The lead detective in the Homicide Department of Washington and psychologist Alex Cross discovers that the schizophrenic Gary Soneji is behind a series of bloody mass murders and struggles to capture him. The narration is in the first person by Alex and in the third person. Step by step, he tries to better profile the killer to finally catch him and struggles to understand what message he wants to convey but above all why he leaves so much blood behind! Meanwhile, once again, FBI agent Kyle Craig asks him to solve the Smith case, something that Cross rejects once again, as he did in the previous book, "Jack and Jill". And just when you think the Soneji case is coming to an end, there is a big twist in the detective's life and the first-person narration is taken over by Thomas Pierce, an FBI agent who works in the Behavioral Science Unit, who is called by Kyle Craig to investigate a new mystery that has arisen. Thus, Cross's assistant and close friend, John Sampson, teams up with a very intelligent personality to identify the reasons for the change in the plot (about which I can't say more).
Most of the book deals with the investigation of the Smith case and there the developments are stormy. At first, I wondered why Pierce took over as the lead of the story while I was wondering why we are interested in Smith since the book has a central axis and a very solid one at that. Thomas Pierce has every reason to deal with the Smith case, as his first victim was his own wife, Eloise! Incidentally, I should mention that the solution to the pattern of the murders is not correctly translated into Greek and so the translator had to change the girl's name! Gradually, then, the author begins to show me the first examples of an exciting and thrilling writing style, like the one I knew in his later books. And suddenly, without expecting it, not only do the above and below come back but the Smith case becomes one with the life of Alex Cross! From then on, then, I feverishly turned the pages to see how the events would unfold, how the killer with the alias "Smith" would be identified and how one of the best books in the series so far would end! In fact, it is the first text that made me search online texts to have a complete picture of the plot, to see what would happen to certain characters and how their lives would develop in the next books. I just wonder why the killer had to travel all over Europe and America and not stay only in America, as the pattern he had in mind could be implemented in his own place.
On a personal level, Alex Cross once again shows himself to be tired of the violence he has to face daily, but this time the case is too personal to leave it unresolved. The paradox is that "Smith" imposes himself on his life in an almost heaven-sent and rather fantastic way. The detective's children are growing up while his relationship with the principal of his son's school, Christine Johnson, is completed. This part is quite sensitive, as her husband was murdered in "Jack and Jill" and now she is trying to get back into life with a man she already sympathized with. Her relationship with Cross passes the approval of his family and comes out victorious. To see, will the detective finally manage to be happy? The only negative is that at the end of the book they go on a family vacation to Bermuda and Christine becomes a victim of abduction but neither in the summaries did I read anything about this nor in the next book is anything like this mentioned! The book ends abruptly and I hoped that in the next one the story would start from that point. But no! After all, we'll see along the way what has happened (I hope).
"The Cat and the Mouse" is a continuous hunt with unexpected role and situation reversals, a novel full of unexpected developments, great surprises and plenty of blood, as Smith, one of the two killers in the story, is a surgeon and the author does not spare anatomical descriptions in the murders. It is a very complex story for demanding readers and so far I think it is the best in the series. The character of Cross begins to be solidified, the author has found where he wants to put the weight of the cases and what he wants to say and so here we have a layered, complex narration with twists until the very last page.