Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 38 votes)
5 stars
11(29%)
4 stars
17(45%)
3 stars
10(26%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
38 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was okay.

However, it didn't really reveal any new insights on the poets or their work.

It seemed rather平淡 and lacking in depth.

Perhaps more research could have been done to uncover some hidden aspects or unique perspectives.

The analysis might have focused too much on the obvious and failed to dig deeper into the true essence of the poets and their creations.

To make it more engaging and informative, it would be beneficial to explore different interpretations and offer fresh perspectives.

This could involve looking at the historical and cultural context in which the poets lived and worked, as well as considering their personal experiences and emotions.

By doing so, a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the poets and their work could be achieved.
July 15,2025
... Show More

The best kind of literary criticism is one that provides the reader with the background. And what context could be more infamous and stifling than the Hughes/Plath mythology? However, it doesn't rely entirely on this context. Instead, it still views the poetry for what it truly is - that is, poetry. Such literary criticism is well-researched, with a measured approach and thoughtful analysis. It delves deep into the works, exploring their themes, techniques, and emotions. By doing so, it enriches the reader's understanding and appreciation of the poetry. It doesn't let the overshadowing mythology cloud the essence of the literary works. Instead, it uses the background as a tool to enhance the exploration of the poetry itself. This kind of literary criticism is invaluable, as it allows the reader to engage with the poetry on a deeper level and discover its true beauty and significance.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Every time I believe that I have perused everything there is to be read regarding these two remarkable individuals, I unexpectedly stumble upon yet another book.

This particular volume offers a captivating exploration of "Birthday Letters" and the intriguing stories that lie beneath some of the poems. Frequently, these compositions were penned as a response to Plath's works.

It is a truly fascinating and deeply insightful read that has compelled me to once again reach for both their collections of poems.

The way in which the author delves into the minds and emotions of the poets, uncovering the hidden meanings and inspirations behind their words, is truly remarkable.

It has given me a newfound appreciation for their art and has deepened my understanding of their complex relationship.

I highly recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in poetry or in the lives and works of these two literary giants.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Amazing book but a difficult read. This statement holds true for many literary works that offer profound insights and unique perspectives. The book in question is no exception. It presents a complex narrative that challenges the reader's understanding and forces them to think deeply.


Reading it alongside "Birthday Letters" by Ted Hughes can be truly enlightening. "Birthday Letters" is a collection of poems that provides a personal and emotional account of Hughes' relationship with Sylvia Plath. By reading both works together, the reader can gain a deeper understanding of the themes and motifs that are present in both.


The combination of the two books offers a rich and multi-faceted exploration of love, loss, and the human condition. It allows the reader to see how different authors approach similar themes and how their unique writing styles can enhance and complement each other.


In conclusion, while the book may be a difficult read, it is well worth the effort. Reading it alongside "Birthday Letters" can provide a truly enlightening experience and offer new perspectives on some of the most fundamental aspects of the human experience.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is an outstanding introduction to the lives of both Hughes and Plath. It offers a detailed and fascinating exploration of their complex and intertwined lives.

To truly maximize the benefits of reading this book, it is essential to first read "Birthday Letters". "Birthday Letters" provides crucial context and background information that enriches the understanding of the events and emotions described in this book.

By reading "Birthday Letters" first, readers can gain a deeper appreciation for the relationship between Hughes and Plath, as well as a better understanding of their individual personalities and creative processes.

This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the lives and works of Hughes and Plath, and reading "Birthday Letters" first is the key to unlocking its full potential.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It is indeed true that poetry is not the same as biography.

Nevertheless, there are numerous confessional poets, and their life stories do offer context for their work.

However, the work can also stand on its own (at least, if it is well-written).

Plath is one of the most controversial and confessional poets of all time.

Hughes, her widower, finally broke his lifelong silence about his first wife, her suicide, and the aftermath when he published his first confessional work in Birthday Letters the year before his death.

In this book, the intersections of biography and the works of both poets are thoroughly explored.

The book is not merely a tour through the lurid details of the poets' lives; it is a worthwhile critical investigation.

It is a good read for anyone who is interested in Hughes and Plath as poets rather than as dramatic characters.

It provides valuable insights into their creative processes and the complex relationship between their personal lives and their artistic output.

Overall, Birthday Letters is an important addition to the body of work on these two influential poets.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I had initially begun reading Hughes’ Birthday Letters, but unfortunately, I didn't truly establish a connection with them. However, this remarkable and lovely book has been an absolute game-changer for me. It has not only assisted me in comprehending their beauty to a much greater extent but has also furnished me with an additional perspective through which to view one of the twentieth century's most astonishingly productive and yet destructive poetic partnerships.

The book is particularly outstanding in the sense that it undertakes a meticulous and in-depth analysis of the Birthday Letters. It doesn't stop there, though. It also has a wealth of profound insights and interpretations to offer regarding Plath’s late work. This comprehensive approach allows the reader to gain a more holistic and nuanced understanding of the complex relationship between Hughes and Plath, as well as the significance of their individual bodies of work.

Overall, this book has been an invaluable resource for me, enhancing my appreciation and understanding of these two literary giants and their remarkable contributions to the world of poetry.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Actually, this work is rated 3.5 and it is definitely worth reading if you have a desire to explore the mythology that surrounds the intertwined poetry and lives of Ted Hughes and Sylvia Plath. The author's analysis of poems from Hughes' "Birthday Letters" features rapid-fire transitions. I believe that had I actually read those poems, I would have felt more at ease with these transitions. I am not a die-hard follower of Plath, but the despair resulting from her mental illness and Hughes' unwavering examination of his role in the story are sufficient to make me want to revisit the poetry of both of them.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Snippets and tidbits, these are like little treasures that I discover along the way as I continue this writing journey.

Each one is a precious crumb that leads me forward, guiding my thoughts and inspiring my words.

Sometimes, it's a single sentence that pops into my head, filled with insight and wisdom.

Other times, it's a random idea or a fleeting emotion that I capture in writing.

These snippets and tidbits may seem small and insignificant on their own, but when combined, they form the building blocks of my writing.

They give my work depth and texture, making it more engaging and relatable to my readers.

As I continue to write, I look forward to uncovering more of these crumbs and using them to create something truly beautiful.

Whether it's a short story, a poem, or an article, I know that each piece will be enriched by the snippets and tidbits that I collect along the way.

So, I'll keep my eyes and ears open, ready to catch those precious moments of inspiration and turn them into words that will touch the hearts of others.

July 15,2025
... Show More
One could almost forgive Hughes' philanderings, were he not such a mediocre poet.

His actions in the realm of love were rather unseemly, but perhaps if his poetic talent had been truly outstanding, one might have been more inclined to overlook his flaws. However, the fact remains that his poetry fails to reach the heights that one might expect from a great literary figure.

I'm not interested in seeing Plath through his eyes. We had enough of that when he destroyed the journals she wrote in the months before her suicide.

It is a travesty that he chose to take such a drastic action, robbing us of the opportunity to gain a deeper understanding of Plath's state of mind during that crucial time.

"I did it. I." Yes, yes you did. And for your trouble, the far superior writer stuck her head in the gas oven.

His admission only serves to highlight his culpability in this tragic affair. Plath was a brilliant writer, and her untimely death is a loss to the literary world. Hughes' actions cannot be excused, and his reputation will forever be tarnished by his treatment of her.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Good use of poetry to tell their story.

Poetry has the power to convey emotions, experiences, and stories in a unique and captivating way. It allows individuals to express themselves with elegance and precision, painting vivid pictures in the minds of the readers.

When people use poetry to tell their stories, they can explore the depths of their feelings, share their joys and sorrows, and document their life's journey. Poetry can be a form of therapy, a way to heal emotional wounds and find inner peace.

Moreover, using poetry to tell a story can make it more memorable and engaging. The rhythm, rhyme, and imagery of poetry can add a musical and artistic quality to the narrative, making it more likely to resonate with the audience.

In conclusion, the good use of poetry to tell their story is a wonderful way for people to express themselves, connect with others, and leave a lasting impression.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This did look interesting indeed.

However, once I started delving into it, I quickly came to the conclusion that I simply didn't desire to invest so much time in reading about someone who had committed suicide.

Perhaps at some other point in the future, I might give it another try. But for the present moment, it is just far too depressing.

The subject matter seems to weigh heavily on my mind and emotions, making it difficult for me to fully engage with the text.

I need some time to distance myself from this rather somber topic before I can approach it with a more open and receptive mindset.

Until then, I will set this aside and focus on other things that can bring a bit more light and cheer into my life.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.