Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 42 votes)
5 stars
13(31%)
4 stars
19(45%)
3 stars
10(24%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
42 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Inimitable.


This word holds a special charm and significance. Something that is inimitable is truly one-of-a-kind, impossible to replicate or imitate exactly. It represents a quality or characteristic that is unique and sets it apart from everything else.


When we encounter something inimitable, it often leaves a lasting impression on us. It could be a work of art, a performance, a person's style, or a particular brand. The inimitability of these things makes them stand out and be remembered.


In a world where so many things seem to blend together and follow the same trends, the presence of something inimitable is refreshing and captivating. It challenges us to appreciate the individual and the extraordinary. It reminds us that there is value in being different and that true originality is worth celebrating.


Whether it's the inimitable beauty of a natural wonder, the inimitable talent of a musician, or the inimitable spirit of a community, these are the things that make life rich and diverse. They inspire us, move us, and make us believe in the power of the unique.


So, let's embrace the inimitable and strive to create and appreciate those things that are truly one-of-a-kind. For in doing so, we add a touch of magic and wonder to our lives.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Oh, Alright! I'm not going to finish this. I was never going to finish this.


I don't know if it's the history lesson aspect, the writing style that seems a bit too formal, the lack of sensuality that might have made it more engaging, or the larger-than-usual print that gives it a rather textbook-like appearance. But this book truly felt very much like an elementary school reading text book.


Don't get me wrong. Endora Welty is good at what she does. Some of her descriptions are quite lovely and vivid, painting a clear picture in the reader's mind. It's just that throughout the reading, I was very aware that I was reading a book. There was a certain detachment, as if I was not fully immersed in the story. Maybe it's just not the right book for me at this moment. That's all I'm saying!

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly wish that I could have felt differently about it, but unfortunately, it just wasn't meant to be for me.

Descriptive writing indeed has its own group of dedicated fans who seem to be able to get lost in the beauty and vividness of the words. However, for me, it was a completely different story.

I found myself adrift in a never-ending stream of images that, try as I might, meant absolutely nothing to me. It was as if I was looking at a beautiful painting but couldn't understand the emotions or the message it was trying to convey.

Maybe it's because I have a different way of perceiving things, or perhaps I just haven't found the right descriptive writing that speaks to my heart. Whatever the reason may be, I can't help but feel a sense of disappointment that I can't fully appreciate this particular form of writing.

But who knows, maybe one day I'll come across a piece of descriptive writing that will change my perspective and make me see the world in a whole new light.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is an okay collection. However, the star appeal that I felt when I read "A Curtain of Green" was simply not present here. It's rather strange because this collection was published only about a year after that one. It seems so obvious to me that it would have been better to either publish most of both collections or just combine them together, as a significant number of these stories were quite unforgettable. Eudora Welty (I have mistakenly typed it as Wlety countless times in my life, dating back to my college days when I wrote a long-term paper on her novel "The Optimist’s Daughter" - End digression) still remains a more tender-hearted version of Flannery O’Connor. Her characters are often larger than life, yet they are not grotesque caricatures of humanity.


By far, the best story in this collection is the title story. In it, a man grows tired of his pregnant wife and stays out drinking all night. When he returns home, she is gone, having left a note saying she has jumped in the river. The subsequent story involves dragging the river with, believe it or not, a wide net. It's really good. Here's how it begins: “William Wallace Jamieson’s wife Hazel was going to have a baby. But this was October, and it was six months away, and she acted exactly as though it would be tomorrow.”


I am conflicted in my feelings about Welty (finally got it right this time) because I have read several of her books and I truly try hard to like her. And there have been a few occasions when I did. I really liked "The Optimist’s Daughter." I think I must have convinced myself that I am the kind of person who likes Welty and struggle to come to terms with the fact that perhaps I'm not.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Landing was an experience that left an indelible mark on me.

It was as if the very essence of my being was being pulled apart, piece by piece.

The anticipation leading up to it was palpable, but nothing could have prepared me for the reality that awaited.

The moment I set foot on that unknown ground, a wave of emotions crashed over me.

Fear, excitement, and a sense of the unknown all intertwined, creating a chaotic storm within.

As I took in the unfamiliar surroundings, my heart pounded in my chest.

Every sound, every movement, seemed to magnify the intensity of the moment.

The last bit of The Landing was the most brutal.

It was as if the universe was testing my limits, pushing me to the brink of exhaustion and despair.

But through it all, I refused to give up.

I held on tightly to my inner strength, determined to overcome whatever challenges lay ahead.

And in that moment of turmoil, I discovered a part of myself I never knew existed.

A part that was resilient,勇敢, and capable of facing anything.

The Landing may have torn me to shreds, but it also made me whole again.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I didn't find these stories that memorable.

However, the exception is the title story which is truly remarkable. Thanks to its hilarious dialogue, abundant action, and a hint of magical realism, it stands out.

The writing is skillfully crafted throughout the collection. Nevertheless, in most of the stories, the characters don't engage in much activity.

Nor do they possess interesting interior lives, aside from being sheltered and lovesick.

There is a distinct Southern slowness and humidity that pervades these stories.

But unfortunately, there isn't much of a payoff for having to endure it.

Overall, while the title story is great, the rest of the collection falls a bit short in terms of character development and overall impact.

It seems that the author focused more on creating a certain atmosphere rather than fully fleshing out the characters and their stories.

Perhaps with a bit more attention to these aspects, the collection could have been even more engaging and memorable.

July 15,2025
... Show More
If you have a penchant for Welty's more mythical and dreamy tales, then you are sure to be enamored with A Wide Net.

Some of the stories within this collection, like "At the Landing," seem to have a certain connection to the Natchez Trace and the imaginative realm of The Robber Bridegroom, the novella that Welty had released just the previous year in 1942.

The way Welty weaves her narratives in A Wide Net is truly captivating. She creates a world that is both familiar and yet充满奇幻色彩.

The characters come to life on the page, and their stories draw the reader in, making it difficult to put the book down.

Whether you are a long-time fan of Welty or new to her work, A Wide Net is highly recommended. It offers a unique and enchanting reading experience that is not to be missed.

So, if you're looking for a book that will transport you to another world and leave you with a sense of wonder, give A Wide Net a try. You won't be disappointed.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Miss Welty had an in-depth knowledge of her beloved South.

Her writing was truly remarkable for its vivid and detailed descriptions.

Among her works, "First Love" held a special place in my heart.

The way she described the deaf boy perceiving voices as breaths in the frigid air was simply magical.

It was moments like these that made reading her works an absolute joy and a worthwhile experience.

Her words seemed to bring the scenes to life, allowing the reader to immerse themselves fully in the story.

Miss Welty's ability to paint such a clear picture in the reader's mind is a testament to her great talent as a writer.

Her works will continue to be cherished and studied for years to come, inspiring generations of readers and writers alike.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Beyond the open door, the rain cascaded down, bearing the heavy hue of the sea, in the air where the sunlight still lingered. Its watery reflection illuminated the room, much like how a room might have illuminated a mouse-hole.

Eudora Welty's The Wide Net is a collection firmly rooted in the meandering rivers and vibrant landscapes of the Natchez area near New Orleans. Welty's stories are intricately connected to the place through folklore, history, and the cultural nuances that render Southern life so incredibly rich.

In "First Love," Welty delves into an unexpected connection between a deaf-mute boy and a woman trapped in her own circumstances, set against the backdrop of a historic judicial case. "The Winds" offers a blend of humor and suspense as the townspeople prepare for an unpredictable storm. It's a scene of comical preparedness, yet also a reminder of how deeply nature is intertwined with the community's daily rhythm. "Livvie," one of the most captivating stories, revolves around a young Black woman at a crossroads between her duty to a dying husband and the possibility of new beginnings with a stranger. It's a tale of transformation - personal, spiritual, and seasonal.

Throughout the collection, musical instruments frequently make an appearance: cornets (trumpets), fiddles, banjos, and pianos mark moments of change, education, and even revelation. They are not merely background noise but seem to signify something greater - a sense of hope, transition, or even a reaching towards something beyond oneself.

Reading The Wide Net makes me dream of relocating to a small town, a place abundant with history and mystery. But then I recall that this comes with fewer bookstores and a smaller library.
July 15,2025
... Show More

It's an odd little collection of stories. There are two that lean towards historical fiction. "First Love" involves Aaron Burr around the time of his trial for treason, and "A Still Moment" features James Audubon and two other minor historical figures who meet in the woods. I had a liking for "A Still Moment", yet I have my doubts regarding what it gains by having the characters be historical. I had to look up the other two, and even after reading a bit about them, it neither added nor detracted anything from my understanding or enjoyment of the stories. The same holds true, even more so, for the presence of Burr in "First Love".


"The Wide Net" is a fabulous story and easily the best in the collection. Next in line is probably "At the Landing", which is also quite good and very disturbing in its portrayal of rape and the victim's reaction to it. I'm glad I read the collection if only for these stories. In general, I also like Welty's use of language and her ability to make the ordinary seem extraordinary and almost magical, such that the Natchez Trace becomes a place out of myth.


But the rest of the stories (5 out of the 8, including "First Love") were just not all that captivating. I'm well aware that this might just be me, or perhaps my mood. I have a strong suspicion that with age, and the ever-growing distraction of the internet, I am becoming dumber and a much worse reader than I used to be. Who knows how I would have reacted to these 20 - 25 years ago? Certainly not me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Unlike "A Curtain Green" which had numerous stories that I truly loved,

I found myself not liking a single one in this particular collection.

I believe it's because Welty decided to switch to a surrealist, "To the Lighthouse" style.

This new style requires all of my concentration not to zone out.

I own her complete short stories, which means there are three more books in the bunch.

I'm really hoping that this was just a passing phase for her.

"A Curtain Green" was simply so good that I can't help but compare everything else to it.

I'm keeping my fingers crossed that the remaining books will bring back the magic and charm that I loved in her previous work.

Maybe I just need to give this new style more time and a chance to grow on me.

But for now, I'm still longing for the kind of stories that "A Curtain Green" had to offer.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I was extremely into this work compared to "A Curtain of Green and Other Stories". The connection through the Natchez Trace among all the elements was truly captivating.

"First Love" stood out as my absolute favorite. What more can I say? The unexpected 18th-century settings, with the presence of founding fathers, had an irresistible charm for me. It was like my personal kryptonite.

You know, there could be far worse things to have as a kryptonite. I mean, just think about actual kryptonite. It's not as interesting or engaging as these historical and literary elements that draw me in and make me love this work so much.

I find myself constantly thinking about the stories and the unique setting, and it makes me eager to explore more of what this author has to offer.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.