This remarkable productivity has sometimes been misinterpreted negatively, as has her choice of themes. In the past, she was often advised to focus on "women's themes" and leave the "great social novel" to authors like Norman Mailer. Against the backdrop of this criticism, her 22nd book, "Foxfire: Confessions of a Girl Gang", almost seems like a return, as Oates engages with the dream of a feminist utopia in it.
The books of Joyce Carol Oates are often difficult to interpret. I can only speak for myself, but her socially critical works often leave me somewhat at a loss. I have to let these stories work in my subconscious for a long time before I can make assumptions about their meanings. With "Foxfire: Confessions of a Girl Gang", it took me several months to develop a suspicion of what the author wanted to tell me with this book. The realization was accompanied by an interesting observation: I couldn't settle on an interpretation because I was too close. I had to gain distance first to recognize what was right in front of my nose. I'm firmly convinced that this effect is no coincidence.
Joyce Carol Oates must have either deliberately forced it or at least tacitly accepted it because otherwise, it's not possible to explain why she let me dive so deeply into the first-person perspective of her unreliable narrator Maddy that I couldn't see the forest for the trees. "Foxfire" is a memoir framed by short references to the present. As an adult woman, Madeleine remembers her time as a teenager, as Maddy and as a founding member of the girl gang FOXFIRE. How necessary this separation between Madeleine and Maddy is for her becomes quickly obvious. Her descriptions are like a stream of consciousness, and she often writes without periods and commas, as if she were being carried away.
I could vividly imagine how she types faster and faster, leaving behind every boundary between the present and the past and reliving the events again. Maddy's experiences exert an enormous pull on her, which she can only withstand if she detaches herself emotionally. This makes "Foxfire" extremely authentic, but it wasn't always easy to follow her thoughts. Nevertheless, I instinctively understood how and why FOXFIRE came into being. The gang began as a sisterhood that took justice for women as its banner. It was an answer to many things, and within its ranks, the members found loyalty, dedication, love, and care. They were there for each other when no one else was, especially not the men in their lives, whom they all experienced as overbearing.
Therefore, it's no wonder that anger was a crucial binding factor in the dynamics of FOXFIRE. Its potential for violence was recognizable early and clearly; so it's no wonder that the gang quickly became criminalized because the girls intoxicated themselves with their anger, which was given an outlet for the first time. Female violence is thus a central motif in "Foxfire" – Joyce Carol Oates vividly describes how it arises, is channeled, and ultimately escalates. Therefore, I believe that the author wants to emphasize with this novel that female emancipation and feminism are inevitable. That's the message whose definition I struggled with so much. He who sows the wind will reap the whirlwind.
"Foxfire: Confessions of a Girl Gang" is a novel about the emancipation experience of young women in the 1950s. I thought for a while whether it could also be qualified as a coming-of-age story, but I came to the conclusion that this category is too weak for what Joyce Carol Oates describes in this book. The violence with which the girl gang FOXFIRE emancipated itself is too dominant for that. "Foxfire" has nothing to do with the description of a gentle, innocent awakening. Rather, it's about the dream of radical, vengeful equality that shatters when the gang goes too far. In the end, these young warrior women have to realize that feminism is not possible against society but only with it – and that includes men, of course. I found the reading hypnotic and extremely inspiring. It's a brutally feminist book that gripped me, as a female reader, mercilessly in my sense of justice. Whoever believes that women couldn't fight for their rights with all their might is very wrong.