn't take more than 70 pages to get to the actual plot and action. So much of this could have been told in half the number of overall pages.

However, there are some positives. This is my introduction to Mia Dearden, and I like what I've seen so far.

Regarding the art, it's perfectly fine. But my biggest concern is the page layouts. There's way too much crammed onto one page, and that's the case for almost every page that I can make such a comment about.

My weakness for archers is widely known and it all began when I was a little boy, with Green Arrow and Hawkeye.

Recently, I started watching the TV series Arrow, which led me to revisit some of the original material. I searched online for the best Green Arrow comics and ‘Quiver’ was the only one I could find in my local library. So, it was an easy choice.

I was surprised to discover that Kevin Smith had written the story. I had no idea he collaborated with DC. The artwork, however, felt a bit too 90s for my taste. But I did like the panel sequencing and the story really gripped me. Smith had some courage when writing this as it throws the reader right into the middle of the action and doesn't bother to provide much background. For example, in the Dare Devil comics I've read, one thing that bores me to death is how they always feel the need to tell his story. But here, it's different. The characters enter the scene as if you already know what's going on and who they are. I must admit, I really enjoyed that, even when it meant I wasn't entirely sure I was following. I especially loved the part when he meets his Justice League pals again and they explain to him that he is supposed to be dead. It was brilliant.

Anyway, I quite enjoyed it. But you know me, give me a bearded blond archer who looks like he stepped out of ‘Seven Brides for Seven Brothers’ and I'm happy. Heh.