Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
37(37%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
The original text seems to be a link to an article titled "29 Primeiras Estórias" on a WordPress blog. To expand it to 300 words, we could write something like this:


The link https://1001livrosbrasileirosparalera... leads to an interesting collection of 29 first stories. These stories likely offer a diverse range of perspectives, themes, and writing styles. They might take readers on various literary journeys, exploring different emotions, experiences, and ideas. Whether it's through fictional tales or real-life accounts, these stories have the potential to engage, inspire, and entertain. By clicking on the link, readers can embark on a literary adventure and discover the unique voices and narratives within this collection. It's an opportunity to expand one's literary horizons and gain a deeper understanding of the Brazilian literary landscape.

July 15,2025
... Show More

There are some works that, being literary landmarks, although not hermetic or encrypted, are not accessible to all readers. Some of them, precisely because they try to emulate a popular speech, become almost impenetrable to those not initiated in the "speech" that the work wants to mimic.


This is what happens with Guimarães Rosa's Primeiras Estórias. Readers interested in the "little story" or in superficiality will probably have problems reading Rosa. They will finish the reading without understanding anything and complaining. The fact is that Rosa's work is, in the best sense of the term, an experience. It is no coincidence that many try to reproduce what he did, without success, generating only clumsy and bizarre caricatures.


Besides the use of neologisms, the author's text has a musicality, a rhythm, that a hasty reading makes impossible to appreciate. Even a silent reading needs to be done allowing the "inner voice" to declaim the text. Attempts to read Rosa mechanically produce a truncated, disjointed and poor reading.


It is also worth pointing out the references and plays that the author makes with elements of Universal Culture, with the sounds of different languages and with the sounds of our own language. Rosa's text is similar to some types of musical composition, works for two or more voices.


The author's ability to involve us with very little text is impressive. Primeiras Estórias is a roller coaster of emotions. We are taken from childhood innocence to the processing of grief and madness, passing through scathing social criticisms and texts that can only be described as beautiful. But again, not all texts lend themselves to merely rational analyzes.


As much as the idea of "feeling" bothers me, it is undeniable that Rosa's narratives are based on a spectrum much more related to emotion than to reason. Some of his texts refer to experiences so particular that for those who do not live that reality they seem unreal or even silly.


Undoubtedly, Primeiras Estórias is a good gateway to get to know Guimarães Rosa and an excellent introduction before venturing into his masterpiece: Grande Sertão Veredas. We have here beautiful, reflective texts and the use of language almost to its limits. However, the truth must be told, similar to what is said about wines, here the reader needs maturity and a refined palate to truly appreciate it. It is a text that requires some humility, that the reader "take off his shoes" because this is definitely not just any ground.

July 15,2025
... Show More

João Guimarães Rosa is a master of irony, capable of creating an inimitable atmosphere in all his tales. Each story is like a myth, written in the style of a parable.
In The Thin Edge of Happiness, a young boy on a trip suddenly grasps the cruel nature of existence. Happiness is possible, but it is fragile.

Everything was softened by melancholy, even the day; that is, the coming of twilight. Nightfall is sorrowful everywhere. The stillness stole out from where it was kept. The boy was soothed in a half-frightened way by his own despair; some inner force was working in him, putting down roots to strengthen his soul.

The stories are diverse and vivid. An attempt at revenge turns into a frivolous party. Secret love becomes obvious. A pickpocket climbs a palm tree. A Woman of Good Works is an ambiguous tale of an equivocal crime.
Well, according to what I heard, the man she murdered was a villain, a cur in the form of a man, and a most horrendous calamity, danger, and scourge to the people of this place.

A little girl tells incredible stories. A bride is abducted. An amnesiac man ascends to heaven. The mystery of The Horse That Drank Beer remains unsolved. And there are many other enigmas.
In The Third Bank of the River, a man figuratively becomes a third bank of the river.
Father stepped into the canoe, untied it, and began to paddle off. The canoe slipped away, a straight, even shadow like an alligator, slithery, long.
Our father never came back. He hadn’t gone anywhere. He stuck to that stretch of the river, staying halfway across, always in the canoe, never to spring out of it, ever again.

Time is a river, and each of us is an island in the stream.

July 15,2025
... Show More
A number of appetizing aperitifs, alluring starters or delicate delicacies

that completely fascinate and confuse. They lose themselves in the mouth

and roll around to land softly like manioc roots in the stomach

and then follow me forever in my dreams.

Typically.
July 15,2025
... Show More
In fact, it's 3.5 stars, because I really liked most of the short stories that make up this book. The half star that is missing from the four is entirely due to my difficulty, at times, in following the original, inventive and sometimes extremely strange prose of Guimarães Rosa. It demanded a great effort from me at times, forcing me to read some sentences more than once, and at other times to imagine them being said orally, until I could understand their meaning.

Here is an excerpt from the short story "A benfazeja", one of the ones I liked the most and, for some reason, it made me remember "O Leproso", from "Novos Contos da Montanha" by Miguel Torga.

"I know they didn't pay attention to the woman; it wasn't possible. Living too close, in a small village, with loose arms, people get rid of people slowly. People don't see again those who aren't worth it. Do they still think it wasn't worth it? Yes, well, yes. In what they didn't even think about; and they didn't ask, about a lot of things. Why? The woman - a slacker, a mess, dirty with herself, pitied, so old and ugly, made dizzy, not repentant in the crime - and guide of a blind man. You all never suspected that she could arch herself in the most closed extreme, in the domains of too much?"

Of course, when the reading requires more effort, it ends up taking away a little of the pleasure of reading, although towards the end, I noticed that it was becoming less, as I was getting used to the language. Now it's a matter of gathering courage, to throw myself into the Grande Sertão!
July 15,2025
... Show More
Uma obra que não é fácil de descrever. Guimarães Rosa é um escritor que não se encaixa muito bem nas caixinhas que a maioria dos críticos literários gostam de criar.


A escrita de Guimarães Rosa é repleta de neologismos e tem um grau de oralidade imenso. Até considero que este livro é dos poucos de ficção em que a versão audiobook não sofreria muitas perdas em relação ao texto escrito. Aliás, muitas vezes, principalmente quando uma frase que ao ser lida parece difícil de compreender, ler o texto em voz alta ajudou na compreensão.


Um dicionário e um caderno para apontar os neologismos do Guimarães Rosa são dois instrumentos essenciais para a leitura de "Primeiras Estórias". Nesta coletânea de contos, o escritor mineiro usa o sertão, que consiste aproximadamente na região norte de Minas Gerais, sudoeste da Bahia e leste de Goiás, como cenário das suas histórias. Há de tudo um pouco mas destaco as crianças, os valentões e os loucos. Tudo isso num ambiente quase sempre muito pobre e miserável.


A profundidade dos textos é enorme e eu acredito que nesta leitura eu tenha apenas arranhado a superfície na maioria deles. Há muita filosofia, muita reflexão. Há até incursões ao sobrenatural. Os meus contos favoritos foram: "Famigerado", "Sorôco, sua mãe, sua filha", "Os Irmãos Dagobé", "A Terceira Margem do Rio", "O Cavalo que bebida cerveja", "Luas de Mel" e "A Benfazeja".


Este ano fez 30 anos que li este livro pela primeira vez para a escola e naquela época havia sido uma leitura praticamente impossível. O texto de Guimarães Rosa é demasiado inacessível para uma leitura escolar. Se ainda fosse algo supervisionada, poderia ter tido algum valor na época. Foi sim orientada para as provas e nada mais. A edição que li, da Global Editora, tem um longo texto de fortuna crítica no final.


Para finalizar, além de recomendar a leitura (que deve ser feita lentamente), destaco algumas frases do livro que têm a cara de Guimarães Rosa:


1. Era uma viagem inventada no feliz. (As Margens da Alegria)


2. Seu pensamentozinho estava ainda na fase hieroglífica. (As Margens da Alegria)


3. Aquele homem, para proceder da forma, só podia ser um brabo sertanejo, jagunço até na escuma do bofe. (Famigerado)


4. Ali, antenasal, de mim a palmo! (Famigerado)


5. A gente estava levando agora o Sorôco para a casa dele, de verdade. A gente, com ele, ia até aonde que ia aquela cantiga. (Sorôco, sua mãe, sua filha)


6. A gente teve de se acostumar com aquilo. Às penas, que, com aquilo, a gente mesmo nunca se acostumou, em si, na verdade. (A terceira margem do rio)


7. Eu sofria já o começo de velhice — esta vida era só o demoramento.


8. Eles se olhavam para não-distância, estiadamente, sem sabêres, sem caso. Mas a Moça estava devagar. Mas o Moço estava ansioso. (A terceira margem do rio)


9. Meu Amigo, não. Disse um “Oh” polissilábico, sem despesas de emoção. (Fatalidade)


10. Iam-se, na ceguez da noite — à casa da mãe do breu: a vaca, o homem, a vaca — transeuntes, galopando. (Sequência)


11. Tudo, aliás, é a ponta de um mistério. Inclusive, os fatos. Ou a ausência deles. Duvida? Quando nada acontece, há um milagre que não estamos vendo. (O Espelho)


12. Tão branco; mas não branquicelo, senão que de um branco leve, semidourado de luz: figurando ter por dentro da pele uma segunda claridade. (Um moço muito branco)


13. Sou remediado lavrador, isto é — de pobre não me sujo, de rico não me esporcalho. (Luas de mel)


14. Me passei para o lado do velho, junto — … tapatrão, tapatrão… tarantão… tarantão… — e ele me disse: nada. Seus olhos, o outro grosso azul, certeiros, esses muito se mexiam. (-Tarantão, meu patrão)


15. Enquanto a gente brincava, descuidoso, as coisas ruins já estavam armando a assanhação de acontecer: elas esperavam a gente atrás das portas. (Os cimos)

July 15,2025
... Show More

Observation of the little boy in 'Appearance of the Bird': 'But, in this shining moment, he knew and discovered: that you could never truly, in terms of value, enjoy the beautiful or good things that happened. Sometimes, because they came quickly and unexpectedly, when you weren't ready yet. Or they were expected, and then they didn't taste as good as they were, just crude imitations. Or, because the other things, the bad ones, also continued, on both sides, and left no room open. Or because still other things were missing, which happened in all kinds of situations, but which had to come together with that first one to make a whole. Or because, even while they were happening, you knew that they were on their way, towards their end, gnawed at by the hours, disintegrating...'

This passage presents a profound exploration of the complex nature of experiencing and enjoying the good things in life. The little boy realizes that there are numerous factors that can prevent us from fully savoring these precious moments. Whether it's the element of surprise, unmet expectations, the presence of negative aspects, or the absence of complementary elements, all these can impact our perception and appreciation of the beautiful and the good.

It makes us reflect on how often we may take the good things for granted or fail to truly cherish them in the moment. We are reminded to be more aware and present, to make the most of the opportunities that come our way, and to strive to create a more complete and fulfilling experience by addressing the various factors that can influence our enjoyment.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Zeer zeer bijzonder taalgebruik, neologismen bij de vleet en opvallende zinsconstructies. This makes the reading experience quite unique and engaging. The language used seems to break free from the ordinary, adding an element of mystery and excitement.


The atmosphere of the stories is often philosophical and lyrical. It's as if the author is trying to convey deep thoughts and emotions through the power of words. The stories seem to draw their existence from the evoked atmosphere, which gives them a certain charm and allure.


However, the actual content of the stories is often difficult to follow. It requires a great deal of concentration and effort to understand the meaning and significance behind the words. This is perhaps one of the challenges of reading such works, but it also makes the experience more rewarding.


I have previously read 'Het uur en ogenblik van Augusto Matraga', and that went quite well. It was an enjoyable read that kept me engaged from start to finish. Now, I have 'Diepe wildernis: de wegen' left to read. I'm looking forward to it, but I think I'll let it sit for a while before delving in. JM

July 15,2025
... Show More
Contos were published after Grande Sertão: Veredas and Corpo de Baile. Then, there was already Guimarães Rosa. These are shorter stories, contrary to the copious stories he had written before. It seems that here he wanted to condense things. Even if there is not exactly an order, there are some interesting things to observe. The first one - As margens da alegria - and the last one - Os cimos - have a connection. Moreover, the story that is exactly in the middle of the book - O espelho - is almost an essay, it is almost Jorge Luís Borges and his obsessions with mirrors. It is also worth comparing this story with "O espelho", a story by Machado de Assis.

There is a bit of everything. It seems that he wrote the stories for newspapers and magazines.

I didn't like Darandina. It is a rare urban story written by Guimarães, but perhaps it is a bit too full of the author's mannerisms. Everything is a bit exaggerated in terms of style.

On the positive side, there is a lot of good stuff. There are the more famous stories. Perhaps the best known is "A terceira margem do rio", full of symbolism, but there are other good things. I would recommend looking at the less well-known stories. There are many hidden gems in the book.

A particularly touching story is "Sorôco, sua mãe, sua filha", in which he exposes the feminine as the central part of existence.

Also, if you find them (depending on the edition), look at the drawings in the index. A very curious thing.

Finally, a book to be read slowly. Guimarães Rosa - and this perhaps holds even more true for this book - is an author to be read very slowly, carefully chewing each word or phrase.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Lightning Review/in the style of "Cherish" by The Association


There are some clunkers scattered here and there within this collection. However, on the whole, it is a pretty damned fantastic little assortment. The highs, and there are numerous of them, are truly breathtaking. A few of these pieces are even immortal. One can only hope that the price of this and all of Rosa's books will come down soon through reprints. A general rule of thumb regarding this thing is that if it involves horses, it is probably not very, um, good.


Lightning Review rating: Moonlight on Vermont affected everybody. It seems that this particular work has had a profound impact on all who have come across it. The beauty and charm it exudes are palpable, leaving a lasting impression. It's as if the moonlight itself has cast a spell on the readers, drawing them into a world of wonder and enchantment.

July 15,2025
... Show More
When nothing seems to be happening, there is a miracle that we are not seeing.

Often, in the midst of the ordinary and the mundane, something extraordinary is taking place right before our eyes. We might be so focused on the lack of obvious change or progress that we overlook the subtler signs of a miracle unfolding.

It could be a small act of kindness that has a profound impact, a moment of inspiration that leads to a breakthrough, or a series of seemingly coincidental events that come together to create something beautiful.

We need to train our eyes and hearts to be more attuned to these hidden miracles. By looking beyond the surface and being open to the possibility of the unexpected, we can discover the magic that exists in every situation.

So, the next time you find yourself in a situation where nothing appears to be happening, remember that there might just be a miracle waiting to be revealed.
July 15,2025
... Show More

He put on his hat and decided to say goodbye to us.

Perhaps he was leaving in search of a different kind of existence, one that was both close and far from his family.

Maybe he felt a longing for something more, something that couldn't be found in the familiar surroundings of his home.

As he walked away, we watched him go, wondering what the future held for him.

Would he find what he was looking for? Or would he come to realize that what he had left behind was truly precious?

Only time would tell, but for now, he was gone, and we were left to deal with the void he had left in our lives.

 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.