The posthumous, Pulitzer Prize-winning play is from the only American playwright who ever won a Nobel Prize for Literature. This play offers an absolutely agonizing, autobiographical portrayal of an American family from the first half of the 20th century. It is a powerful and poignant work that delves deep into the complex relationships and inner turmoil within the family. Sadly, it's probably all the more relevant here in the first half of the 21st century. The issues and themes explored in the play, such as family dynamics, alcoholism, and the search for meaning and identity, still resonate with audiences today. O'Neill was truly a master of the dramatic form, able to create characters and situations that are both realistic and deeply affecting. His work continues to be studied and performed around the world, a testament to his enduring legacy as one of the greatest playwrights in American history.
The play under discussion is a true masterpiece that delves deep into the lives of the Tyrone family. It is a story filled with lunacy, rheumatism, addiction, alcohol, whiskey, morphine, Shakespeare, consumption, and tragedy. James Tyrone, Mary, Jaime, and Edmund all find themselves in a state of chaos and turmoil in one boozy, morphine-soaked afternoon.
This drama is not only one of the finest but also one of the most wrenching I've ever experienced, both on the page and on the stage. As James Tyrone Sr's acting career is on its last legs, the family retreats to their summer cottage at the Monte Cristo home in Connecticut.
As the day turns to night, we are introduced to James' two sons. Jaime is brutish yet gentle, while Edmund, who is dying of consumption, is sensitive. There's also Kathleen, the maid, and finally, Mary Tyrone, the matriarch and one of the most unforgettable female protagonists. The play is a domestic drama that showcases a battle of wits between the parents and their sons, who alternate between blaming and comforting each other in quick, brutal moments.
Mary's addiction to morphine is a result of Tyrone's miserly ways and the pain of giving birth to Edmund while Tyrone was on the road. The morphine has only made her more delusional and masochistic. She misses her father and punishes herself constantly for not being the ideal daughter. James is often obsessed with making a quick dollar, which leads him to fall prey to money-making schemes that leave him broke. Jaime turns to drink to cope with his brother's illness and his father's role in their mother's addiction. Edmund, shy and sensitive, seems stunted in his growth, trapped in a childlike state as everyone awaits his death.
The play is cruel, with some of the most lacerating dialogue I've ever heard or read. It also explores the theme of toxic love. No wonder it set the tone for Edward Albee's "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?" several years after its production in 1956.
The 1962 film adaptation, directed by Sidney Lumet and starring Katharine Hepburn as Mary, is my favorite incarnation of this tragic anti-heroine. The performances of Ralph Richardson as Tyrone, Jason Robards as Jaime, and Dean Stockwell as Edmund are also wonderful, capturing the tragedy in glorious black and white.
I've had the opportunity to see three live productions of this play. The 2016 Broadway revival, starring Jessica Lange as Mary, had its flaws but was still affecting. The 2018 production at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, with Jeremy Irons as James and Lesley Manville as Mary, truly captured the poetry of O'Neill's broken heart. The third production, a modernized version set in the Covid era in Connecticut in 2021, was a misfire, as much of the drama and heart of the play had been chopped off.
I often debate with friends about which of the big three American Dramas has the most mentally unstable characterizations - Mary Tyrone, Blanche DuBois, or Willy Loman. I'd say they are all about equal, but Mary is the most sympathetic as she has never deliberately tried to ruin or be cruel to anyone.