Awful writing! It is needlessly vague and infuriatingly sanctimonious. I eagerly anticipated section four (a chapter of ONLY short "epigrams and interludes"), hoping that the valuable gems hidden beneath the rest of the dross would be distilled and separated. Unfortunately, the brevity of each statement leaves many completely unproven, resulting in broad (often idiotic) generalizations. Also, Nietzsche, what's with all the em-dashes? Do you think you're Emily Dickinson?
While I am about to recommend reading only the introduction, I must criticize this assessment: "[The book's:] significance lies not only in the stylistic excellence--Nietzsche was a consummate artisan of the German language" (xxiii). HA! The second half of this sentence IS more accurate: "[it:] is marred only occasionally by a failure to elaborate a thought or idea fully."
Other than the absurdity of claiming this to be "stylistic excellence," the introduction provides a clear, relatively succinct overview of every section of the text. Another plus is that it leaves out the intense derision pervasive in Nietzsche's voice.
I wonder if I had read this 125 years ago, would I have enjoyed it more? Perhaps I would have thought, "Wow, someone is finally attacking the blinding and diminishing dogma of religion! Nietzsche's confidence is inspiring and his strong attitudes are just what are needed!" However, living in a much more secular age (thank god!) and having the benefits of 135 years to expound on Darwin's initial discoveries, reading Nietzsche's obnoxious mini-rants today strikes me as either, "Duh" or "Well, he's actually quite mistaken there." Our "entire instinctual life" is not based on the single, most primal drive of "the will to power." [The second reaction was often a result of having recently read Boyd's evolution of cognition and fiction and Wright's evolution of God.]
*Christianity is "an ongoing suicide of reason...nonsense and superstition" (44-5). The Bible is "perhaps the greatest audacity and'sin against the spirit' that literary Europe has on its conscience" (49).