Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
33(33%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Mailer has crafted this piece from the first-person narrative perspective of the demon entrusted with Adolf Hitler's development.

The story delves into the Hitler family history and the early/developmental years of young Adolf, as recounted by a minor devil.

This book, however, failed to truly engage me.

In narrating the tale, Mailer examines numerous possible explanations for why Adolf Hitler evolved into a monster.

Some of these are rather interesting - potential inbreeding, an abusive father, a profound inferiority complex.

Nonetheless, overall, the story tends to plod along.

One never truly empathizes with any of the characters, not even the narrator (which I suppose is a good thing considering the main characters are all evil and the narrator is a devil).

But after a while, I found myself asking: why am I reading this?

That being said, the writing is, of course, outstanding.

As is always the case when reading Mailer, it is advisable to have a dictionary close at hand.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A classic case of a book that owes any success to the name of the author.

If someone named "Buzzajoni" had written it, you most likely wouldn't have ever heard of it.

The narrator, a mysterious SS man who is later revealed to be an exceptional presence, provides us with a detailed account. He gives us young Adolf from the moment of his birth, as well as Hitler's father and mother, his sisters and brothers.

Moreover, he delves into the intimate details of Hitler's childhood and adolescence. We learn about the early experiences that might have shaped the future dictator.

It's a fascinating look into the life of one of the most infamous figures in history, presented through the eyes of this mysterious narrator.

However, it's important to note that the success of this book may be more due to the notoriety of the subject matter and the author's name rather than the literary merit alone.

Nonetheless, it offers a unique perspective on Hitler's early life and is sure to capture the attention of readers interested in history and the making of a dictator.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The writing had been polished to a certain extent. However, I found myself growing increasingly tired of the rather scatological focus that seemed to pervade it. As a result, I decided to put an end to it.

On a different note, I have a great appreciation for Mailer as a stylist. His use of language and the unique way he crafts his sentences are truly remarkable. There is a certain elegance and sophistication in his writing that draws me in and keeps me engaged.

Despite my aversion to the scatological aspect of the particular piece I was working on, I still maintain my admiration for Mailer's overall stylistic abilities. It is this admiration that continues to inspire me in my own writing endeavors.

I look forward to exploring more of Mailer's works and learning from his masterful use of language and style. Maybe one day, I can incorporate some of his techniques into my own writing and create something equally as captivating.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This book evoked a plethora of conflicted emotions within me. As someone who adheres to a Jewish lifestyle, I was appalled to find myself experiencing a certain degree of understanding for Adolf Hitler. Nevertheless, I believe that this text, which is rooted in Mailer's own Jewish heritage, might have been his way of rationalizing the heinous acts that occurred without explicitly stating "this is what I think." It is a fictionalization that endeavors to make sense of the senseless. People frequently question why the Holocaust happened in relation to God, asking, "Why would He allow this?" Perhaps Mailer's answer lies in placing the story in the hands of the devil.

For those contemplating reading this book, it could be beneficial to peruse Mailer's "On God" to gain an understanding of his perspective on God. His conception of God is distinctively his own creation (God as the artist, who makes mistakes and is a learning, growing entity). This provides valuable context for interpreting the themes and ideas presented in the book.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Evil is not something that one is born with; rather, it is created.

Norman Mailer takes us on a journey through the dark side, a creepy, dysfunctional, incestuous, and self-perpetuating place. He uses the early life of Adolph Hitler, both real and imagined, as a model. The guide is a minion of the underworld, a devilish spirit assigned by the "Evil One" or "Maestro" to be the spiritual genius or a kind of "guardian angel" of young Adolph. Adolph's father, Alois, is a product of a 19th-century patriarchal authoritarian culture that values brag and swagger. His well-intentioned mother, Klara, like the rest of the family, is completely subjugated. When Adolph is six years old, his father retires from a successful career as an Austrian Customs Official, buys a farm, and takes an interest in beekeeping. Young Adolph finds this fascinating. The hum of the hive, the efficiency of the process, and the way the drone bees are eliminated when they are no longer useful all seem perfectly natural to him. He learns that efficiency and subjugation are the keys to getting the most honey.

Like C. S. Lewis, Mailer deftly probes the twists and turns of evil. However, the book is rich in irony as it does not elaborate on the nature of good. The minion refers to God as the "Dummkopf" because of the many flaws in creation. "He does see Himself as the Divine Artist. Of course, He is also a blunderer - so many of his creations are botched. A good many are disasters which He then proceeds to plow back into the food chain. That is His only means of keeping multitudinous, mediocre and often meaningless spawnings from choking the existence of the rest. Yet, I will admit, He is dogged. He is still looking to improve His previous creations."

However, the idea of God as a micromanager runs contrary to the concept of free will. It is His antithesis, who resents the notion of free will among us, that seeks to manipulate human affairs like a totalitarian puppet master, confusing subjugation with leadership.

Mailer gives us a fascinating meditation on the nature of evil by one of the giants of American letters.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Pure stubbornness is the sole reason that led me to finish _The Castle in the Forest_. Mailer portrays young Hitler in a way that a simpleton Freud enthusiast might envision: filled with mother love, sexual transgression, and anus cleaning.

The novel commences with a long-winded discussion regarding Hitler's genealogy and inbreeding. I have perused numerous captivating and even empathetic accounts of incest, yet this one did not fall into that category. We are made to witness Hitler's father sleeping with whomever he can lay his hands on and his "hound" as well, with an abundance of needless details. Gratuitous sexual acts and analogies persist throughout the novel. So much so that by the time one of the sons begins receiving blowjobs from younger boys and elderly men, I was not overly astonished. Hitler's childhood experiences hold some interest, but they are overshadowed by anus cleaning, masturbation, games with feces, and such. All of Hitler's major traits are linked to sexual perversion; his trademark mustache stems from his sister's pubic hair, and the Nazi salute from his ability to keep his arm and penis raised simultaneously when the schoolboys compare their units around the urinal. It could potentially be an interesting perspective on Hitler, but due to Mailer making everything crude or sexual or both, it becomes difficult to endure his story and impossible to take the analysis seriously.

The other overly discussed topic is his retired father's new occupation as a bee keeper. I was already extremely tired of hearing about excrement and bee-keeping when Mailer veered off into, as you might have guessed, bees' excrement. Unbelievable.

The sections on novel writing and the struggles between good and evil are by far the most engaging. I anticipated Norman Mailer to have fascinating insights, and indeed he does. However, even these sections do not reach their full potential. And when your narrator continuously apologizes and explains his lengthy digressions to the reader, shouldn't that serve as a red flag?

The novel did possess two advantages: it made me desire to read more Grimm's fairy tales, and the audio version had a rather good reader in Harris Yulin. He has a powerful voice and differentiates each speaker adeptly, and I assume that he deliberately made Hitler's father horribly irritating. I'm just sorry that Yulin had to read all of this book, although at least he was compensated for it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a truly strange book.

When you combine elements from "The Screwtape Letters", "Rise and Fall of the Third Reich" and "The Secret Life of Bees", you can get a sense of what this book is like, although my comparison doesn't do justice to the three excellent books mentioned above.

The story chronicles the formation of the young Adolph Hitler and the events leading up to his birth that influenced his nature. Honestly, this book would bore a neo-Nazi to tears. It might be great if you are interested in beekeeping, incest, or the Austrian Customs inspection techniques of the 1800s.

Although it's not easy to identify with the most despicable man in recent history, since the story focuses on Hitler as a youth, he seems distant and disconnected from what he will become. For this reason, reading the intimate details about his bathroom habits, hygienic rituals, and imperfect anatomy was more disgusting than engaging. I just wanted to finish the book quickly.

In fact, I found a bookmark from a previous library patron about one-third of the way through, and I suspect that's as far as they got before returning it. A lot of research and time went into creating this book, but from Mailer, I expected more.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I simply couldn't bring myself to complete this book.

It's a story about Hitler during his youth, and while Norman Mailer has chosen a captivating subject, he presents it in a rather disjointed manner, incorporating elements of the fantastic and supernatural.

This approach ultimately detracts from the overall narrative instead of enhancing it.

The book doesn't seem serious enough to be considered a fictionalized biography, yet it's not entertaining enough to be classified as a fantasy novel.

As a result, I found myself at a loss as to how to engage with it, and I've decided to put it aside for good.

It's a real pity, as the potential of the subject matter was great, but the execution left much to be desired.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Castle in the Forest is a remarkable work that serves as both the memoir of a demon named Dieter and a biography of young Adolph Hitler and his family. Dieter, assigned by Satanic forces, provides a unique perspective on Hitler's early life. Hitler, born with a single testicle and an unbearable body odor, was the result of a complex web of incest. His grandmother gave birth to his father Alois after coupling with a cousin, and then Alois slept with his stepsister, Klara, who later became his wife after obtaining permission from the Vatican. Their union produced Adolph Hitler.
Mailer's account of the sexual mores in the Austrian agricultural community is brutally honest, even including a scene where the devil is present during Hitler's conception. The novel creates an animalistic world filled with sex and carnality, exploring Hitler's relationships with his mother and half-sister, as well as the mating habits of queen bees. However, the book does not fully succeed as a horror novel due to its demon's point of view. Instead, it is cold, disturbing, and sinister, yet also rather dreary.
Mailer lines up a cast of real and perhaps fictional characters, all of whom are creepy and cruel. The novel focuses excessively on Alois, Hitler's father, a womanizing brute who would whip his children without hesitation. There are also other characters like Der Alte, the lonely apicurist with a lecherous interest in young Adolph and his brother. The novel takes detours to historical events such as the coronation of Nicholas II and the stampede of Khodynka, which was plotted by the devil and his allies. Mailer's style of excess, while creating some demonic set pieces, also works against the novel at times, as seen in the long and boring bee keeping adventures of Alois.
Overall, The Castle in the Forest is an ambitious novel that, despite its flaws, offers a disturbing and thought-provoking look at Hitler's early life and the forces that may have influenced him. It serves as a warning to those at a crossroads and leaves readers wondering what other great characters and events would have been explored in the planned sequels.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Love it.

Well, I truly love this author. Their works have a unique charm that always manages to captivate my heart.

Every word they pen seems to be carefully crafted, painting vivid pictures in my mind and evoking a wide range of emotions.

Whether it's a thrilling adventure, a heartwarming romance, or a thought-provoking mystery, this author has the ability to transport me to another world and make me feel as if I'm a part of the story.

I can't get enough of their writing and eagerly await each new release.

It's like a literary treasure trove that I can always turn to for entertainment and inspiration.

This author has become a favorite of mine, and I will continue to support and follow their work for years to come.

I just can't help but love it!
July 15,2025
... Show More
I absolutely adored this book!

It is an author that I am pleasantly surprised to discover, with a cynical writing style just as we love them.

I had previously read "Hitler's Father" which is a very good complement as it relates the same facts with more details.

This new book offers a fresh perspective and delves deeper into the subject matter. The author's unique writing style makes the story engaging and keeps the reader hooked from start to finish.

The characters are well-developed and the plot is full of twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat.

I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good read and is interested in learning more about this fascinating topic.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The writing in this piece is truly beautiful and lyrical, which initially grabs the reader's attention.

However, as one delves deeper, the narrative ultimately proves to be disappointing.

The text spends at least a hundred pages exploring the intricacies of apiculture.

While this may be interesting in its own right, the connection between this content and the development of Adolf Hitler's psyche completely eludes me.

It seems rather disjointed and leaves the reader wondering how these two seemingly disparate topics are supposed to be related.

Perhaps there is a deeper meaning or hidden connection that I am failing to grasp, but as it stands, the lack of a clear and coherent narrative detracts from the overall quality of the piece.

It is a shame, as the beautiful writing holds so much promise, but without a more engaging and logical storyline, it falls short of its potential.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.