There is so much to think about regarding this book. I believe that this, my first encounter with Oates' work, will remain with me for a long time. I can't recall exactly where I heard about this book, but once I did, I knew without a doubt that I had to read it. It took me a year and a half to finally get around to it, haha. It is a read that is sometimes heavy and sometimes tender, set in upstate NY in the 1950s. I think it would be worth a reread sometime in the future.
One of the beauties of this book is Oates' remarkable ability to subtly portray age and aging. Just by reading the words, I could sense the characters evolving from early teens to early adulthood, and then the narrator into later life. It was truly a captivating experience.
However, there are also some negatives. The later initiates to Foxfire, I suppose, were introduced to create the divisions that would ultimately contribute to the downfall. But they didn't really stand out as completely necessary or thoughtful additions to the plot. I wondered if the book could have managed just fine with only the central few characters.
Another aspect to consider is the heavy-handed use of racial slurs. Granted, it was the 50s, and one could argue that it was a reflection of the times. But personally, I didn't enjoy it. I only found it relevant in the scene with Marigold, where the Foxfire girls began to be quietly divided by prejudices, having grown into their own individuals yet still bound by an ideology formed years before. Otherwise, it felt rather surprising and unnecessary.