...
Show More
There are two Herman Melvilles. On one hand, there is the author of such remarkable books as Moby Dick and Billy Budd, works that have left an indelible mark on the literary world. On the other hand, there is the philosophercaster who presented us with the never-ending dialogues in Mardi and The Confidence Man. At the outset, it seemed as though this was going to be an engaging book. However, as one delved deeper, it became evident that it dragged on interminably. The text is replete with philosophical dialogues, within which it is extremely challenging to discern who said what. The lack of clarity in attributing the various statements makes it a rather tiresome read, despite the initial promise of interesting philosophical musings. One wishes that the author had found a more effective way to present these ideas, perhaps with more distinct voices for each character in the dialogues. As it stands, the book struggles to maintain the reader's interest and fails to fully realize its potential.