Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
28(28%)
4 stars
35(35%)
3 stars
37(37%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
It was extremely difficult to cultivate a great deal of empathy for Kate Vaiden, the eponymous character of this book.

In this charmingly folksy and quintessentially Southern coming-of-age novel, Kate encounters tragedies right from the start that would impede the growth of the vast majority. And indeed, Kate is stymied. She is like a ship without a rudder, moving from one place to another in search of signs.

She is constantly cognizant of the fact that she is causing pain to those who care about her. She lacks self-awareness and changes direction on a whim. As she ages and succumbs to illness, she acquires a modicum of perspective, yet not in a manner that is overly convincing.

Ultimately, it left me with the lingering thought of "What was the point?" This novel, while perhaps having some elements of interest, fails to fully engage the reader on an emotional level and leaves one questioning the significance of Kate's journey.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly had a great affection for this book.

I was completely enamored with the writing style, which was both engaging and captivating.

The story itself was also extremely interesting, keeping me hooked from beginning to end.

However, I must admit that the ending didn't quite reach the level of perfection that would have earned it a 5.

Nonetheless, it was still a very good read and I will definitely be reading more from Reynolds Price.

After having read both Roxanna Slade and now Kate Vaiden, I have come to the conclusion that his talent lies in his ability to give these characters a distinct and believable voice.

As I was reading, I felt as if I really knew these women on a personal level, as if they were real people with their own hopes, dreams, and fears.

This is a testament to Price's skill as a writer and I look forward to seeing what other wonderful works he has in store for us.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The narrator of this award-winning novel is a 57-year-old single woman who is on the verge of meeting the son she abandoned as an infant.

Kate grew up in the 1930s and 1940s in a tightly-knit small rural community. After the tragic death of her parents when she was 11, she was raised by an aunt and uncle who loved her unconditionally.

The author skillfully portrays the speech of a person reminiscing about her life with folksy similes, which gives the reader a vivid sense of time and place. Price presents us with a conflicted and flawed character who is both sympathetic and perplexing at times.

Although I am not a psychologist, I started to question if Kate suffered from PTSD or Reactive Attachment Disorder, as she constantly rejected or abandoned those who loved and supported her, and even seemed to use people.

Despite all the aspects of this book that I enjoyed, I never felt a connection with the narrator. Perhaps it was because she never seemed to be connected to her own story. By two-thirds of the way through, I was already counting the pages until the end. Overall, I would rate this book 3.5 stars.

July 15,2025
... Show More

I vividly remember having a great fondness for this book. However, it has been such a long time that unfortunately, I can no longer recall the specific reasons that made me like it. It is truly a pity as I'm sure there were some remarkable aspects about it. But here's what I suggest. You should take the time to read this book. As you progress through its pages, pay close attention to the details, the storylines, the characters, and the overall atmosphere it creates. Once you've finished reading, I would love for you to come back and share with me your thoughts and insights. Maybe through your perspective and analysis, I will be able to jog my memory and remember exactly why this book held such a special place in my heart all those years ago.

July 15,2025
... Show More

My favorite book that I've read by this author up until now features a truly remarkable and unforgettable female character. She is strong-willed and independent, yet is also haunted by a tragic past that seems to follow her wherever she goes. From a young age, she has endured more than her fair share of heartache and loss, which has seemingly endowed her with an unsettling ability to push away those who cherish and need her the most. As I read through the pages of this book, I was constantly on the edge of my seat, wondering what would happen next to this complex and fascinating character. It was a disturbing read, to be sure, but one that I couldn't put down. I found myself completely invested in her story, and by the end, I was left with a sense of both sadness and admiration for this unforgettable woman.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm not really loving this book. In fact, sometimes I don't even like it. However, I'm going to finish it because it's a book club read.

Kate is increasingly becoming an unlikeable character to me. I keep waiting for her to do something that would spark my sympathy or make me better understand her choices and behavior. But with only 80 pages left, there is still no sign of redemption.

I understand that she had horrible experiences in her childhood. But there seems to be something lacking in the writing that would make me truly feel that those tragedies are the reason she turned out this way.

She appears to be a very confused and selfish character, and the rest of the cast isn't much better. It's quite disappointing, really. I hope that in the remaining pages, there will be some kind of revelation or transformation that will make me see Kate and the other characters in a different light. Otherwise, this will be a rather forgettable read for me.
July 15,2025
... Show More
My initial impression of Reynolds Price’s Kate Vaiden was centered around its unique voice, at least during the first 50 pages or so. I was somewhat uncertain whether the language was truly authentic Southern or Price's modified version. My hunch leaned towards the latter as I had spent three years in North Carolina, specifically Durham, and as far as I could remember, no one there spoke like the characters in the novel. As one of my professors astutely pointed out, "Okay, the voice is great, but you can't build a novel on voice alone. There has to be more." And indeed, she was right. After 50 pages, while the distinctiveness of the voice was a notable achievement, it simply wasn't sufficient. In fact, at times, I found the voice rather irritating.

So, what else did the novel offer?

I came away from Kate Vaiden with one predominant impression, which was related to my own experiences with literature as an adult. As a child, I devoured a wide range of books, from fairy tales to children’s classics like Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Winnie the Pooh, to young adult novels such as The Pigman and Charlotte’s Web, and even crossover children/adult books like The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, and White Fang. As a fourth grader, I could easily read mass market adult literature like Jaws, Carrie, and The Godfather from cover to cover. However, sometime during high school, I lost interest in literature as I developed other interests. I struggled to finish a book, no matter how thin. (For those who know me and might wonder if I "phoned in" my school reading assignments, the answer is no. I read everything assigned to me. My lackluster effort was only for those books I chose on my own in my free time.) From high school until today, I often had difficulty completing an entire novel. Since 1982, I’ve attempted to read Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment five times, yet I never made it past the first twenty pages. When I confessed this to a professor, he suggested that perhaps my difficulties stemmed from my agony over Raskolnikov’s dilemma. I replied, "Who’s Raskolnikov?" You see, I always believed there was something else I could be doing or another (better) book I could be reading. So, I’d inevitably lose my concentration or my thoughts would wander to other, more important things in my eyes.

And this is precisely what Kate Vaiden is about. Our heroine, Kate Vaiden (rhymes with “maiden”), never commits to a single path in life. Just as she begins to develop a relationship or bond with someone or someplace, she bolts. It doesn't matter if it's family, friends, lovers, or beloved pets. There is a trail of hurt in her wake. She has a “the grass is always greener” mentality, much like my experiences with literature. Four years ago, I started Salman Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children. I got to about page 80 and then stopped. My thoughts were, “Well, this is a great book. I’ll get back to it some other time.” (I never did.) The same happened with Somerset Maugham’s Of Human Bondage and Charles Dickens’s David Copperfield.

Kate Vaiden’s inability to commit to a single, concentrated path in her life was both baffling and frustrating. And despite my best efforts to understand, I couldn't glean any clear insight from the book. After each instance of Kate Vaiden’s flights, I thought, “Kate, what the hell are you doing?!?” I guess it’s Reynolds Price’s way of suggesting that men aren't the only ones with commitment issues.

Incidentally, I started reading Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin in 2009. After about 100 pages, I thought the book was great. For some inexplicable reason, I set it aside. It wasn't until 2012 that I finally finished it. But I'm glad I did because it turned out to be one of my all-time favorites. Unlike me, I suppose Kate Vaiden herself never learned. If she had actually committed to one particular path, perhaps she would’ve had a much better life. But some people – and I guess Reynolds Price is implying as much – are self-destructive and, for reasons unknown to them, are prone to making significant errors in judgment.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Forgiveness and acceptance are powerful and profound themes that truly shine through in this deeply moving narrative. The way the story unfolds, it becomes evident that these two elements are not only central to the plot but also to the human experience as a whole. Reynolds Price, without a doubt, stands out as one of the most compassionate authors I have ever had the pleasure of reading. His ability to craft a story that delves into the depths of human emotions and explores the themes of forgiveness and acceptance with such delicacy and authenticity is truly remarkable. Each page seems to be filled with his understanding and empathy for the characters and their struggles. It is this quality that makes his work so engaging and thought-provoking, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have been meaning to read some works of Reynolds Price for a long time! This particular book was my choice for the "Read a book from the decade of your birth" category in the Read Harder challenge.

And I absolutely adored it. The writing was truly outstanding: it was true, clean, with a distinct voice and a strong sense of place. There were countless clever little similes that added depth and charm to the story. I was extremely impressed by how beautifully he was able to write from a woman's perspective. If I hadn't been so aware of who the author was, I could easily have forgotten that this book was written by a man. The character of Kate doesn't seem overly womanly or forcedly feminine. She simply feels real: her sexuality, her relationships, her choices, and her thoughts all ring true.

As an added bonus, Reynolds Price was born in North Carolina and lived there for almost his entire life. Parts of Kate Vaiden take place in Greensboro, which I loved. It added a special local touch to the story that made it even more engaging for me.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Reynolds Price is truly an amazing writer.

He has an extraordinary ability to capture the voices, desires, and moral reasoning of his characters with remarkable clarity.

The book in question is truly striking, written with such empathy and heart that it immediately draws the reader in.

However, towards the end of the book, I unfortunately had to stop reading it because it became too graphic for my taste.

It's a pity because the earlier parts of the book were so engaging and well-written.

If you're looking for a similar read but one that is less graphic, I would highly recommend checking out Roxanna Slade.

Her works offer a different perspective and a more palatable level of description while still maintaining the essence of good storytelling.

Give her a try and see if her writing style suits your preferences.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The story of Kate Vaiden commences when she reaches the age of fifty-seven. At this stage of her life, she harbors a deep hope of reuniting with her son, whom she had abandoned forty years prior when he was just a baby.

The book then embarks on a journey back in time to Kate's childhood. It uncovers the series of events that have shaped her life and ultimately led her to this poignant moment. This is a narrative brimming with tragedy and misfortune. It unveils a young woman who was a hapless victim of circumstance. Time and again, when faced with crucial decisions, she often found herself making the wrong choices.

It is a truly heartbreaking story, masterfully crafted by Reynolds Price. His writing weaves a tale that is both engaging and deeply moving, drawing the reader into Kate's world and making them feel every emotion she experiences.
July 15,2025
... Show More

I have always been a great admirer of Reynolds Price's books, and this particular one stands out as one of the very best. He is truly one of the finest southern writers, and I am constantly in awe of his remarkable ability to understand women so profoundly.


This is an astonishing story that is set in North Carolina during the early 1900s. It chronicles the life of the main character, Kate Vaiden, from start to finish. While I do struggle with some of the decisions she makes, I can also appreciate how her life experiences have shaped and influenced those choices.


The story takes us on a journey through Kate's joys and sorrows, her loves and losses. We see her grow and change over the years, facing challenges and overcoming obstacles. Price's writing is so vivid and detailed that we can almost picture the landscapes and characters in our minds. It is a truly immersive reading experience that leaves a lasting impression.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.