I would have given it 3.5 stars but unfortunately, I just couldn't quite bring myself to go up to 4. In my personal opinion, Reynolds Price is truly a master when it comes to writing. He has an amazing talent for creating vivid and memorable characters, and Kate Vaiden is no exception. She is a character that I know I won't forget easily. However, despite Price's excellent writing skills, the story itself just never really had that captivating power to pull me in completely. It didn't reach the point where I was eager to get back to it as quickly as possible. There was something lacking in the overall narrative that prevented me from becoming fully immersed in the story. Maybe it was the pacing or the development of certain plot points. Nevertheless, I still appreciate Price's work and the effort he put into creating this story and character.