Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
39(39%)
3 stars
30(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I've always regarded Saul Bellow as a writer whose works are truly worthy of a re-read. In the case of the classic 'Augie March', it even calls for multiple reads. I picked up 'The Victim' again about 10 days ago and noticed that I'd given it 4 stars the first time around. Strangely, I recalled feeling, if not exactly let down by my initial expectations, a bit underwhelmed. Nevertheless, I like to think that mental maturity, a by-product not merely of time but of life itself (combined with extensive reading), blesses one with the capacity for greater intellectual appreciation.

My immediate instinct after finishing the second reading of 'The Victim' this morning was to check its place within his body of work. I wasn't surprised to discover that this was one of his earliest works, specifically his second novel. The prose is still exquisitely tight and rich, yet his tendency to meander into verbosity and lead the reader on a circuitous path to the ultimate point, which made works like 'Humboldt's Gift' and 'The Dean's December' seem denser than they actually were, was absent. This was a writer still in the process of finding his voice, and not in a rush to do so.

What struck me most throughout the novel was the powerful metaphysical current that runs through it. Descriptions of the light, weather, and the characters' physical attributes abound. The sweltering, muggy New York summer (which I've experienced firsthand and can attest is far from pleasant) persists for the majority of the book, lending it an oppressive, stifling atmosphere. It's a dark, humid, sticky night, creating an almost Dostoyevskian sense of paranoia (strongly reminding me of Raskolnikov's guilt-ridden wanderings through the streets of St. Petersburg in 'Crime and Punishment'), setting the stage for the first encounter between the two key characters of the book: Asa Leventhal and Kirby Allbee. The latter appears out of nowhere to accuse the former of ruining his life by indirectly causing the loss of his job, thus setting off a downward spiral in which he loses his wife and ultimately his own sense of self and sanity.

The remainder of the novel delves into the push and pull between the two. At its core, the conflict is almost ideological and religious, concerning the role of God (or the lack thereof) in how man perceives and ultimately copes with tragedy and difficult circumstances. Allbee singles out and resents Leventhal's Jewish belief that justice is an almost insoluble spiritual matter, one left for the gods to decide. Leventhal, guided by his belief in predestination, refuses to take any direct responsibility for his role in Allbee's fate. After all, Allbee was never owed an existence by God, so why should he spend his days compensating for his ill fortune? On the other hand, fatalism doesn't sit well with Allbee's Christian ideal that the self has the opportunity, through penance, for moral transformation and resurrection. This is neatly encapsulated in one of their final interactions in the novel, after a chance meeting:

'You haven't changed much,' said Allbee.

'I wasn't the one that was going to change so much'.

Leventhal is compelled to confront this challenge to his beliefs throughout the novel. Towards the end, it falls to a close friend of his - perhaps Bellow's mouthpiece - to assist him in dispelling the notion that perhaps mankind has been endowed with rationality by God not to passively accept our lot, but rather to learn how to evolve, change, and be aware of our inner selves:

'Wake up! What's life? Metabolism? That's what it is for the bugs. Jesus Christ, no! What's life? Consciousness, that's what it is. That's what you're short on. For God's sake, give yourself a push and a shake'.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This statement seems to suggest that the work in question gives the impression that it was written by Bellow in a short period of time, but in a positive sense. It implies that perhaps due to his genius or some other remarkable ability, Bellow was able to produce something of great quality within a week.

It makes one wonder about the creative process that Bellow might have gone through during that time. Was it a burst of inspiration that allowed him to write so quickly? Or perhaps he had already done a great deal of thinking and planning beforehand, and was simply able to put it all down on paper in a short span.

Regardless of the reason, the fact that it feels like he wrote it in a week speaks volumes about the power and impact of his writing. It shows that even in a relatively short amount of time, he was able to create something that had a lasting impression on the reader.

Overall, this comment about Bellow's writing being done in a week is both a testament to his talent and a source of curiosity about the creative forces that drove him.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Leventhal is a man who is constantly filled with self-doubt. He is always wondering if the other person knows better than him.

Seemingly by chance, he meets an old colleague who blames him for a past incident.

I have never read any of Bellow's work before, and I found this book to be both frustrating and engaging.

I was never certain about Leventhal's character. Was he a victim, or was he just taking advantage of life?

This novel is beautifully written, with wonderful descriptions. It is both thought-provoking and infuriating.

It makes you question the nature of human behavior and the choices we make.

Despite its flaws, it is a book that will stay with you long after you have finished reading it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Rise and Fall of Ambivalence

Asa Leventhal's wife is away in another town, leaving him to fend for himself. He works for a trade magazine in Manhattan and has a relatively secure position there. However, some time ago, when he was unemployed, he sought a job at a different magazine. A friend of a friend had recommended him. This second man, Allbee, had made some extremely anti-Semitic remarks at a party that Asa attended. At the interview, the boss dismissed Asa rudely. Asa became aggressive and gave him a piece of his mind. Subsequently, Allbee lost his job and blamed Asa's behavior for it. But Allbee was an alcoholic and rather unstable. A couple of years later, Allbee suddenly shows up, looking very shabby, and demands reparations.

At the same time, Asa's nephew, who lives on Staten Island, is sick and probably dying. The father, Asa's brother, is working in Texas. The mother is suspicious of hospitals and doesn't take the kid there until it's quite late. Is she mentally unstable? Asa's mother had died in a mental institution. Allbee claims to be a victim, but he behaves like the Old Man of the Sea in the story of Sinbad. Asa can't seem to get rid of him. The kid is definitely a victim. You can see that Asa could potentially be a victim too. He isn't certain whether Allbee has a valid point or not. "Illness, madness, and death were forcing him to confront his fault" if he actually was at fault. He asks two friends, but they give very ambivalent answers or don't understand his dilemma.

In another of his novels that explores questions and introspection, Bellow creates a masterpiece of subtle and varying emotions. The characters (at this particular stage of their lives) are filled with ambivalence, yet they still harbor strong feelings. "The Victim" is a rich blend of philosophy and wonder within a most ordinary story. There is no sex or violence, yet the story manages to grip you. What about repentance and the fluctuating possibility of change? Should you repent for something that you feel wasn't your fault? What do others think of your behavior? Should you be concerned about this? In Bellow's novels, nothing has clear-cut edges. In the end, was all that doubt really necessary? It's truly brilliant.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.