4.5/5 stars
In November 2019:
I had to read this play for graduate school. LOL! I'm upping it slightly to 4.5 stars because I'm growing very fond of it from reading it so often.
In January 2019:
I had to read this one for a class during the winter semester. I still really love this play. As I said before, it's not my absolute favorite, and I think I enjoyed it more when I was in high school. But it was a lot of fun, especially when watching it alongside and comparing it to the 2012 movie adaptation. I still adore Beatrice and Benedick.
In 2018:
This was a reread for me. Although I didn't enjoy it as much as I did when I studied it in high school, I still really loved it! Beatrice and Benedick are Shakespeare's best comic relief. The ridiculousness of the entire play is just so much fun and charming. To be honest, I forgot how dramatic this play was, and it made me remember why I didn't care that much about Claudio and Hero's storyline. Dogberry is also one of my favorite Shakespeare characters. Overall, I feel like this play definitely gets overshadowed by "Midsummer Night's Dream" (which I do agree is better), but it's still such a great and fun comedy!
Much Ado about Nothing, penned in 1598, masterfully weaves together the tales of two distinct couples. The more captivating and undeniably entertaining pair is Benedick and Beatrice. Their past romance seems to have been tumultuous.
Now, in their interactions, they pour all their energy into wittily insulting each other, vying to outdo the other. Beatrice often emerges victorious in these battles of words.
The other romance unfolds between Claudio, a count and a military friend of Benedick's, and Hero, Beatrice's cousin and a wealthy heiress. Claudio returns from war, lays eyes on Hero and her extensive tracts of land (which actually belong to her father but will be hers eventually), promptly decides he's in love, ensures she's her father's only child and heir, and then has his commander, the Prince of Aragon, Don Pedro, propose to Hero on his behalf. Their relationship progresses in a rather oddly public manner. When Don Pedro's jealous and mean-spirited brother, Don John, decides to sabotage their romance for no particular reason, it goes awry in an equally public way.
Meanwhile, all of Beatrice and Benedick's friends are convinced that the war of wits between them masks deeper feelings. In one of the play's funniest plot twists, they decide to trick both of them into believing that the other is in love but will never admit it due to being too hard-hearted. When things go terribly wrong between Hero and Claudio, Benedick is faced with a difficult choice: his old world of male camaraderie or his newly discovered love for Beatrice.
This play is filled with humor, much of it quite risqué if one is familiar with Elizabethan idioms. However, as is typical of Shakespeare, about half of it went over my head, except when I took the time to read the explanatory footnotes in my Riverside Shakespeare volume. Dogberry the constable, who无意间 discovers the plot against Hero but isn't quite sure what to do about it, is one of the highlights, with his constant misuse of words, delightfully and obliviously mangling the English language.
Deception is a recurring theme throughout the play: Don John's deception of Claudio and Don Pedro, everyone's deception of Benedick and Beatrice, Hero's father's deception of Claudio and Don Pedro at the end, and even Benedick and Beatrice hiding their true feelings.
I highly recommend the delightful 1993 film version of this play, starring the wonderful Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson at their best, along with Denzel Washington as Don Pedro, Michael Keaton as the hapless Dogberry, Keanu Reeves as the evil Don John, Robert Sean Leonard as Claudio, and a lovely young Kate Beckinsale as Hero in her film debut.
I really, truly enjoyed my reread of this book a great deal. It was such a wonderful experience to revisit the story and all its characters. However, boy! Do I have some strong feelings about Claudio. He is just the worst. What a poop head he is!
I mean, seriously, his actions and behavior throughout the story are just so frustrating and annoying. He makes so many bad decisions and treats people so poorly. I just can't stand him.
Despite my intense dislike for Claudio, though, I still found the book as a whole to be really engaging and enjoyable. The other characters and the overall plot more than made up for his shortcomings. It's just too bad that Claudio had to be such a pain in the neck.