I had a profound longing for Narnia in the most heartrending and melancholy way when I was a little girl. At that time, I was completely oblivious to any Christian subtext when I first read "The Chronicles of Narnia". I vividly remember devouring those books just as children today are voraciously reading the Harry Potter series. Lewis's rich and vivid descriptions of fauns, dragons, and giants have left an indelible mark on my memory.
Ten-year-old me had an all-consuming desire to live in that world, shoot arrows, savor Turkish Delight, and befriend those enchanting talking beasts. Above all, I yearned to know Aslan, to be cuddled and loved by that magnificent, fierce, and endearing lion. However, in the end, I had to let go of him and his realm. I recall being so inconsolable that my parents allowed me to stay home from school for a day! This was truly unusual as they never let me play hookey. It's strange to remember that now.
There were numerous aspects of that world that made me feel, in some way, bad. I felt guilty, ashamed, or simply uncomfortable. Remember when Susan didn't return, essentially because she discovered her sexuality? And what about the Calormenes? Those dark-skinned people with extremely strong garlic breath who wore turbans and worshiped a Satanic "false god" who demanded blood sacrifices from his followers? There was so much blame and condemnation in that world. There was a lot of finger-pointing, shaming, damning, and excluding. It was all very black and white, us or them, good or evil.
For these reasons, I ultimately rejected the Narnia books. Later, when I learned that Lewis was a devout Christian and Aslan was essentially supposed to be Jesus in a lion suit, I wasn't the least bit surprised. Nowadays, I recommend Miyazaki movies, especially "Kiki's Delivery Service", to every tween girl I encounter to cleanse their palate of some of the more despicable Disney portrayals of femininity. I also happily give kids (and adults!) the Dark Materials trilogy to counteract their exposure to the Narnia dogma.
All that being said, these books remain a memorable part of my childhood, and I still recall certain parts of them with fondness and longing.
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi...
(Click the above link to read professor Carol Zaleski's interesting take of the seething religious/political furor surrounding these classics.)