A classic!!
Told through the character Chief Big Indian, we are able to see the ins and outs of life in the mental ward. The author skillfully uses the Chief's own imperfections to set the mood for the other patients in the hospital. Each of them seems to go through life with the pace of a crawl, as if trapped in a never-ending cycle of monotony and despair.
Set in the 1960's, the story highlights the life inside a mental institute. For the patients, life is basically the same thing day after day. There is no excitement, no change, until Randle McMurphy shows up. He is an out spoken and rebellious character, determined to fight the system, especially the head nurse, Nurse Ratched. His arrival brings a new energy and hope to the ward, but also sets off a series of events that will change the lives of everyone there forever.
“One can never consider the thing one is fighting against as being definitively defeated. The only possibility is to strike it and strike it, until one runs out of strength and another has to take its place.”
“The thing he was fighting against could never be considered definitely beaten. The only chance was to hit it and hit it, until one was left without strength and another had to take one's place.”
The novel is a great metaphor constructed around two extraordinary characters and told by a giant.
The giant is one of the oldest patients in the psychiatric hospital where the novel takes place, “the chief” Bromden, a half-breed son of an old Indian chief. Bromden is schizophrenic and lives in constant fear that the “Combine” will crush him with its pitiless machinery. To avoid this, he has spent years pretending to be deaf and mute, which puts him in a privileged position from which he can tell us everything that the patients and staff on the ward do and say without taking his presence into account, and which he makes us understand with his lyrical and altered vision of the reality he observes, mediated by his constant hallucinations and delusions.
“No one complains about the fog. Now I know why: although it is annoying, it allows one to sink into it and feel safe. That's what McMurphy doesn't understand, that we want to be safe. He keeps trying to get us out of the fog, expose us, where it would be easy to catch us.”
All this gives the story a certain fairy-tale tone in which the confrontation between two strong wills is told, that of the evil witch Nurse Ratched and that of the brave and cunning Randle Patrick McMurphy, two characters who will remain in our minds forever.
“McMurphy doesn't know it, but he's on the track of what I understood a long time ago, that it's not just a matter of the Big Nurse, but that it's the whole Combine, the great power resides in the Combine at a national level, and the nurse is nothing more than a high-ranking official within it.”
This struggle will symbolize the control that the “Combine”, incarnated by the Big Nurse and her followers and violent nurses, is capable of exercising over indolent and conformist societies, the patients, who prefer the security of control to the responsibility and freedom to choose and direct their destinies, a metaphor for the manipulative capacity of the “Combine” to make them forget even that they are being controlled and make them believe that they are the ones who are handling the situation.
“I don't think you have a very clear idea of what the public is like, friend; in this country, when something doesn't work, everyone leans towards the quickest solution.”
The problem with the story arises when the current sensibility clashes with certain clichés that are striking in the novel: on the one hand, women are whores, repressive nurses or castrating mothers, and on the other hand, the patients are all white, except for “the chief” Bromden, who is half-breed, while the violent guards/nurses are black. It is also not a great success on the part of the author to present so lightly the sexual crime for which McMurphy is condemned.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but I will as soon as I can, and from what I've read, it seems that it leans more towards the struggle of wills than towards the metaphor about power, so I must announce to all those who have seen it that they have a powerful reason to also read the novel.
AUDIOBOOK READ BY JOHN C REILLY PERFECT
2/10/24
I always think of this book when I find myself in a downward spiral. I'm off work again so soon this year. I guess I did things out of order. I'm supposed to descend into clinical depression and then read the book. Lying here today without tears, I'm still infuriated by the fact that a fellow team employee took the praise for using a brand new program that I trained myself on and have been communicating with every day at work for six weeks. He took the praise because he did it on a day I was off. Yep, congratulate the man. Obviously, I'm crazy and have no idea what I'm doing. CRAZY!!! Once a person is labeled, all faith, trust, and responsibility go out the window. It doesn't matter that I've been with the company for 15 years and he's with a temp service. Am I the only one seeing this incongruity? And that's why I want to die.
1/13/24
Well, oops, I did it again. I broke my brain. Today is the first day I've felt human since Tuesday past. I don't know if human is the correct term. Let's consider. Are people in wheelchairs human? Are people with DMII human? Are people without sight human? Then yes, I suppose I've been human as well the past week. But could I function? NOT IN THE LEAST. I woke up today feeling rested. You know that kind of relaxed you get about the middle of a vacation when you question yourself, thinking you had been rested the whole time, and then you realize, "oh right! I've been getting 6 hours of sleep at night after eating chips for a late dinner because I had to get such and such done now"? So 10 hours a night has been quite therapeutic. I thought it was time to crack open this audiobook again. Let's see what lesson I learn this time.
4/18/22
Gosh, how many times have I actually read this now? I honestly do not know. And every time, it's like I've never read it; I take away something different. Tonight's lesson, I think, will be about self-esteem and how fragile it is. How one person can tear it down or build it up. No matter how hard you try to be positive, how you want to love yourself just the way you are, and you even talk to yourself in the mirror - in the bathroom, in the driver's seat, maybe with the swiveled camera on your cellphone - just one word, one look can shred your soul. Why do we have to show our age? How is it that we go to bed one night and it seems that overnight you look like your mother, who you love with all your heart, but you're not ready? You'll never be ready.
10/9/20
The movie is currently on Netflix, and it couldn't have come at a more appropriate time in my life. I broke out the audiobook, blew off the dust, and reminded my inner McMurphy to stay strong. I'm currently on medical leave from work for the third time this year. I feel bad for my psychiatrist. She's definitely earning her money with me.
I first read this book in 2007 after I had a nervous breakdown and became a daytime outpatient at Our Lady of Peace, my city's mental health facility. I lost my teaching job and went 5 days a week; I ate lunch there. I was so medicated they had to transport me. Somehow, this book and movie, especially the character of McMurphy, was how my dad related to me during this trying time. Mental health is a trigger issue for me. It's not understood today, and it certainly wasn't understood in the '60s. Let's just keep them caged, sedated, and manipulated. Make them feel guilty about their problems. Take away comfort and leisure. No friends, no family, no fun, no fresh air. Yeah, that sounds healthy.
Addendum 2/13/18
Just bought this on Audible. 50th anniversary edition read by John C. Reilly. It got me thinking of my dad asking his McMurphy how Ms. Ratchett was today. That was probably the roughest patch of my life, but I would never have changed a thing. I learned so much about myself and became so much stronger in spirit. However, I realize that if I had lived in an earlier time period, my outcome could have been much gloomier and permanent. I've been reading various other mental health books lately, and sadly, some things never change as advanced as medicine has become. We just can't seem to grasp the BRAIN.
AUDIO REREAD # 19
How many of us "have been told dragons do not exist, then been dragged to their lairs?" How many of us "forget sometimes what laughter can do?" I think out of all the characters in all the books, Billy breaks my heart the most. Tag teamed by his mother and Nurse Ratchett, he never had a chance in life. All he wants in life is love, and he proves himself to be such a gentleman. As I drove home from work this morning listening to this book, I glanced at my speedometer; I was driving 40 mph on the interstate. It was during the gas station scene when the gang learns that being insane can still mean being powerful. That's when I finally realized how much hope McMurphy instilled in these terrified, suppressed lives, which makes the last couple of hours of the story all the more tragic. McMurphy gave these men another glance at happiness, reminded them how to be assertive, inspired a little self-worth again. He basically showed them they were men, deserving of humane treatment. They were not anyone's "Boys," even at Billy's age, the youngest at 31. They didn't deserve the underhanded, demeaning manipulations and insinuations of a sadist. But these new emotions did not germinate and bloom; only malice and grief took root. Very few books hold my heart through the years as this one does. I appreciate Kesey's honesty on the pages.