Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 42 votes)
5 stars
13(31%)
4 stars
19(45%)
3 stars
10(24%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
42 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have never been so deeply immersed in the captivating worlds of an author's creation as I am with the enchanting stories of Eudora Welty.

Her writing has an uncanny ability to wrap you in a cocoon of vividness, where you can almost see the sights, hear the sounds, smell the scents, and feel the textures of her characters' lives.

But she doesn't stop there. She delves even deeper, taking you on an intimate journey into the very hearts and minds of her characters.

By the time you reach the end of each story, it's as if you've embarked on a real adventure, having truly been somewhere, whether it's a place of joy, heartbreak, or utter confusion.

These stories are nothing short of masterpieces, incredibly rich in detail that lingers in your mind long after you've turned the last page.

They are a testament to Welty's extraordinary talent and her ability to create worlds that are both familiar and strange, drawing you in and making you a part of her fictional universe.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This series wasn't as outstanding as the A Curtain of Green and Other Stories. I'm well aware that Eudora Welty came from an era when certain things were considered the norm. However, it was extremely difficult for me to overlook the frequent usage of the N-word.

Despite this, her writing still possessed the same enchanting power. The manner in which the beautiful prose intertwined throughout all the stories made me reluctant to abandon it.

It's truly a pity that such a talented writer had this one aspect that was so off-putting. Nevertheless, I couldn't deny the beauty and skill that was evident in her work.

I found myself constantly torn between being repelled by the offensive language and being drawn in by the captivating prose. It was a strange and somewhat uncomfortable experience.

Yet, I still feel that there is value in reading her work, if only to understand the context and the times in which she wrote.
July 15,2025
... Show More
She is the Ernest Hemingway of southern female writers.

Her works are filled with the unique charm and spirit of the South. Just like Hemingway, she has a distinct writing style that captivates readers.

Her stories often explore the complex emotions and relationships of the people in the South, painting a vivid picture of their lives.

She delves deep into the human psyche, revealing the hidden desires and fears that lie within.

With her powerful and evocative language, she brings the South to life on the page, making readers feel as if they are right there in the midst of it all.

Her works have had a significant impact on the literary world, and she is widely regarded as one of the most important southern female writers of her time.

Just as Hemingway's works have stood the test of time, hers are also likely to be remembered and cherished for generations to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Even when a story doesn't quite manage to soar to great heights, it always has the power to instill within the reader a deep sense of nature, a longing or yearning, and a quality of thoughtfulness.

When Welty is successful in forging a connection between her characters, their innermost desires, and the irresistible appeal of nature, the work takes on a life of its own. It moves and stirs both the inner and outer aspects of the reader until one becomes acutely aware of something profound. This profound something seems to be forever distant, just out of reach, yet at the same time, it feels forever near, as if it is constantly hovering on the periphery of our consciousness.

Welty's ability to create this delicate balance and connection is what makes her work truly remarkable and worthy of our attention and admiration.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly wanted to have a greater affinity for these than I actually did.

I am a huge enthusiast of the setting, and I truly valued the Natchez connection that intertwined all the stories.

While a significant number of them are indeed very good, some of these tales felt a touch lackluster.

Perhaps I wasn't in the appropriate mental state to peruse them. These are stories that demand one's time, to savor the details and the subtleties, and I might have skimmed through some too hastily.

Anyhow, Welty shines brightest when she is penning dialog, and the title story serves as a remarkable illustration of that.

Her ability to bring the characters to life through their conversations is truly a marvel.

Even in the stories that didn't quite grip me as tightly, the dialog added a layer of authenticity and charm.

It's clear that Welty is a master of her craft, and I look forward to delving deeper into her work in the future.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The collection of stories presented here offers a diverse range of literary experiences.

First Love takes the reader on a journey through the complex emotions and青涩 moments of young love.

The Wide Net by Eudora Welty weaves a tale that explores the interconnectedness of lives in a unique and captivating way.

A Still Moment, also by Welty, presents a snapshot of a particular moment in time, filled with depth and meaning.

Asphodel, which was published in one complete issue of the YALE REVIEW in Autumn 1942, delves into themes that are both profound and thought-provoking.

The Winds brings a sense of movement and change, as the characters navigate the forces that buffet them.

The Purple Hat adds a touch of mystery and intrigue, while Livvie offers a glimpse into the life of a particular individual.

Finally, At the Landing rounds out the collection, leaving the reader with a lasting impression.

Together, these stories create a rich tapestry of human experience, inviting the reader to explore and discover the many nuances and subtleties within each one.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this collection from The Modern Library edition which also included A Curtain of Green and Other Stories, her first collection of short stories. Regarding that collection, I thought overall they were superb. However, I cannot say the same about The Wide Net and Other Stories. In fact, I very much disliked these stories.


I am well aware of Eudora Welty’s skill as a writer, along with her many awards and her established place in the literary canon. I read with pleasure “What There is to Say, We Have Already Said,” a collection of letters written between her and William Maxwell, another accomplished writer. That being said, had I not known these stories were written by Eudora Welty, I would not have finished them.


There were 8 short stories in this collection. The stories were filled with very long sentences that were either meandering, overly descriptive, indecipherable to me, or a combination of “all of the above”. The only story that I understood was the title story, The Wide Net.


I’ll leave it at that. I am eager to read the reviews of others and learn from them. Perhaps these stories have a certain style that I am not accustomed to reading. Maybe with more exposure and a better understanding of her writing style, I will come to appreciate these stories more. But for now, my initial impression is not a positive one.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a really good collection of short stories.

Each story within it offers a unique and captivating experience.

"First Love" takes readers on a journey through the emotions and turmoil of that initial encounter with love.

"The Wide Net" weaves a tale that keeps you on the edge of your seat, filled with mystery and anticipation.

"A Still Moment" provides a quiet and reflective moment, allowing you to soak in the atmosphere and the thoughts of the characters.

"Asphodel" delves into a world of beauty and perhaps a touch of the unknown.

"The Winds" brings a sense of movement and change, as if the forces of nature are at play in the lives of the characters.

"The Purple Hat" has its own charm and allure, drawing you in with its interesting plot and characters.

"Livvie" tells a story that is both heartwarming and engaging.

"At the Landing" rounds out the collection with a story that leaves a lasting impression.

Overall, this collection is a must-read for any lover of short stories.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I’ve been engaged in reading this along with the Welty book club.

Just recently, I completed the final story titled At the Landing.

We are scheduled to have a discussion about it tomorrow.

This particular story was truly a disturbing one.

It was told through the medium of gorgeous language and vivid descriptions of nature, much like many of the other stories in this collection.

The combination of the beautiful language and the disturbing content created a unique and powerful reading experience.

As I turned the last page, I found myself reflecting on the various themes and emotions that the story had evoked.

I’m looking forward to hearing the perspectives and insights of the other members of the book club during tomorrow’s discussion.

It will be interesting to see how others interpreted the story and what they took away from it.

I’m sure it will be a lively and engaging conversation.
July 15,2025
... Show More
"First Love" was truly an amazing experience. It had a certain charm and allure that made it stand out from the rest. The emotions it evoked were intense and profound, leaving a lasting impression on those who experienced it.

However, the rest of the experiences didn't quite hit the same notes. They may have had their moments, but they lacked the magic and authenticity that "First Love" possessed. It's as if "First Love" set a standard that was difficult to match.

Perhaps it's because "First Love" is often associated with innocence, purity, and a sense of newness. It's a time when everything seems possible and the world is full of wonder. The memories of "First Love" can stay with us for a lifetime, shaping our understanding of love and relationships.

In conclusion, while the rest may not have been as remarkable as "First Love", it's important to remember that each experience is unique and has its own value. We should cherish the memories of "First Love" while also being open to new and different experiences in the future.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Perhaps one must be southern to appreciate her?

This statement intrigues and makes one wonder. It implies that there is something about a particular person that is more easily understood or valued by those from the South.

Maybe her charm, her way of speaking, or her cultural references are deeply rooted in the southern experience.

Those who are not from the South might struggle to fully grasp the essence of what makes her so special.

However, this doesn't mean that others can't come to appreciate her in their own way.

With an open mind and a willingness to learn about her background and the southern culture that has influenced her, anyone can begin to see the qualities that make her unique.

Perhaps it is through sharing stories, traditions, and experiences that we can bridge the gap and find common ground, allowing us all to appreciate the beauty and complexity of this individual, regardless of where we are from.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Just read The Wide Net, and I truly enjoyed the arc of the story.

Ever since getting married, stories about marriage seem to have a different impact on me. They strike a chord deep within.

That being said, there were certain aspects in this story that I just couldn't quite understand, like his silly dance. It left me scratching my head, wondering what the author was trying to convey.

I also had the pleasure of listening to a recording of Welty reading it from the 80s. That was really an enjoyable experience. Her voice brought the story to life in a unique way.

However, apart from that, I would be hard-pressed to recommend this story wholeheartedly. While it had its moments, there were also parts that felt a bit lacking or unclear.

Maybe it's just my personal taste, but I found myself not fully engaged throughout the entire narrative.

Nonetheless, it was still an interesting read, and I'm glad I gave it a chance.

Perhaps others will have a different perspective and find more to appreciate in this story.

Overall, it's a bit of a mixed bag for me.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.