...
Show More
I read this book aloud to two 7-year-olds. They liked the story, but chapter books were too difficult for them to read alone. Wow, I really disliked this book, not because of the overall story. How can this be a young adult novel? Note that I haven't seen the movie and didn't know it was a movie. My main concerns with this book are as follows: - Swearing. - Promotion of bullying and lack of bystander awareness. The swearing is completely unnecessary. In no way does a young adult novel require swearing. The author and editor could have easily replaced the curse words with simple words that are better descriptors. Secondly, the bullying depicted throughout the book is unacceptable. The portrayal of the vice-principal is horrifying and makes me even less inclined to recommend this book. The author made a bully a crucial character in solving the problem of the owls at risk. Moreover, the bully was never confronted, held accountable, or taught that his actions were unacceptable. The author tried to "justify" the bully's behavior based on his home situation. The handling of bullying could have been greatly improved, even with some attention from the vice-principal to properly acknowledge and address the experienced bullying. Physical evidence should not be the determining factor in disciplinary action for a bully. As I read the book aloud to the children, I had to emphasize that any form of bullying is not okay. Overall, I think the story was clever, but it could have been better in dealing with the issue of bullying. I would not recommend this book to parents who want their children to be respectful and understand the rules.