Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
29(29%)
4 stars
35(35%)
3 stars
36(36%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

Two short stories in the collection really caught my attention. The first and by far the most significant one is "The State of the Art". This story seems to offer a unique perspective on something, perhaps on the current state of a particular field or an aspect of society. It makes me wonder what exactly the author is trying to convey through this narrative.


The second story that piqued my interest is "A Gift from the Culture". I'm curious to know what this gift is and how it relates to the overall theme of the collection. Maybe it's a symbolic gift that represents a certain value or tradition within a specific culture. As I read these stories, I find myself delving deeper into the world created by the author, eager to uncover the hidden meanings and messages.


Overall, these two stories have drawn me in and made me excited to explore the rest of the collection. I'm looking forward to seeing what other literary treasures await me within its pages.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a collection of short stories by Iain M. Banks.


The stories Road of Skulls, A Gift from the Culture, and Descendant are all well-written. They introduce interesting concepts that draw the reader in. However, just as the stories start to get really interesting, they end abruptly.


Odd Attachment is like a dark one-liner joke in short story form. It is super short, yet amusing and disturbing at the same time. Cleaning Up is a slightly longer anecdote that had me chuckling.


Piece I read and then immediately forgot what it was about. Scratch I didn't understand at all.


Finally, The State of the Art, which makes up the majority of this book and gives the book its name, has several interesting ideas. It takes a fun look at humanity and ties into some of the other books in the Culture series. However, even this story still feels like it ends before it reaches its full potential.


Overall, most of the stories in this collection are well-written, entertaining, and thought-provoking. But they all share the drawback of feeling incomplete, ending just as the reader starts to get fully immersed in them.
July 15,2025
... Show More
When I was younger, I had the pleasure of reading most of Banks' science fiction novels. So, when I saw this collection of his short stories in the library, I couldn't help but pick it up.

Overall, it was an okay read and there were moments that I found enjoyable. However, when compared to my memories of his best works, it was more or less a disappointment.

The longer namesake story had great potential. I thought the comparison between the technologically superior Culture and 70's Earth civilization was an interesting concept. But in the end, it felt like a missed opportunity.

The age-old question about the meaning of life and other things was handled in an overly superficial and downright carnivalistic manner. Of course, this was probably done intentionally by Banks, but for me, it just felt lackluster.

Perhaps my expectations were too high, but I couldn't help but feel that this collection didn't quite measure up to his previous works. Nevertheless, it was still an interesting read and I'm glad I gave it a chance.
July 15,2025
... Show More

"The State of the Art" is a remarkable small masterpiece. Ostensibly, it falls under the genre of science fiction. In this story, aliens hailing from a highly developed society come to study the human condition in the 1970s. However, beneath this seemingly straightforward plot, Banks delves deep into seeking the true essence of human nature. The question that plagues us is why humans are so inherently destructive and overly obsessed with material prosperity. Banks presents a rather dire answer to this conundrum. Yet, amidst the bleakness, I managed to find a glimmer of hope in Linter's profound love for humanity. This love serves as a counterpoint to the otherwise dismal portrayal of human nature. It shows that even in the face of our flaws and vices, there is still a capacity for love and compassion that can potentially redeem us.

July 15,2025
... Show More
"The State of the Art" is the fourth volume of Iain M. Banks' Culture cycle.

It has a particularity: it is a collection of short stories, the only one among the nine novels that make up the cycle.

The work owes its title to the longest story in the collection, and perhaps the best in my eyes. The other stories range from good to anecdotal, but it is really "The State of the Art" that gives the collection all its interest, perhaps with "Descent" also standing out from the rest.

The exercise of "rating" a collection of short stories is always delicate. Should one take into account the best, the worst, or some sort of average of the stories that make it up? Here, I have chosen to focus on the strong impression left by the eponymous story of the collection, even though overall the collection is not as good as the first three novels of the cycle.

Each story in the collection offers a unique perspective and exploration within the framework of the Culture universe. Some may not reach the same heights as the title story, but they still contribute to the overall tapestry of ideas and concepts that Banks presents.

Despite its shortcomings compared to the earlier novels, "The State of the Art" still has its moments of brilliance and is worth reading for fans of the Culture series and those interested in thought-provoking science fiction.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Some stories are amusing, making us burst into laughter with their light-hearted humor.

Others are interesting, captivating our attention with their unique plots and characters.

And then there are those that are thought-provoking, making us stop and reflect on the deeper meanings of life.

However, while each of these types of stories has its own charm, they may not be enough to fully wrap the wonder and hold our attention for an engulfing read.

We often crave something more, something that can transport us to another world, make us feel a wide range of emotions, and leave a lasting impression.

Maybe it's a story that combines all these elements - a touch of humor, an interesting premise, and a thought-provoking message.

Or perhaps it's a story that takes us on a wild adventure, challenging our beliefs and expanding our horizons.

Whatever it is, we continue to search for that perfect read that can fully satisfy our thirst for wonder and entertainment.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The original article is not provided, so I can't rewrite and expand it specifically. However, I can give you a general example of how to expand an article to about 300 words.

Let's assume the original article is: "The sun is shining brightly today. The sky is blue and there are no clouds. It's a beautiful day."

Expanded version:

The sun is shining brightly today,

casting its warm and golden rays all over the place.

The sky is a vivid shade of blue,

as if it were a vast canvas painted by an artist.

There are no clouds to be seen,

making the sky look even more clear and纯净.

It's truly a beautiful day,

perfect for going outside and enjoying the nature.

People can take a walk in the park,

have a picnic, or just sit and soak up the sun.

The birds are chirping happily,

adding to the peaceful and愉悦 atmosphere.

Overall, it's a day that makes one feel grateful and alive.

5:07
July 15,2025
... Show More
State of the Art is a captivating Culture novella enhanced by a few additional short stories. However, only one of these shorts can truly be considered part of the series. The short stories themselves are just okay, lacking that special something to make them truly stand out.

The novella vividly depicts what occurs when a Culture team arrives in 1977 to assess Earth and determine if first contact should be made. This is presented in a clever and realistic manner. The Culture agents spend a year on the planet, while their ship hacks every computer and downloads all available information. But a complication arises when one agent goes native and decides he wants to stay on Earth regardless of the decision. His conversation with fellow agent Diziet Sma (from Use of Weapons) is the highlight of the story. He expounds on the entire purpose of the Culture and unfavorably compares it to that of Earth. If you desire to understand the Culture, this story is a must-read. The finale is predictably disheartening as the Culture decides against first contact and essentially agrees to let us destroy ourselves, and the agent who intended to stay is killed in a random mugging.

So, perhaps the titular story deserves 4 stars, but the superfluous short stories bring the overall rating down to 3 stars.
July 15,2025
... Show More
If you have a penchant for the Culture series and are captivated by Iain M. Banks' masterful writing style, yet perhaps find the series' space warfare aspect not entirely to your taste, and are averse to its one-culture-to-rule-them-all undertones, then this book is an ideal choice for you.

My absolute favorite story within it was A Gift From the Culture. It exuded a sense that was both dark and despondent, yet at the same time, it held an element of revelation.

Odd Attachment, with its 'lovely' and humorous plot, came as a pleasant surprise to me as well.

And, of course, the eponymous The State of the Art novella, which is the crown jewel of this collection, truly delves deep into the whole concept of moral relativity. This, together with the view that suffering is the natural path to meaning, forms the overarching themes of the collection.

Without a doubt, this is my top Culture book thus far!

Ah, also, the stories in this book serve to prove to me that Elon Musk completely fails to understand Iain M. Banks and the Culture.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The titular story is truly a five-star gem. It captivates the reader from the very beginning, with its engaging plot and well-developed characters.

Likewise, the story about the guy and the suit is equally outstanding. It has a unique charm that keeps you hooked until the end.

And let's not forget the last one. It had me cackling with laughter! If you're an audiobook listener, you're in for a treat. The narrator's performance added an extra layer of humor to the already hilarious story.

Overall, these stories are a must-read or listen to. They offer a great escape from reality and will leave you entertained and satisfied. Whether you prefer to read or listen to your stories, these ones are sure to please.
July 15,2025
... Show More

More of the delicious Culture Series. Technology has truly come an incredibly long way. It has advanced to such an extent that it is outrageously vast, and this vastness always gives you an abundance of things to think about. The rapid pace of technological development has brought about countless changes in our lives, transforming the way we communicate, work, and even think. With the continuous emergence of new technologies, we are constantly faced with new challenges and opportunities. It makes us wonder about the future and how technology will continue to shape our world. Will it bring more convenience and progress, or will it also bring some negative impacts? These are all questions that we need to seriously consider. The delicious Culture Series will continue to explore the relationship between technology and culture, and bring you more in-depth insights and discussions.

July 15,2025
... Show More

- Between its pages, there is a high degree of irregularity and some striking curiosities.


Género. Relatos.


What it tells us. The book Última generación (original publication: The State of the Art, 1991) is a collection of science fiction stories (one, the one that gives the title to the volume, so long that we could speak of a short novel) by the author, along with a small essay (something common in his books of the saga) regarding the vision that Banks had about La Cultura.


If you want to know more about this book, without spoilers? Visit:


http://librosdeolethros.blogspot.com/...



This book offers a unique reading experience. The stories within it are filled with unexpected twists and turns, taking the reader on a journey through different worlds and concepts. The author's imagination is on full display, creating a vivid and engaging universe. The inclusion of the essay provides additional depth and context, allowing the reader to better understand the author's perspective on La Cultura. Whether you are a fan of science fiction or simply looking for something new and exciting to read, Última generación is definitely worth checking out.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.