I first read this book nearly 10 years ago. At that time, I considered it to be just decent, not outstanding. However, after rereading it now, my perspective has changed significantly. It has gone from a mere 3-star decent book to a brilliant 5-star one.
Hearts in Atlantis is composed of 5 interconnected stories that revolve around America's baby boomer generation. The first and longest story, "Low Men in Yellow Coats", is set in 1960. It is a beautifully narrated tale about small town America and the end of childhood innocence. The child characters in this initial story serve as the link that runs throughout the remainder of the book. I truly adored Bobby and felt a deep connection with him. His love for books, his struggle with his mother after losing his father, his relationship with Ted Brautigan, his new elderly neighbor, and his love and protection for his girlfriend Carol Gerber were all so vividly portrayed.
The title story, set in 1966, really sets the tone for the rest of the book. It tells the story of a group of college freshmen and the chaos that surrounds them during a time when "boys with poor grades one year are likely to end up dying in the jungle the next year". The students discover love, political awareness, protest, and a highly addictive card game. The Vietnam War and the associated draft loom large over this story, as they do in the remaining 3 tales, which are set in the 80s and 90s as the baby boomers age and reflect on their lives.
So, why did this 10-year gap cause this book to go from good to great for me? I believe it's because I am now more mature (yes, older). Mr King is a generation ahead of me, and my view of life has undoubtedly changed as I approach the big 40. The prevailing theme throughout Hearts in Atlantis is that of lost innocence and wasted opportunities - of looking back and asking "what if?" I think every generation experiences the same thing - at some point in our lives, we reflect on all the possibilities we had and wonder how we ended up where we are.
If you are seeking a thought-provoking and well-written collection of stories, I hope you will give Hearts in Atlantis a try. However, if you are looking for traditional horror stories, this is not the book for you.
Five stars