10 out of 21 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars Description, yes. Plot and characters, no., November 6, 2003
Lawrence Durrell, Justine (Cardinal, 1957)
Well, my two-month struggle with the first hundred fifty pages of the first novel of the Alexandria Quartet has left me with one firm resolution: I will never read the other three (or, probably, any other Durrell).
Don't misunderstand me. Durrell writes truly beautiful prose. The descriptions of Alexandria are lush, extremely detailed, and really give the reader a vivid feel for the city. You can almost sense the heat baking out of the clay as the night progresses.
However, the problem is that aside from Alexandria itself, there isn't a single character in the novel that is worth caring about, and there isn't a plotline worth following. In fact, what little plot there is in the novel appears and disappears randomly, much like a faraway TV signal on an old Zenith black-and-white television. There's simply nothing to do but marvel at the beauty of Alexandria. Which, I suppose, is fine for those folks who take week-long vacations to a particular tourist spot and then spend eight hours a day staring at that landmark as it stubbornly refuses to do anything but just sit there. Perhaps it's a sign of my short attention span, bad breeding, or whatever, but I like there to be at least a minimal amount of action in a novel. If I wanted a book where absolutely nothing happens, I'd read Stephen Jay Gould. (zero)
Uma cidade torna-se um universo quando estamos apaixonados por um dos seus habitantes. It's as if the whole world revolves around that one person.
"(...)«Servimo-nos dos outros como se fossem machados para abater aqueles a quem realmente amamos.»" This statement makes us think about the complex nature of our relationships and how sometimes we might use others unconsciously.
A nossa amizade permitia-nos partilhar as ideias e os pensamentos mais íntimos e compará-los de uma maneira que teria sido impossível se nos encontrássemos unidos por esses laços mais estreitos. It's true that friendship allows for a level of openness and sharing that might not be possible in other types of relationships.
As palavras que os apaixonados empregam às vezes estão carregadas de falsas emoções. Somente os silêncios possuem aquela precisão cruel que lhes confere a verdade. We often express our feelings through words, but sometimes those words might not truly convey the depth of our emotions.
Nessa tarde, fomos passear de braço dado à beira-mar. A nossa conversa foi cheia de fragmentos das nossas vidas sem rumo, sem plano geométrico. It was a beautiful afternoon, and our walk along the beach was filled with random conversations about our lives.
Tik vilinoši sācies. Vēlāk šis darbs mani nogurdināja ar ārkārtīgi gariem mēģinājumiem aprakstīt un psiholoģiski/filozofiski izanalizēt Justīnes personību. Tā arī nespēja viņu ne ieraudzīt ne saprast. Ar citiem tēliem veicās drusku labāk. Tomēr visveiksmīgākā ir sanākusi pilsēta. Vispār romāns par dažu cilvēku toksisku apsēstību eksotiskā pilsētā.
Nākamais romāns ciklā sola Baltazara filozofisko skatījumu uz šo mīlasstāstu. Šaubos, vai tam man pietiks spēka. Pilnā atsauksme https://gramatas.wordpress.com/2017/0....
Beigās pat, apdomājot izlasīto tekstu, nosliecos uz 3 zvaigznēm. Jo autors nav vainīgs, ka man man viņa filozofēšana negāja pie sirds. It all started so intriguingly. Later, this work disappointed me with extremely long attempts to describe and psychoanalytically/philosophically analyze Justine's personality. She also couldn't see or understand her. It went much better with other characters. However, the most successful one has been the city. Overall, it's a romance about some people's toxic obsession in an exotic city.
The next romance in the cycle promises Baltazar's philosophical view on this love story. I doubt if that will have enough strength for me. In the end, even after considering the read text, I'll rate it 3 stars. Because the author is not to blame that her philosophy didn't touch my heart.
When I started reading "The Alexandria Quartet" with very high expectations, I was actually extremely excited. To be honest, the thought of "Will I like it?" kept revolving in my mind when I began the book. Whether it was because of excitement or Durrell's narrative style, I read the first few pages over and over again to understand and be able to enter the book. After all, "Justine" doesn't offer an easy reading experience to the reader. It seems to say, "I will wrap you up beautifully and then let you fall off the cliff with a bang." Suddenly, you find yourself asking, "Which character is telling this at this moment, and what time is it?" The intricate web of events that is woven expects you to read it with the same care. Therefore, I recommend reading the book with full attention. A momentary distraction of the mind can cause you to miss a very poetic sentence.
The book, like it did for other readers, took me to Alexandria during the time I was reading it. I felt the heat on my skin as if I was really there. I wanted to swim and plunge myself into the cool waters here and there. It was like watching a movie, and I brought each character to life in my mind. The physical forms of Justine, Melissa, and Nessim took shape in front of my eyes. I connected with Justine's passion and Melissa's vulnerability as I read. When the book ended, I turned back to the first few pages and read it again. Then everything made much more sense.
Also, the loves, passions, and vulnerabilities in the book took me back to the platonic loves I felt in middle school and high school. :) The strong desire to see, to feel completely by the side, to fall into the void in the absence... Maybe I was very much influenced by it.
Now I'm impatient to read the events from Balthazar's perspective. I've ordered the book, and I'm feeling a melancholy excitement to return to Alexandria again. :')
Having just discarded Dave Eggers’ Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius, I found myself in search of a book that seemed to be making an earnest attempt. A book that was exerting effort, as if it were truly exhausted from渴望 being read. Fortunately, thanks to my friend Michael, who always lends me the more intellectually demanding books, I discovered Lawrence Durrell. Durrell, whose brother Gerald was the author of My Family and Other Animals, a book I grew up watching on the BBC as a child, is the author of the intimidating-sounding Alexandria Quartet. It always resided on my family’s bookshelf at home, but I had always assumed it was something I would never be able to get through. I had always thought I preferred his brother’s writing, you know? Then I picked up Justine and began to read.
Our common actions in reality are merely the sackcloth covering that conceals the cloth-of-gold – the meaning of the pattern. For us artists, there awaits the joyous compromise through art with all that has wounded or defeated us in daily life; in this way, not to evade destiny, as ordinary people attempt to do, but to fulfill it in its true potential – the imagination. Otherwise, why should we hurt one another?
Yep, he’s definitely depressed. But in the most readable and soothing manner. And it’s such an exotic form of depression that you want to be there, experiencing it with him. With all his Middle Eastern sexual ambiguity and the muezzins crying out in the background. This, too, I believe, is a telling detail from his biography:
Wife: Nancy Myers (m. 1935, div. 1947)
Wife: Yvette Cohen (m. 1947, div.)
Wife: Claude-Marie Vincendon (m. 1961, d. 1967)
Wife: Ghislaine de Boysson (m. 1973, div. 1979)
Poor bastard. Four “divorces?” You owe it to his poor wives to at least give his writing a try…