Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 61 votes)
5 stars
16(26%)
4 stars
23(38%)
3 stars
22(36%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
61 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
A very small pamphlet was based on a speech from the 70's of Chomsky.

In this pamphlet, Chomsky discussed political theory and philosophy in a much more abstract and general way than he usually does when he focuses on US foreign policy.

His analysis is clear-sighted and truly unparalleled. It offers a refreshing and nice treat to read him on a different topic rather than just foreign policy.

It allows readers to explore and understand his thoughts and ideas from a broader perspective, delving into the deeper realms of political theory and philosophy.

This pamphlet serves as a valuable resource for those interested in Chomsky's work and those who wish to gain a more comprehensive understanding of political thought and philosophy in general.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I am probably disappointed.

I understand that the silver bullet is libertarian socialism. State socialism has been lumped together with state capitalism, and state capitalism has been considered with the note that these commies are the same eggs, just in profile. Hehe.

Libertarian socialism is an ideology that emphasizes individual freedom and voluntary cooperation. It argues that the state should have a minimal role in the economy and society, and that economic and social relations should be based on mutual aid and self-governance.

However, in practice, libertarian socialism has faced many challenges and difficulties. It is difficult to achieve a balance between individual freedom and social justice, and it is also difficult to organize and manage a complex economy and society without the support of the state.

Therefore, while libertarian socialism has some attractive ideas and ideals, it is not a panacea that can solve all problems. We need to continue to explore and experiment to find a more suitable social and economic model.
July 15,2025
... Show More
He says,

"Man never views what he owns as truly his own as much as what he does. The laborer who takes care of the garden is perhaps, in a truer sense, its owner than the listless pleasure seeker who enjoys its fruits. Since truly human action stems from inner impulse, it seems as if all peasants and craftsmen could be elevated into artists. That is, men who love their labor for its own sake, improve it with their own creative genius and inventive skill, and thereby cultivate their intellect, ennoble their character, and exult and refine their pleasures. Thus, humanity would be ennobled by the very things which now, although beautiful in themselves, so often tend to be degraded. Freedom is undoubtedly the indispensable condition without which even the pursuits most suitable to individual human nature can never succeed in producing such beneficial influences. Whatever does not spring from a man's free choice or is only the result of instruction and guidance does not enter into his very being but remains alien to his true nature. He does not perform it with truly human energies but merely with mechanical exactness. And if a man acts in a mechanical way, reacting to external demands or instruction rather than in ways determined by his own interests, energies, and power, we may admire what he does but we despise what he is." For Humboldt, then, man "is born to inquire and create, and when a man or a child chooses to inquire or create out of his own free choice, then he becomes, in his own terms, an artist rather than a tool of production or a well-trained parrot."


Consider the following characterization of revolutionary socialism:

"The revolutionary socialist denies that state ownership can lead to anything other than a bureaucratic despotism. We have seen why the state cannot democratically control industry. Industry can only be democratically owned and controlled by the workers who directly elect industrial administrative committees from their own ranks. Socialism will fundamentally be an industrial system; its constituencies will be of an industrial character. Thus, those engaged in the social activity and industries of society will be directly represented in the local and central councils of social administration. In this way, the powers of such delegates will flow upwards from those carrying out the work and familiar with the needs of the community. When the central industrial administrative committee meets, it will represent every phase of social activity. Hence, the capitalist political or geographical state will be replaced by the industrial administrative committee of socialism. The transition from one social system to the other will be the social revolution. The political state throughout history has meant the government of men by ruling classes; the republic of socialism will be the government of industry administered on behalf of the whole community. The former meant the economic and political subjection of the many; the latter will mean the economic freedom of all. It will be, therefore, a true democracy."


There is one final element that must be added to this picture, namely the ongoing militarization of American society. How does this fit in? To see, one has to look back at WWII and recall that prior to WWII, of course, we were deep in the depression. WWII taught an important economic lesson. It taught the lesson that government-induced production in a carefully controlled economy - centrally controlled - could overcome the effects of a depression. I think this is what Charles E. Wilson had in mind at the end of 1944 when he proposed that we have a permanent war economy in the postwar world. Of course, the trouble is that in a capitalist economy, there are only a limited number of ways in which government intervention can occur. It can't be competitive with the private empires, for example, which means it can't be any useful production. In fact, it has to be the production of luxury goods, not capital, not useful commodities that would be competitive. And unfortunately, there is only one category of luxury goods that can be produced endlessly with rapid obsolescence, quickly wasting, and no limit on how many of them you can use. We all know what that is.


Quick and easy guide to Chomsky's libertarian socialist theories. A nice, easy summary. On Anarchism is more in-depth, but this is what it's advertised to be. It would make sense to read this prior to a lot of his other works to understand the theoretical underpinnings of the systems he analyzes in detail.
July 15,2025
... Show More
In a society that allocates vast amounts of resources to waste and destruction, it becomes rather challenging to take seriously the arguments regarding efficiency.

As is widely known, the very essence of the concept of efficiency is deeply intertwined with ideology.

Maximizing the production and consumption of commodities is by no means the sole criterion for a fulfilling and decent existence.

There are numerous other aspects that contribute to the well-being and quality of life of individuals and society as a whole.

For instance, factors such as social justice, environmental sustainability, and the preservation of cultural heritage play crucial roles in determining the true value and efficiency of a society.

Therefore, we need to look beyond the narrow focus on commodity maximization and consider a more comprehensive and holistic approach to evaluating efficiency and progress.

This will enable us to build a more just, sustainable, and fulfilling society for future generations.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Out of all the Noam Chomsky books I own,

I chose to have this one signed by Noam himself.

That should tell you how amazing this book is.

This particular book holds a special place in my collection.

It contains Chomsky's profound insights and revolutionary ideas that have had a significant impact on various fields.

The moment I got it signed by him, it became even more precious.

It's not just a book; it's a piece of history and a connection to one of the greatest minds of our time.

Every time I pick it up and flip through the pages, I am inspired by Chomsky's intellect and his unwavering commitment to truth and justice.

This signed book is a treasure that I will cherish for a lifetime.
July 15,2025
... Show More
One of Chomsky's earliest discourses on politics is also one of the most accessible ones. It is concise, well-structured, and serves as an astonishing introduction to Chomsky's pragmatic perspective on government.

Here, you won't encounter overarching ideological posturing, theatrics, or even a profound sense of urgency. Instead, there is a calm and rational exploration of the practical consequences of different forms of government.

This ultimately leads to a vision of a gradual shift towards a socialized society that empowers the individual both politically and in their workplace.

It is brilliant, true, and remarkably practical, yet such conversations are rarely heard elsewhere. I highly recommend this single-sitting read to anyone who has an interest in political theory.

It offers valuable insights and a unique perspective that can enhance one's understanding of the complex world of politics and governance.

Whether you are a student, a researcher, or simply someone who wants to be more informed about political affairs, this work by Chomsky is well worth your time and attention.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Немного ликбеза и побольше приятных мыслей. As I saw it, he doesn't have illusions regarding the implementation of ideas. He's simply not a pessimist.


---


“And in time, when, as I hope, the revolutionary libertarian socialist movement acquires a mass character, discussions will inevitably have to grow into action.”


---


“Unfortunately, there is only one category of luxury items that can be produced endlessly, quickly become morally obsolete and wear out, and that without any restrictions or reasonable limits. We all know what that category is: military production.”


---


“<...> Joseph Schumpeter, who describes today's political democracy as a system in which 'the solution of current issues by the electorate is secondary in relation to the election of the people who are to make the decisions'.”

July 15,2025
... Show More
The original article is not provided, so I can't rewrite and expand it specifically. However, I can give you a general example to show you how it can be done.

Let's assume the original article is: "The cat is sleeping on the mat."

Expanded version:

The cute little cat is peacefully sleeping on the soft mat. Its fur is smooth and shiny, and it looks so cozy and relaxed. The mat provides a comfortable place for the cat to take a nap. It seems that nothing can disturb its sweet dream.



If you can provide the original article, I will be able to rewrite and expand it according to your requirements.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Noam Chomsky's book is truly excellent.

It provides a concise description of the political and economic powers that govern the world.

It delves into the inner workings of these forces and how they shape our society.

Moreover, it presents possible alternatives for achieving a real and meaningful change.

The author offers valuable insights and perspectives that can inspire readers to think critically about the status quo.

Whether you are interested in politics, economics, or social change, this book is highly recommended.

It is a thought-provoking and engaging read that can expand your understanding of the world we live in.

So, don't miss out on this opportunity to explore the ideas and theories presented by one of the most influential thinkers of our time.

Pick up Noam Chomsky's book and embark on a journey of discovery and enlightenment.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Elegant yet simple - Chomsky rips off the mask of political power and forces us to see the face that has often been hidden.

His incisive analysis strips away the layers of obfuscation and reveals the true nature of power dynamics.

That face is often hard to look at in the'mirror' of collective responsibility; we often avoid looking at that which distorts the images we want to project.

We prefer to focus on the光鲜亮丽 aspects and turn a blind eye to the less savory truths.

However, it is only by looking in this mirror that we can see what the future holds for all of us.

Chomsky's work challenges us to confront the uncomfortable realities and take responsibility for shaping a better future.

His ideas serve as a wake-up call, urging us to question the status quo and strive for a more just and equitable society.

By facing the hidden face of political power, we can begin to make the necessary changes and ensure a brighter tomorrow for generations to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Maximization of commodities is hardly the only measure of a decent existence.

In today's consumer-driven society, there is a tendency to equate a good life with the possession of a large number of commodities. However, this narrow view fails to take into account the many other aspects that contribute to a fulfilling and meaningful life.

For example, relationships with family and friends, a sense of purpose and fulfillment in work, and the ability to pursue hobbies and interests are all essential components of a decent existence. These intangible aspects cannot be measured in terms of commodities and yet are often more valuable than material possessions.

Moreover, the pursuit of commodity maximization can have negative consequences. It can lead to overconsumption, environmental degradation, and a sense of emptiness and dissatisfaction. We need to recognize that there is more to life than just accumulating stuff and start to focus on the things that really matter.

July 15,2025
... Show More
After reading Hayek's book “Road to Serfdom”, I was eager to explore the details of what he warns might occur in a society founded on the principles of the free market when the state lacks certain controls or regulations.

What transpires is that corporations essentially consume the state and govern from the shadows.

It is very concise and to the point. Similar to his other works, it has provided me with a great deal to investigate in areas of thought that I have never truly been acquainted with.

I am commencing to observe that Hayek's warning, despite his being a staunch advocate of the free market, has materialized in numerous ways.

I am beginning to understand that although capitalism brings remarkable genius and industry to the world, it still conceals many flaws that can and will be exploited by malicious individuals.

This realization has led me to further contemplate the delicate balance between a free market and the necessary role of the state in ensuring the well-being and fairness of society.

It has also made me more aware of the potential consequences of unbridled capitalism and the need for vigilant oversight to prevent the abuse of power and the exploitation of the vulnerable.

Hayek's work serves as a timely reminder that we must constantly assess and adapt our economic and social systems to safeguard against the pitfalls that may arise.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.