It is not a bad novel that is set in Madrid right after the Spanish Civil War. Pawel vividly tells the story of a country that is still severely affected by the ravages of a bitter internal war. The novel portrays the deprivation, angst, anger, and fear that have tightly gripped the entire population, including both the winners and the losers.
Moreover, Pawel does a remarkable job of meticulously detailing how a police investigation can take a wrong turn and find itself getting lost in misleading pathways and alleys. The story unfolds with a sense of mystery and suspense, keeping the readers engaged from beginning to end.
The author's description of the post-war Madrid is so vivid that it allows the readers to almost feel the pain and turmoil of the people living there. Overall, it is a captivating novel that offers a unique perspective on the Spanish Civil War and its aftermath.
A diverting read, though seems to understate the horrors of the Spanish civil war.
Rebecca Pawel introduces us to Sergeant Carlos Tejada Alonso y Leon, one of Spain’s Guardia Civil. Death of a Nationalist (2003) is the first of four Sergeant Tejada novels, following in the footsteps of Philip Kerr’s 1930s Berlin noir series. Like Kerr, Pawel’s protagonist is an investigator within a fascist regime, in this case Franco’s Spain.
The novel begins at the end of the Spanish civil war. The Guardia is restoring order in Madrid, which means rounding up leftist sympathizers and sending them to prison and interrogation. Sergeant Tejada is called to investigate the murder of a fellow Guardia member. Suspicion immediately falls on the communists, who are still attacking Franco’s forces sporadically. After an initial mistake, Tejada starts to suspect that the murder may be more complicated, perhaps linked to the black market in army rations.
The writing is suspenseful, making it an absorbing page-turner. Pawel’s novel is also well-researched, with a postscript acknowledging information from web-based oral histories. This is seen in the rich period details like the bomb damage on Madrid’s streets and the malnutrition of the population.
However, the psychological trauma of years of fratricidal slaughter doesn’t come alive on the pages. In fact, Pawel seems to have her characters shrug off the psychic burdens of the war too easily. After just a few conversations, an attractive leftist woman schoolteacher finds herself in the arms of Nationalist Sergeant Tejada, kissing passionately. This is especially strange since the same schoolteacher was nearly raped by Nationalist troops earlier that evening.
As a comparison, American readers might question the credibility of a novel where a Southern Belle falls for one of Sherman’s troops as his army burned through the South. (Since Death of a Nationalist has been translated into Spanish, it’s disappointing not to have more reviews from Spanish readers to see if they think the plotting is plausible.)
Those unfamiliar with the factions in Spain’s civil war may find the different groupings confusing: Falangists, Royalists/Carlists, Republicans, Nationalists, reds/Communists, etc. More background description of the warring parties would have helped clarify the novel’s plot.
Overall, it’s a fine beach read but far from great literature.
While it may seem strange to discover a hero among the ranks of the fascists, this actually offers valuable insights into the complex mentality of political polarization during times of war. It forces the reader to consider that the enemy is not simply pure evil, but rather a complex entity with its own set of motives and actions. The hero in question is indeed cruel, yet he is portrayed as being better than his fascist colleagues. This cruelty is balanced by the author's mention of the actions of the Communists, adding another layer of complexity to the story.
Tejada, the central character, is a rogue agent who is willing to take the lives of those he deems to be evil. He is also an unreliable narrator, often following false clues and arriving at incorrect conclusions. This aspect of his character makes him more realistic and relatable, as we all make mistakes and misinterpret information at times. The author has a talent for writing engaging lines, such as comparing naive statements to having a "piss free zone" in a pool or an airplane with a "no smoking" section. These vivid comparisons add a touch of humor and depth to the story, making it all the more enjoyable to read.