Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 44 votes)
5 stars
15(34%)
4 stars
14(32%)
3 stars
15(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
44 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm going to place this book within my tub of "dog stories."

However, it's going to require a rather special 4th grader.

This particular child will need to possess the ability to handle Keeper's advanced vocabulary.

The words used in the book are not the typical ones that a regular 4th grader would encounter.

They are more complex and challenging, demanding a higher level of language proficiency.

It will be interesting to see which 4th grader has the skills and determination to take on this literary adventure and fully understand the story despite the advanced vocabulary.

Perhaps it will be a child who loves reading and is constantly seeking to expand their knowledge and vocabulary.

Or maybe it will be someone who has a natural affinity for language and is eager to learn new words and their meanings.

Whoever it may be, they will surely have a unique and rewarding experience with this book.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Being a story for children, it is supposed to be gentle and suitable for their innocent minds.

I must admit that I initially felt a bit taken aback when she called Keeper's mother a bitch in the beginning. It seemed rather harsh and inappropriate for a children's story.

However, aside from that one instance, the rest of the story was actually quite charming. It was told from a dog's point of view, which added a unique and endearing perspective.

The descriptions of the dog's thoughts and experiences were vivid and engaging, making it easy for the reader to empathize with the little creature.

Overall, despite the small flaw at the start, it was still a rather cute story that could potentially capture the hearts of young readers and help them drift off to sleep on those half-asleep nights.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly relished the adult style of writing that was presented.

It had a certain sophistication and depth that made it not only a captivating read for adults but also a great choice for an advanced young reader.

The language used was rich and nuanced, allowing for a more profound exploration of the themes and ideas within the book.

It had the ability to engage the reader on a deeper level, making them think and reflect.

For an advanced young reader, it could serve as a stepping stone to more complex literature, challenging them and expanding their literary horizons.

And for adults, it offered a refreshing and engaging read that could transport them to another world and provide them with an escape from the daily grind.

Overall, it was a book that I would highly recommend to both advanced young readers and adults alike.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is the story of a remarkable dog who has the ability to tell his own tale.

As a tiny pup, he was unfortunately separated from his beloved mother and siblings. This unique dog then had to learn the hard way about surviving on the perilous streets. Surprisingly, he even had a talent for making up poetry.

Along his journey, he managed to find some kind-hearted human friends. He was also presented with the opportunity to win fame and fortune, and was given the name Keeper.

However, through all of this, Keeper could never forget his long lost little sister. He constantly dreamed that if only they could be reunited again, his life would be truly perfect.

But there was an old enemy lurking in the shadows, watching and patiently waiting to make his move. The future of Keeper and his hopes of being with his sister again hung in the balance.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I've been a dedicated fan of Lois Lowry ever since I first delved into Anastasia Krupnik many years ago. Her talent for crafting wonderful children's fiction is truly remarkable. I thoroughly enjoyed this particular book as well. However, despite the way it was marketed and cataloged, it didn't strike me as being written specifically for children.

It's not that the story contains anything inappropriate for young readers. In fact, I believe a paraphrased version could be just as entertaining for them as it was for me. Nevertheless, the advanced vocabulary, undefined French words, numerous references, and much of the humor embedded in both the phraseology and certain situations would likely be beyond the comprehension of elementary school children and probably most middle schoolers too.

The very first paragraph alone features words like "poverty," "abandoned," "circumstance," "immodesty," and "affluence." It's highly unlikely that the average 5th grader would be able to both read and understand every single one of those words. And if they managed to reach the second page, words like "accompaniment," "sordid," "lichen," "proximity," and "perimeter" would probably further deter many young readers attempting to follow the "five finger rule."

Similarly, True Kelly's illustrations are as delightful as always, but they don't always seem to align with what is being described in the text. The dishwasher named Pete, described as a "heavyset man" with an "interesting decoration" on his arm, is depicted in Kelly's picture as a man with a tattoo that matches the description of the "decoration," yet he doesn't appear to be "heavyset" at all.

The homeless man named Jack, who becomes the dog narrator's first human companion and names him Lucky, is described as having a "long, uncombed" beard and is clearly getting on in years. However, the illustrations on pages 36, 38, and 39 seem to show him as a young man with just a shadowy stubble around his mouth and chin. (He does look older on page 42, but he is still lacking the long beard.)

Furthermore, Kelly's whimsical illustration style, especially the cover illustration, and the small size of the volume initially led me to believe that this book was targeted at 4th grade readers and younger. So, when I actually read it and discovered its true sophistication, it came as quite a surprise.

I almost have the sense that Lois Lowry originally wrote this story for adults but was advised by her editors and publisher that it wouldn't sell well in that form. As a result, it was given Kelly's child-friendly illustrations to make it more appealing as a children's book.

At any rate, I'm glad that I had the opportunity to read this book as an adult, and I would be happy to be proven wrong about its accessibility to children. I might just give it a try and recommend it to some of the more advanced 5th and 6th grade readers I know to see what their thoughts are!
July 15,2025
... Show More
When I first laid my eyes on this book, I initially thought it would be an extremely easy read due to its simplistic cover. However, I was completely incorrect in assuming that the book would be effortless for students. In fact, there is a wide array of vocabulary being utilized throughout the text.

This captivating story is told from the perspective of a dog named Keeper. Keeper constantly encounters numerous problems that he has to surmount, yet he always does so with his nose and tail held high, exuding confidence and determination. Throughout the entire narrative, Keeper never forgets about his sister Wispy and continuously embarks on a search for her.

This book can serve as a valuable lesson to show kids that regardless of what they are going through, they should maintain a positive attitude and keep their heads held high. I firmly believe that this is a great book for readers of any age because of how straightforward and easy the story is to follow. I thoroughly enjoyed it when I was younger, and I am convinced that if I were to re-read it now, I would still derive the same level of enjoyment from it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A good children's book is like a magical key that unlocks the door to a world of imagination and learning. It has the power to capture a child's attention from the very first page and keep them engaged until the very end.

Such a book is filled with colorful illustrations that bring the story to life and make it easier for children to understand. The characters are relatable and endearing, and the plot is exciting and full of adventure.

A good children's book also teaches valuable lessons about life, love, friendship, and more. It helps children develop their language skills, expand their vocabulary, and improve their reading comprehension.

In addition, a good children's book can be a source of comfort and entertainment for children. It can help them relax after a long day at school or when they are feeling sad or lonely.

Overall, a good children's book is an essential part of every child's life. It has the potential to inspire, educate, and delight children for years to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**Original Article**: This is a simple article. It has a few sentences. It is about a topic.

**Expanded Article**:
This is a rather simple article.

It consists of just a few sentences.

The focus of this article is on a particular topic.

Although it may seem brief, it still manages to convey some information.

Perhaps it could be expanded further to provide more details and examples.

However, as it stands, it serves as a starting point for discussion or further exploration of the topic.

With a little more effort, it could be transformed into a more comprehensive and engaging piece of writing.

Nonetheless, even in its current state, it has its own charm and value.

It shows that sometimes, simplicity can be just as effective as complexity in getting a message across.



**Another Copy**:
This is a simple article indeed.

It contains only a few sentences.

The subject matter of this article is a specific topic.

Despite its brevity, it does manage to touch on some key points.

Maybe it could be enhanced by adding more in-depth analysis and real-life illustrations.

As it is now, it offers a basic understanding of the topic.

With a bit of work, it could be developed into a more detailed and captivating piece.

Nevertheless, in its present form, it has its own appeal and significance.

It demonstrates that a concise statement can often have a powerful impact.

It makes us realize that sometimes, less is more when it comes to communicating ideas.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I first came across this wonderful piece in my 5th grade class, and from the very moment I started reading it, I was completely captivated. I vividly remember picking it up at a bookstore, and to this day, it still has the same magical charm.

The personality of the main dog character is truly endearing. It's one of those rare kids' stories that has the power to bring tears to my eyes. It manages to capture all of the emotions and thoughts that I used to imagine my own dog having when I was younger in the most fascinating way.

I firmly believe that this would serve as an excellent introduction to more advanced vocabulary for a high-level reader in elementary school. Moreover, it would also be a delightful read for an adult who is seeking a really charming and yet genuinely outstanding short story. It's a literary gem that can be enjoyed by readers of all ages.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A young dog is the narrator of this charming story that takes us through his life journey. He starts off as a puppy in an alley, facing the uncertainties and challenges of the outside world. Then, he has experiences with two different men, which shape his understanding of humans and life. Finally, he finds a happy home with a girl, where he is loved and cared for.


Unlike many other dog stories, this one has a refreshing twist - the dog lives! This makes it all the more heartwarming and engaging.


I truly believe that this would be an excellent book to read aloud. The author has a great sense of humor and plays with language in a delightful way. The dog narrator, in particular, enjoys composing little poems, which add an extra layer of charm to the story.


The book is also enhanced by the warm and cartoony illustrations by True Kelley. These illustrations bring the story to life and make it even more appealing, especially for younger readers.


Overall, this is a wonderful book that combines a touching story, great language, and beautiful illustrations. It's a must-read for dog lovers of all ages.
July 15,2025
... Show More
My 8-year-old son and I just had the wonderful experience of reading this book aloud together, and we were completely charmed by it.

Lowry's writing style is truly remarkable. It is sophisticated enough to engage adults, yet accessible enough for children to understand and enjoy. Her sense of humor is extraordinary, and it had us laughing out loud many times. We even had to take pauses to catch our breath.

This is an amazing tale (and tail). We were so impressed that we decided we must own it forever. We read a library book this time, but now we know that it will have a permanent place on our shelf, right next to "The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane" by Kate DiCamillo.

We can't wait to read it again and share it with our friends and family. It's a book that will surely be cherished for years to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this wonderful story to my granddaughter who is six years old.

The vocabulary in the story is way beyond her level of comprehension, but that didn't stop her from absolutely loving to listen.

I didn't quiz her at all to find out how much she understood because, quite frankly, I don't really care.

The important thing is that we had a really good time together.

She was so engaged that she kept asking me to keep reading, and of course, I obliged.

It's such a charming story, and Lois Lowry is truly a wonder when it comes to writing.

Her ability to create a world that captures the imagination of both young and old is simply amazing.

This reading session with my granddaughter was a precious moment that I will always cherish.

I can't wait to read more of Lois Lowry's works to her in the future.
 1 2 3 4 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.