Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
33(33%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

The Writing Life is a concise yet profound book. Annie Dillard, with her elegant prose, shares several autobiographical anecdotes. As a writer herself, these reminiscences incidentally or metaphorically offer insights into her craft. She compares writing to various activities such as mining, sailing, painting, chopping wood, and aerobatics. She also describes it like an inchworm or a strand of fibreoptic. The book is filled with such vivid analogies.


Although there is an element of irony, Annie Dillard's meditations can sometimes be harsh and disheartening. For example, she asks, "Why not shoot yourself, actually, rather than finish one more excellent manuscript on which to gag the world?" However, on other occasions, she provides powerful, humorous, and comforting bits of wisdom about the writing trade. She points out that out of a global population of 4.5 billion, perhaps only 20 people can write a serious book in a year. Just like there are people who perform other extraordinary feats like lifting cars, entering sled-dog races, going over Niagara Falls in barrels, or flying planes through the Arc de Triomphe. She emphasizes that we should not take these human extremes as norms. These truths are meant to comfort the anguished writers. It doesn't mean that faster-written books are necessarily worse. It just means that most writers should stop berating themselves for writing at a normal, slow pace. So much for the high daily word counts of Stephen King or Michael Crichton.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is rather short - just over one hundred pages in hardcover - and it is extremely easy to read.

If you take a look at my five status updates, you will come across quotes from the book. The book is truly filled with quotable quotes that are not only often entertaining but also highly enlightening.

I firmly believe that Annie Dillard is a remarkable writer. However, my one criticism of The Writing Life is that it is despairingly certain that becoming a good writer is almost impossible. This, in my opinion, is simply not true.

Now, you may not pen an award-winning novel, but if you peruse reviews on Goodreads, you are aware that there are some really good writers out there. You might not be able to earn a living solely with your words, but you can most definitely enjoy the process of creating sentences and paragraphs.

Perhaps this is simply a memoir by Annie, sharing what it is like to be a writer for her. It is most definitely not a how-to book. Because the message seems to be "Write your butt off and prepare to fail!"

I would simply say, "Don't give up your day job, but if you have a passion for writing, remember that there are places like Goodreads and blog sites where you can get published rather than being punished." Have a great time writing and also have a great time reading this book while you're at it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Tunnel through. Stretch the line to the limits of the possible. It will be hard, and it will be a torment, but that is the writing life.

As Julian Barnes said in "Flaubert’s Parrot", "It’s easy, after all, not to be a writer. Most people aren’t writers, and very little harm comes to them." However, for those who choose the writing life, it is a different story.

The writing life is tough and you will often hate it. There will be days when you are cooped up, engaged in this silent struggle of reading and writing, while life seems to pass you by. Many might not consider such a day as a good one. But a life spent reading and writing - that will be a good life.

It is a life of exploration, of pushing boundaries, of expressing the inexpressible. It is a life that may bring joy, frustration, and everything in between. But in the end, it is a life that makes sense, a life that is worth living.

So, if you feel the call of the writing life, don't be afraid to answer it. Embrace the challenge, endure the torment, and let the words flow. Because in the end, it is through writing that we can leave our mark on the world and make a difference.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Every paragraph in this text is truly stunning. I have a hardback copy of it, and I especially cherish the previous owner's occasional marginalia.

On page 14, Dillard pens: "Flaubert wrote steadily, with only the usual, appalling, strains. For twenty-five years, he completed a big book every five to seven years. I surmise that full-time writers, on average, produce a book every five years; that's seventy-three usable pages a year, or a mere usable fifth of a page a day. The years that biographers and other nonfiction writers invest in amassing and mastering materials are neatly paralleled by the years novelists and short-story writers spend fabricating solid worlds that conform to immaterial truths. On numerous days, the writer can crank out three or four pages, yet on many other days, he realizes he must discard them."

To this, the previous owner exclaims, in disbelief, "? Absurd—writers write much more." And then, a few lines further down, reasons, "Maybe without a computer?" It makes one wonder how the writing process has evolved with the advent of modern technology and whether the previous owner's assumption holds any merit.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Beautiful essays on writing.

It's not a how-to guide, but rather a metaphorical deglamorization of what it means to be a writer. The essence is that writing is agonizing work and those who are sane might well avoid it.

In her most dramatic moment, Dillard likens being a writer to being a stunt pilot. Stunt pilots pen poetry in the sky with their loops and spins. The audience is awestruck by this beauty and envisions how magnificent it must feel. Yet, in the cockpit, the pilot endures splitting headaches and intense pain from the various pulls and tugs of gravity. To make matters worse, he can't even glimpse the art he's crafting.

While I suspect this book will deter some would-be writers (as is its intention), those of us acquainted with the headaches and agony of constructing sentences will likely discover glorious inspiration within its pages. Writing is not glamorous nor is it overly easy. It demands a significant amount of time and a great deal of effort. I suspect most of us question if perhaps we are crazy for engaging in it. Dillard affirms that we are indeed crazy, but there is great delight in hearing this from another insane individual. She is someone who comprehends both the struggle of writing and the inability to cease.

July 15,2025
... Show More
One of my goals this year is to persist in my pursuit of reading as many books about the craft of writing as possible. This month, I made up my mind to pick up Pulitzer Prize winner Annie Dillard’s renowned book of essays on the craft, \\n  The Writing Life\\n, about which I had heard numerous positive things.


Indeed, when I commenced reading the book, it was truly captivating, and I found myself highlighting many insights that deeply resonated with me. However, unfortunately, as the book advanced, it began to become increasingly less accessible to me. Dillard’s prose is refined and lyrical, and indeed, her metaphorical descriptions of things are exquisitely rendered. But in my opinion, there was an excessive amount of it, to the extent that it felt overwhelming. After a while, it became progressively more difficult to pay attention. My mind started to wander, and I ultimately had to re-read certain passages several times. Putting the book down and picking it back up a few days later did offer some assistance, but not to a great extent. Fortunately, the book was very concise (a little over 100 pages), so I was able to persevere and complete it (although it took me nearly a week to do so, which slightly bothered me).


Overall, I believe this book simply wasn't suitable for me, especially at this juncture in my life. While I did appreciate the insights it provided (I did jot down a few things that were beneficial and that I definitely wish to remember), it came across as a bit too intellectually pretentious and abstract in some aspects for my liking. This is why I decided to assign it a median rating of 3 stars. Perhaps if I were to revisit this book at a later stage, when my journey as a writer is more developed, I will have a greater appreciation for it.
July 15,2025
... Show More

There is no scarcity of good days. However, it is good lives that are truly elusive. A life centered solely around the pursuit of pleasurable sensations through good days is insufficient. The life of sensation is one of insatiable greed, constantly demanding more and more. In contrast, the life of the spirit requires less and less. Time seems abundant, and its passage is sweet. While some might not consider a day spent reading as a particularly good day, a life dedicated to reading - that is indeed a good life.


As I see it, Jack Benny always aspired to be a virtuoso violinist. He could play reasonably well, but knowing he lacked true genius in playing, he was rather disheartened. So, he would pretend to be terrible at playing for comical effect. Indirectly related, when our kids first started full-time school and I, as a stay-at-home mom, was floundering for something to do, my husband suggested, "You love to read and you have all this free time, why not write a book?" I was slightly shocked. If I had had a copy of The Writing Life by Annie Dillard at that time, I could have pointed to any page and said, "This is why not, and this, and this."


In The Writing Life, Annie Dillard laments the commercialization of book writing and the trend of writing books for those who don't like to read. Today, this might include books like Fifty Shades Of Grey and Twilight. These are not works of genius and were not written for book lovers. However, they did manage to get non-readers reading. So, is that really such a bad thing? Their existence doesn't directly affect me, but it does make me a little sad. If I were to try writing a book, it would inevitably be a crass commercial attempt, as I know I don't possess the spark of genius. Just as I could splatter paint on a canvas and never be Jackson Pollack, I could produce words on a page and never be Annie Dillard.


"Why are we reading, if not in hope of beauty laid bare, life heightened and its deepest mystery probed? Can the writer isolate and vivify all in experience that most deeply engages our intellects and our hearts? Can the writer renew our hope for literary forms? Why are we reading if not in hope that the writer will magnify and dramatize our days, will illuminate and inspire us with wisdom, courage, and the possibility of meaningfulness, and will press upon our minds the deepest mysteries, so that we may feel again their majesty and power? What do we ever know that is higher than that power which, from time to time, seizes our lives, and reveals us startlingly to ourselves as creatures set down here bewildered? Why does death so catch us by surprise, and why love? We still and always want waking."


This is why I read, and, as sadly as Jack Benny with his violin, why I will never write. The Writing Life contains many beautiful passages and perceptive observations. If nothing else, it has prompted me to explore Annie Dillard's novels, despite being forewarned that they can be dense and challenging, and hopefully, written for those like me who love to read.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Annie Dillard's The Writing Life is a rather curious read.

At just sixty-eight pages, it presents a somewhat scattered view of her writing process. She admits to "fooling around" a lot, and the book is filled with obscure metaphors and descriptions of her non-writing activities.

One of the concepts she explores is the idea that the writing life is freedom. However, she also acknowledges that the process of writing is not free at all. It requires planning, outlining, editing, and revising.

Towards the end of the book, she seems to go against her earlier views, but unfortunately, she never resolves these contradictions.

Another aspect she writes about is how awful being a writer can be. She claims that the life of a writer is colorless and sensory-deprived. But I think this is an exaggeration. Writers do live through experiences and then analyze and recreate them.

Overall, I found the book to be a bit of a disappointment. While there were a few things I liked, such as her description of her workspace and some of the pilot story, I had hoped for more practical advice and insights into the writing process.

Annie Dillard's writing style is also a bit of a hindrance. Her sentences are often short and choppy, and her ideas seem to jump around randomly. She would perhaps be better suited to writing comic strips than serious non-fiction.

In comparison to Ayn Rand's The Art of Nonfiction, which offers more practical and useful advice, The Writing Life falls short. It's a shame, because I really enjoyed Dillard's short story "Total Eclipse." But this book just didn't live up to my expectations.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Meandering, reflective, and a bit ethereal.

These are the words that come to mind when I think about the work I just read. Overall, I found it truly enjoyable and inspiring.

I must admit that I am not overly familiar with Dillard's work. However, I picked up this particular piece out of respect for her reputation and also because of the number of people I know who highly appreciate her work.

After reading it, I can say without a doubt that it was well worth the read.

The way Dillard weaves her words together is simply captivating. Her descriptions are vivid and detailed, allowing the reader to truly immerse themselves in the story.

The reflective nature of the work made me stop and think about my own life and experiences. It was as if she was gently guiding me to look within and find inspiration in the simplest of things.

The bit of ethereality added an extra layer of mystery and charm to the piece. It made me feel as if I was in a dreamlike state, floating along with the words and ideas.

I am so glad that I took the chance and read this work by Dillard. It has opened my eyes to a new world of literature and has left me with a sense of wonder and inspiration.

I would highly recommend this work to anyone who is looking for a thought-provoking and enjoyable read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Annie Dillard's book had a profound impact on me, especially in the prescriptive sections.

She emphasized the importance of writing the story into itself and allowing oneself the time and space to explore. As a writer, it was refreshing to read about how writing is indeed hard work, although I still struggle to fully believe it.

However, I found the second half of the book less engaging and relevant. I fundamentally disagree with her assertion that as writers, our subject should be literature rather than the world. I believe that our environment and the world around us play a crucial role in our writing.

I often felt a mix of jealousy and annoyance when reading about the beautiful secluded islands she retreats to for her writing. It seemed a bit too idealistic and out of touch with the real world.

Moreover, the extended bit about her crush on the stunt plane driver at the end left me quite bored. While I understand it was a metaphor, it felt odd that she delved so deeply into the beauty of it without addressing the context of the authoritarian ruler.

Perhaps this comes back to her focus on beauty and craft over any commitment to the world or environment. Annie Dillard has always been a complex figure for me. The people I hold dear love her work, but I've never quite found what I was looking for in her books.

Nevertheless, her ideas and perspectives have made me think and reflect on my own writing process, and for that, I am grateful.
July 15,2025
... Show More
My first taste of Dillard was truly an unforgettable experience.

As I took that initial bite, a burst of flavors danced on my tongue, leaving me craving for more.

The unique combination of ingredients, the perfect balance of spices, and the rich, indulgent texture all contributed to making it an absolute delight.

It was not just a meal; it was a sensory adventure that awakened my taste buds and left a lasting impression.

From that moment on, I knew that it was good enough not to be my last encounter with Dillard.

I look forward to many more opportunities to savor its delicious offerings and explore the wonderful world of flavors that it has to offer.

Whether it's a casual lunch or a special dinner, I am confident that Dillard will always deliver an exceptional dining experience that will keep me coming back for more.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Astonishing!

It's as if she has an in-depth understanding of every single feeling I have regarding writing. The truly astonishing aspect, however, is that she is able to express those feelings in words with such precision and clarity. I was so engrossed in the book that I basically underlined the entire thing.

Consequently, I'm not going to list my favorite quotes here. Instead, I know for sure that I will return to this book time and time again.

It was an incredibly inspiring, encouraging, and beautiful read. It made me feel as if I'm not alone in my writing journey and that there are others who share the same passion and understand the joys and struggles that come with it.

I can't wait to explore more of her works and see how they continue to impact and inspire me.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.