Hearts in Atlantis is a distinct work by King. It is essentially a novel composed of two novellas and three short stories. Some might view it as a short story collection, but there is truly an overarching narrative that weaves through the five individual tales. Therefore, I will regard it as a novel.
Nevertheless, the drawback of this book is that it is rather uninteresting. The first novella, 'Low Men in Yellow Coats', is excellent and quite captivating. However, the title novella, 'Hearts in Atlantis', was extremely dull. As for the short stories, they seemed more like supplementary information rather than essential narratives.
Fortunately, 'Heavenly Shades of Night are Falling' salvaged this book from receiving a lower rating. It added a glimmer of hope and interest to the overall work, preventing it from being a complete disappointment.
Before you rush to criticize this review, it's important to note that I'm not overly fond of short story collections. I only delved into this one due to the Dark Tower tie-ins, and the first story truly delivered. In "Wolves of the Calla," Father Callahan shared part of his tale with our ka-tet, which included his travels along hidden highways and the persistent pursuit by the Low Men in Yellow Coats. So, I was eager to learn more about these mysterious figures through the first story in this collection.
What better way to begin than with this perfect little time capsule of 1960, those wonderful childhood days at the start of summer vacation with a couple of your closest friends. Every corner seems to hold new and exciting adventures, and those friendships feel like they'll last forever. Everything is going great until a mysterious old man moves in upstairs and the Low Men in Yellow Coats start snooping around. Sing it now... ♫ It’s a cruel (cruel), cruel summer, leaving me here on my own. ♫ This short story was truly awesome, pulling back the curtain on the Low Men. An easy 4+ stars.
Next, we fast forward to 1966 for the titular story "Hearts in Atlantis," which introduces some funny new characters. We follow these freshmen as they struggle to adapt to college life during a tumultuous time in the US, only to find themselves深陷 in a hellish Hearts tournament. The story started strong but then gradually devolved into a hippy diatribe against the Vietnam War. Sadly, once this topic was broached, it became clear that it would be the main focus of the remaining stories. I understand, war is hell, especially ones that should have been avoided. But I don't want to spend so much time dwelling on a war that could have/should have been prevented and all the lives lost. This story dropped to a low 3 stars for me.
The last three stories are much shorter compared to the first two, and aside from a couple of scenes with minor Dark Tower relevance, there's not much to note. Therefore, I'd rate each of these 2 stars. There are a few recurring characters that tie the stories together nicely, making the book more interesting than it otherwise would have been. However, my overall average for the entire collection is a meager 2.6 stars. I loved the first story and parts of the second, but I could have done without much of the rest.