Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
39(39%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a good introduction to the range of Raymond Carver's writing. However, it presents a rather mixed bag. I didn't enjoy it nearly as much as Carver's other collections that I've read, which consisted purely of short stories.

The short stories in this collection deserve a solid 4 out of 5. They showcase Carver's unique ability to capture the essence of human relationships and the ordinary yet profound moments in life. His writing style is简洁明了, drawing the reader in and making them feel as if they are part of the story.

The essays, on the other hand, receive a 3 out of 5. While they offer some interesting insights into Carver's life and work, they lack the same level of impact as his short stories. Some of the essays feel a bit disjointed, as if they were written for different purposes and then compiled together.

The poems in this collection are perhaps the weakest link, with a score of 2 out of 5. They don't seem to have the same depth or complexity as Carver's other works. Some of the poems are rather simplistic, and while they may have a certain charm, they don't leave a lasting impression.

Overall, while this collection does provide a good overview of Carver's writing, it doesn't quite measure up to his other works that I've read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is divided into three very distinct parts, hence my score, which in some cases is 4 and in others 2. Thus, I assigned it a sort of average.

In the first part, "Essays", I finally understood why Raymond Carver never ventured into a novel, always remaining with short stories, and I also got to know his roots and inspirations.

The second part is exclusively for "Poems", so it's the one I liked the least. Although I don't consider myself an appreciator of poetry, I read some interesting things, but not enough to pay more attention to them.

The third part, "Narratives", contains what I already know of Carver: stories not necessarily with a conclusion, but rather episodes from the lives of more or less normal people with lives along the same lines. In his precise and clean language, as always.

It was worth reading this book to understand a little more of the entire work of the writer.
July 15,2025
... Show More

⭐⭐⭐⭐ = Saggi e Racconti da Applausi, \\"NO\\" alle poesie

Carver, the essayist and short story writer, has completely convinced me. I simply couldn't choose between his role as an essayist and a narrator. I would say he is spectacular in both. However, as a poet, for my taste, he doesn't quite make it. Some of his poems manage to stand out, but for the most part, I would say the \\"no\\" prevails. His verses don't strike the right chords. The surgical precision, the \\"photographic\\" vision of the present, are narrative devices that work wonders on me in his short stories. And they work to perfection. But for poetry, I have very, very - very - difficult tastes. Only a few manage to touch those chords. Unfortunately, he doesn't succeed.

This collection was the first for me, and I would recommend it to anyone who wants to get to know this wonderful writer, who is fallible and human, capable of presenting us with fast-paced stories that get stuck in the eyes of the reader like Polaroids. Ordinary stories of ordinary people in an ordinary and violent America that always presents the bill. Fallible heroes like all of us. Because failure and regrets certainly don't take away the dignity of human beings who, despite the weight of addictions/imbalances/difficulties, get up every morning and try to move forward. With their heads held high. It's really beautiful.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Clear-eyed perspectives on writing and influences are what make Raymond Carver's work truly remarkable. His sentences have the power to "send a chill along the reader's spine," and he accomplishes this with great precision, especially in his stories.

I recently reread "Distance" because it is simply outstanding. Although I don't typically read poetry, I did give some of Carver's a try, and I particularly enjoyed "Drinking While Driving." Despite not being able to fully articulate why, I still rate his work as 5 stars in my book.

Moreover, Carver lists a plethora of his literary influences, which I hope will serve as my reading homework for the next few months. Exploring these influences will no doubt provide me with a deeper understanding of Carver's writing and help me appreciate his work even more. I'm excited to embark on this literary journey and see where it takes me.

Overall, Raymond Carver's writing is a must-read for anyone interested in literature. His unique style and ability to evoke strong emotions make his work truly unforgettable.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Again he doesn’t miss. I have to say that I found the essay “Fires” truly and deeply moving. It was as if the words on the page had the power to reach out and touch my very soul. The author's description of the fires was so vivid and detailed that I could almost smell the smoke and feel the heat. It was a powerful reminder of the destructive force of nature and the vulnerability of humanity. The way the author wove together personal experiences and broader themes made the essay not only engaging but also thought-provoking. I found myself reflecting on my own relationship with nature and the importance of protecting it. Overall, “Fires” was an outstanding piece of writing that left a lasting impression on me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This book consists of a selection of essays, seven short stories, and a collection of poems.

I have a great affection for short stories. Raymond Carver, without a doubt, is my favorite short story writer. I also have a penchant for essays. Carver pens some excellent ones that offer a glimpse into his autobiography and enhance my understanding of his short stories. I can discern where he derives some of his inspiration. He writes about his father, and for some reason, this aspect holds great significance for me.

The poems are just that - poems. If one has to read poems, I suppose these are worthy of perusal.

If you're a devotee of Carver, as I am, I assume you must read this book. However, it's not the one I would recommend to those who don't already have an inclination to read his works. The essays are valuable, but I'm not likely to dwell much on the poems (except perhaps the one about Bukowski that seems to have influenced his writing of 'What We Talk About When We Talk About Love'). The stories, of course, are of high quality, but there are only seven of them, and at least a few can be found in other collections (albeit in different forms).

Overall, this book has its merits, but it may not be the most accessible introduction to Raymond Carver's body of work.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This book consists of a collection of Carver's essays, about 50 poems and seven short stories.

The stories absolutely come close to the level of his collections Cathedral and Will You Please Be Quiet Please. However, the poems are of a lower level.

Perhaps it is due to Carver's style, which only comes into its own when he has the time to build up a tension arc.

Nevertheless, in combination with the essays, it is still a nice collection.

Overall, this book offers a diverse range of Carver's works. The essays provide valuable insights into his thoughts and perspectives. The short stories, with their characteristic Carverian style, engage the reader and draw them into the narrative. While the poems may not reach the same heights as his other works, they still add to the overall charm and complexity of the collection.

Whether you are a fan of Carver's previous works or new to his writing, this book is definitely worth a read. It allows you to explore different aspects of his literary talent and gain a deeper understanding of his unique style.

So, pick up this book and immerse yourself in the world of Raymond Carver.
July 15,2025
... Show More
According to the Afterword, Carver revised "So Much Water So Close to Home."

Although I was unaware of this while reading the version of the story in this book, I found myself far more engaged in (and disturbed by) the story this time around.

In Carver's interview with the Paris Review (included at the end of the book), he offers some insights into the purpose of fiction.

He states that it doesn't have to accomplish anything. It simply needs to exist for the intense pleasure we experience in creating it, and the distinct kind of pleasure derived from reading something that is durable, designed to last, and beautiful in its own right.

Something that emits these sparks - a persistent and steady glow, no matter how faint.

Not sure who would casually include sentences like that last one in a conversation - but I'll be damned if that kind of articulation isn't a compelling reason to read this book. :-)

Overall, Carver's work seems to offer a unique perspective on the power and beauty of fiction, and this book is well worth exploring for those interested in delving deeper into his literary world.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The essays in this collection are quite interesting, mainly offering insights into Carver's process. It's evident that his process is rather specific and uncomplicated.

The poetry within really appealed to me. The stories are also fairly engaging.

Carver clearly felt a sense of grievance regarding the edits made in the original publication of "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love", as three of those stories are presented here in a different format.

The version of "So Much Water So Close to Home" in this collection is, without a doubt, the best story he ever penned. I also had a great affection for "Where is Everyone?", which is much more unstructured and fragmented compared to anything else he wrote. It's also the most blatant story I've read so far about admitting alcoholism to oneself.

This collection is truly for fans only. It's specifically designed for those who might desire more personal insights into Carver.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**LO SCRITTORE COME MAESTRO E AMICO**

People were used to leaning their heads towards Carver to hear him better. Carver, rather than speaking loudly, would murmur and whisper. This was partly due to shyness and partly to humility. It was also in respect for the language, which made him handle words, both written and spoken, with great caution. As if it were almost impossible to say what one wanted. As if it were even dangerous.



Despite having taught creative writing for years, he seemed ill-suited to be a teacher: he didn't insist, didn't assert forcefully, preferred to listen rather than give lectures, didn't even consider the idea that among his duties was to discourage an untalented student, didn't know how to crush, and was deeply empathetic with everything his students submitted to him. However, this didn't prevent him from being rigorously analytical in the revision work: he would spend hours and hours on the works produced by his students, version after version, discussing word by word, punctuation marks, and spaces.



The father was called Clevie Raymond Carver, and for his friends, C.R. (Si Ar). The son, on the other hand, was Raymond Clevie Carver Junior. Carver hated being called Junior (which became GeiAr). It was okay as long as his father called him Frog (ranocchio). But then when ranocchio seemed too affectionate, they started calling him junior. This really didn't please Carver, and at the age of 13 or 14, he announced that he wouldn't respond anymore if he was called that. From that moment on, until his death, for his father, he became Doc – or, son.



What follows in italics refers to his father.


Then he died. I was very far away, in Iowa City, and I still had things to say to him.


I thought I would remember everything that was said and done that day and maybe that I would find a way to say it one day or another. But it wasn't like that. I forgot everything, or almost.


Father, I love you,
but how can I thank you, I who can't even stand alcohol,
and who don't even know the good places to fish?


The details of the poem are authentic, except for the fact that dad died in June and not in October, as the first word of the poem says. I wanted a word with more than one syllable to slow it down a bit. But more than that, I wanted a month suitable for what I was feeling at the moment when I wrote the poem, a month of short days and fading light, of smoke in the air, of things that are consumed. June was days and nights of summer, maturity, my wedding anniversary, the birthday of one of my children. June wasn't a month when fathers die.


In fact, my father died at the end of September, at the beginning of autumn.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This collection is rather forgettable.

However, there are a few exceptions that stand out.

The autobiographical essay at the beginning provides some interesting insights.

There are also a couple of poems that add a touch of creativity.

But the real gem of this collection is the final story, "So Much Water, So Close to Home."

This story is truly brilliant and very deep.

It explores complex themes and emotions in a way that leaves a lasting impression on the reader.

Overall, while the majority of the collection may not be particularly memorable, these few outstanding pieces make it worth a read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I really wanted to read this book mainly for the essays and poems, but ultimately I was also curious about the stories.

I have read a lot especially about men with alcoholism and fishing as a hobby.

Although with some stories at a certain point I got a bit distracted due to rather flatter characters (every time someone with a drinking problem as a character, then you kind of know it at a certain point), and everything was going a bit about nothing,

ultimately I was still charmed by his style. The last story also did a lot of good, by the way.

(And I had to read Raymond Carver anyway at some point).

This book offered a diverse range of literary works that initially attracted me with its essays and poems. However, as I delved into the stories, I found myself both intrigued and at times a bit disengaged. The recurring theme of men with alcoholism and the hobby of fishing became somewhat predictable, yet there was something in the author's style that kept me coming back.

The flatness of some characters did pose a challenge, but the overall charm of the writing prevailed. The last story, in particular, left a positive impression.

Overall, reading this book was an interesting experience that made me look forward to exploring more of Raymond Carver's works in the future.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.