Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
Shoeless Joe is innocent.

He is a man who has been wrongly accused and unjustly punished. The story of Shoeless Joe is a tragic one, but it is also a story of hope and perseverance.

Despite the odds against him, Shoeless Joe has always maintained his innocence. He has never wavered in his belief that he did nothing wrong.

Some may argue that Shoeless Joe should have admitted his guilt and tried to make amends. But Shoeless Joe knows that he cannot lie about something that he did not do.

He is a man of integrity and honor, and he will not sacrifice his principles for the sake of convenience or expediency.

Shoeless Joe may have lost his reputation and his livelihood, but he has not lost his dignity. He is still the same man he was before the scandal, and he will continue to fight for what he believes in.

In the end, Shoeless Joe's innocence may never be fully vindicated. But that does not matter. What matters is that he has remained true to himself and his values, and that is something that no one can take away from him.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I learned a few things about the 1919 “Black Sox” scandal after reading this book.


I was truly struck by the remarkable amount of talent that was intertwined in this scandal. Most people are familiar with the legendary left fielder Joe Jackson, who was undeniably one of the best players in the game. However, starting pitcher Eddie Cicotte also had an impressive resume that was Hall of Fame caliber. In fact, he likely would have been enshrined if not for this scandal. Centerfielder Happy Felsch was a budding superstar, while third baseman Buck Weaver and starting pitcher Lefty Williams were really good players in the prime of their careers. First baseman Chick Gandil and shortstop Swede Risberg, although not great, were still good enough to be starting players on a great team. Fred McMullen, just a utility infielder, got involved simply because he heard about the plot and craved money.


The execution of the scam was, unfortunately, a disaster. It was highly disorganized, and many of the participants had loose lips. The players didn't receive the money they were promised, which understandably made them angry. By the start of the World Series, rumors about the fix were running rampant, and the betting odds clearly reflected this. The White Sox, who should have been heavy favorites, were trading at even odds to win.


The first half of the book was the best part, as it vividly discussed the hatching and execution of the plot. However, when it came to the investigation and trial, the flow was not very smooth, and some parts were quite confusing. Thankfully, it did end on a strong note when it explored what life was like for the players after the scandal.


The writing style was a little strange. It wasn't presented as a traditional historical text. There were instances where the narrator seemed to speak for the inner thoughts of some of the players and gamblers, and to me, some of those thoughts appeared to be mere speculation. I would have preferred a more rigorous and in-depth study of the subject.


I was also disappointed with the way the writer addressed the story of Shoeless Joe. It's known that he took the money, but did he actually make any plays in the games that contributed to the conspiracy? I'm curious if the pro Shoeless Joe propaganda in Field of Dreams has any basis in truth. The author was rather unclear on this point. I read several passages multiple times in an attempt to understand exactly what he was trying to convey, but I remained confused.


Nevertheless, overall, I did enjoy the book. I gained a better understanding of what baseball was like during that era, including how gambling was corrupting the game. I now have a clearer perspective on why the players did what they did. I liked that the author didn't simply moralize or make excuses for the players but instead just told their story objectively.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I thought this book was extremely intriguing and fascinating.

The story is presented in a remarkable way, and I couldn't help but constantly wonder what would occur next.

One review that I highly concur with discusses the present state of baseball and how it has changed.

It mentions how steroids and other performance-enhancing drugs are spoiling the game.

This is evident in the book as betting on the outcome of a game can not only ruin a sport but also influence the way players perform.

I also agree that the book provides a valid perspective on why these outstanding players took the actions they did.

Some reviews state that the book is only truly appealing to those who understand the concepts of baseball.

However, I disagree with this view as I am not a baseball enthusiast, yet I adored the book.

I always looked forward to reading more and finding out what happened.

Some reviews also claim that professional baseball is a business, and I indeed agree with that.

Almost any professional sport is centered around business, which helps people understand why the players fixed the game.
July 14,2025
... Show More
We will never know.

There are countless mysteries in this world that elude our understanding.

Maybe it's the true nature of the universe, the meaning of life, or the fate that lies ahead.

No matter how much we explore, study, and theorize, there will always be questions that remain unanswered.

We can only wonder and speculate, but the ultimate truth may forever be beyond our reach.

It is this sense of mystery and the unknown that both fascinates and frustrates us.

It drives us to不断 seek knowledge and understanding, yet at the same time, it reminds us of the limitations of our human intellect.

We will never know for sure, but perhaps that is what makes life so interesting and full of possibilities.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.