Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
36(36%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Zelda Fitzgerald has finally received the recognition she deserves in this fabulous jazzy age treatment.

She was part of the tragic duo, Scott and Zelda, who shone brightly for a time. Zelda was truly ahead of her time. She was "Beat" long before Jack Kerouac coined the term.

She was associated with the flappers, those young women who defied traditional norms and embraced a more liberated lifestyle. Zelda also had her own philosophies, which added to her allure and complexity.

Her story is one of passion, creativity, and ultimately, tragedy. In this new treatment, her life and contributions are being explored and celebrated in a way that they have long been overdue.

It is a reminder of the impact that Zelda had on the cultural and literary landscape of her time, and how her legacy continues to resonate today.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this book in 1980. At that time, I was deeply attracted by it.

Now, with the new interest in F. Scott Fitzgerald emerging, I have decided to read it again.

The first time I read it, I truly enjoyed it.

Zelda, the wife of Fitzgerald, was an extremely interesting character. She was not only nuts in a literal and clinical sense but also had a captivating charm. In fact, I found her to be much more fascinating than her husband.

However, her life had a very sad ending. Despite having an interesting, restless life, it ultimately ended in sadness.

As I prepare to read the book again, I am looking forward to rediscovering the story and gaining a deeper understanding of Zelda and her tragic life.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The captivating and legendary story of Zelda and Scott Fitzgerald is meticulously laid out in this engaging biography of the troubled girl hailing from Alabama.

Amidst Zelda's mental instability and Scott's excessive drinking, it remains a mystery as to which issue emerged first. Did Scott's heavy drinking drive Zelda to the brink of madness, or was it Zelda's unpredictable behavior that led Scott to seek solace in alcohol? What is certain, however, is that Mrs. Fitzgerald unwittingly provided a wealth of material for Mr. Fitzgerald's novels, sometimes even duplicating entire passages from her personal journals.

The biography itself is a well-written and thoroughly researched piece of work. Some readers may find it overly in-depth, particularly the sections where Zelda's novel and a couple of Scott's are analyzed in great detail over several pages. Nevertheless, I believe Nancy Milford was skillfully highlighting the striking parallels between their lives and their literary works. This biography is an absolute must-read for literature students, offering a fascinating glimpse into the complex and intertwined lives of two iconic figures in American literature.

July 15,2025
... Show More
What truly stands out, even more显著 than the somewhat melancholy tale of Zelda the Flapper and F. Scott the Philosopher, is Milford's remarkable tenderness towards both of them, even in the face of their personal excesses. Zelda's descent into madness appears to be inherited schizophrenia. The manner in which her life unfolds might have exacerbated the disease, but it seems as if nothing could truly halt its inexorable progress. F. Scott's near-obsession with her as the central female character in his fiction perhaps did more harm than good, for it never granted her the space to become the person she truly was. There are inklings of that character which lie beneath the surface of the character Fitzgerald creates in his fiction, but since his fiction relied so heavily on his reaching back into the past, especially his and Zelda's shared past, Zelda remains elusive.

This is an important addition to the Fitzgerald "mystique". Reading the story from a perspective sympathetic to Zelda is highly enlightening compared to the typical treatment of the pair, which tends to focus on Scott and treat Zelda as an accessory, or even the "cause" of the alcoholism that subdued and limited his life's work to three great novels, one not-so-great novel, an unfinished novel, numerous short stories of varying quality, and a couple of movie credits. With the publication of Gatsby, which, as Milford notes, he "dragged up out of his gut", intimating a painful birth of America's great 20th-century novel, his potential, in the eyes of readers, editors, admirers, and other writers, seemed boundless. However, this, it seems, was more of a burden than a blessing, for no matter what he did after Gatsby, it would never be sufficient. He was trapped by his own literary brilliance, the excesses of his times, and in the downward spiral of Zelda's disease. That he felt it his responsibility to write better and more brilliantly, to financially support Zelda's treatment, and to justify his drinking, trapped him in a vortex from which he could not, and did not, escape. Nor could she. Their complex lives and their complex life together tell a sad tale that is more captivating than anything either of them ever wrote.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I never thought I'd have any inclination to read about Zelda Fitzgerald.

Initially, my perception of her was influenced by my prior reading of all about Hemingway, who didn't hold her in high regard.

However, one day, I came across the information that she died in a fire in a mental hospital. This fact piqued my interest, leading me to purchase the book.

I'm glad to report that I wasn't disappointed. While I still don't "like" Zelda, this extremely detailed book has made me understand her as a person to a greater extent.

It is truly one of the better biographies I've ever read. Of course, F. Scott Fitzgerald is an integral part of the story.

After reading about Zelda, I no longer feel the need to read his biography as Nancy Milford has already told me everything I ever wanted to know about him.

I have a penchant for reading about the 1920s and those glamorous Americans abroad during the years between the wars.

This book provides all the intricate details, and it didn't surprise me in the least that their lives weren't as grand as the pictures might suggest.

The price they paid for all the debauchery was evident. I liked the book as it evoked a sense of pity for Zelda, this fragile, mentally ill china doll.

I won't read it again, not because it's not good, but because it serves more as an educational book rather than one for pure pleasure. It is, without a doubt, the most thorough book I've read on life between the wars.
July 15,2025
... Show More



  Please don't be depressed: nothing is sad about you except your sadness...



A few obvious points:


--> Nancy Milford conducted in-depth research. She delved deep into understanding the Fitzgeralds, leaving no stone unturned.


--> The life of Zelda and her husband is an interesting study for numerous reasons. Their story is a complex tapestry of love, dreams, and struggles.



  When man is no longer his own master, custodian of his own silly vanities and childish contentments he's nothing at all—being in the first place only an agent of a very experimental stage of organic free will



I was captivated by the exploration of two people who were products of their time and place. They seemed to shine brightly in their dreams, but in reality, they grappled with the unreality of ideas and the burden of mental illness. It's a difficult task to determine how much Zelda's illness influenced their lives. On one hand, perhaps it was due to her illness that she had qualities that Scott found desirable. Without them, their life would have been completely different. On the other hand, because of this illness, they seemed doomed from the start. (Thankfully, today we are better equipped to deal with mental problems, with effective medications available.)



  It was as though they were waiting for something to happen



However, to me, there were too many book interpretations and a bit too much analysis of letters. While I could understand the Fitzgeralds better through those citations, I would have preferred if Milford had sometimes just written her conclusions (rather than long quotes). I'm sure that someone who is more familiar with the Fitzgelards' books and more formally educated in literature will enjoy this biography more than I did.


In summary, it was a thoughtfully written biography, and the story of Zelda and Scott was truly fascinating. Nevertheless, reading it could be tiring at times.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I was already familiar with the general outline of the Fitzgeralds' relationship. After all, who isn't? However, I gained a wealth of additional knowledge about them from this biography. It originated from an academic thesis, and while I could have done without the excessive direct quotes from the Fitzgeralds' letters, especially as Zelda's writing became less coherent. I did appreciate it when the author would draw conclusions and extract the main ideas. I simply wish she had done this more frequently.

Zelda was rather exhausting. She appeared to be deeply self-absorbed and troubled, yet also lacking in depth. She caused a great deal of confusion and pain to those around her, but didn't contribute much in return.

Despite that, the book was interesting, thorough, and easy to read. I'm glad I read it. It's just a pity that, in real life, there wasn't more substance beneath the glamour and never-ending drama of Zelda and Scott's lives. This book, although lengthy, seemed to emphasize that there was very little behind the façade.

Overall, it was an engaging read that provided valuable insights into the complex relationship of the Fitzgeralds. It made me reflect on the true nature of their lives and the price they paid for their fame and fortune.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I don't often read biographies. However, this particular one, which is all about Zelda Fitzgerald and also delves quite a bit into Scott Fitzgerald, was truly remarkable.

It offers a fascinating glimpse into their lives, the era they lived in, and a plethora of related topics.

If you have an interest in Zelda herself, her relationship with Scott, the Roaring Twenties era, the complex issues of mental illness and addiction, the iconic flapper culture, the art of writing, or the many facets of love, then I wholeheartedly recommend this book.

It is a rich and engaging read that will surely captivate your attention and leave you with a deeper understanding and appreciation of these important aspects of history and human nature.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Incredible story of love, dependency, and mental illness. Zelda was truly an artist in her own right. She had her own unique vision and talent. I'd like to think that if she had received the correct diagnosis, she would have been able to stand firmly on her own two feet. However, Scott, despite his love for her, unfortunately, planted too much doubt in her mind. His excessive dependence on alcohol only made the problems in their marriage worse. Instead of constantly trying to "fix" her, he should have been focusing on working on himself. Alas, the life of a suffering artist is often filled with such complex and tragic circumstances.

July 15,2025
... Show More

While this is an extremely thorough biography of the life of Zelda Fitzgerald, I was ultimately left exhausted by her story. I've come across other Goodreads reviews that place the blame on F. Scott Fitzgerald for her insanity. However, it's important to note that schizophrenia is an inherited disorder and not an acquired disease. Typically, it manifests in late twenties or even during the teen years. Back when I was a third-year medical student, we were taught not to focus solely on the content of a schizophrenic's speech but rather on its pattern. As the speech became more incoherent, we would increase the patient's medications. Reading this biography, I couldn't help but wonder when these medications became available.


And so my dilemma lies in whether I actually enjoyed this book. I found the story profoundly fascinating and yet, at the same time, it was all together too tragic. This is ultimately the story of two clearly brilliant individuals. One was the professional writer, who also happened to be an alcoholic. The other was his chanteuse wife, who unfortunately became schizophrenic. I constantly found myself wondering if Zelda, had she not lost her mental balance, would have gone on to become an even better writer than her husband. There are hints that while Fitzgerald used alcohol as a crutch, he was ultimately a fairly disciplined writer. Zelda's writings, on the other hand, contain moments of beautiful and elegant prose. She initially clung to her husband but later desired independence. Sadly, Fitzgerald blamed her for ruining his life as he was financially burdened by supporting her in mental institutions. I can see the egotism in Fitzgerald, as well as his underlying insecurity, but also an incredible love for his wife. Throughout her illness, despite finding love elsewhere, he kept the flame of hope burning for Zelda, encouraging her to use her creativity as a source of salvation. In the end, both were consumed by their demons, and yet, in their heyday, they shone as the brightest of all stars.

July 15,2025
... Show More
My initial impulse is to give this book a one-star rating. Seriously, what the heck, F. Scott Fitzgerald? I would rate his life as one star too.

However, Nancy Milford did an excellent job of depicting Zelda and Scott's extremely dysfunctional, codependent, and abusive relationship. For this, I praise her. She was meticulous with her sources and citations. Some might argue that it was to a fault, as some chapters did seem to drag on. But ultimately, I found it interesting to select which aspects of Zelda's life I wanted to know in great detail and which could be quickly skimmed over.

The first half of the book is somewhat entertaining. Zelda was wild and humorous, but in a way that makes you wince because you know she is on the verge of a complete breakdown. Then, as expected, it takes a truly dark turn and leaves you feeling completely empty inside. Nevertheless, it was still cool, and I enjoyed reading it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I think I read this when I was recuperating from an automobile accident. I had a lot of time on my hands during that period.

It was truly very enjoyable. In fact, it got me so engaged that I started looking for books on Fitzgerald, the Murphys, Dorothy Parker, and the whole crowd. In other words, it opened up a new world of literature for me.

She did have mental problems, and if you examine her entire life, you can see these problems surfacing here and there.

I believe she wrote only one book. Lately, I have heard it questioned, either in print or in interviews, whether she was actually talented in writing. And there is also the speculation that this might be the reason she went to the sanatorium, because Scott couldn't bear to compete with her. However, I don't buy that argument. She may have had some talent, but was she as talented as he was? Or were people only interested in what she had written because of who she was married to?

She was a madcap woman from the twenties. She would jump into fountains and act in a zany way. Others also had their moments of zaniness, but they were never considered wacky enough to be locked up. They had their madcap moments, while she actually went mad.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.