Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 98 votes)
5 stars
36(37%)
4 stars
35(36%)
3 stars
27(28%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
98 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
I initially had high hopes for this book, but unfortunately, it didn't quite live up to my expectations.

I gave up on it because I felt like I was suffering permanent damage from reading it, and I was afraid I might start hitting back. Also, it was a borrowed copy, so that wouldn't have been a good idea.

In fairness, there is some good writing here. The beginning chapters were quite enjoyable, and they even made me laugh a little. I have friends who are into genealogy, and their husbands always have that look when they start talking about it, which is exactly how I imagined Claire's husband Frank.

Claire is a nurse, which is a useful skill when she gets thrown back in time. And she manages to land on her feet and get a job once she figures out what's happened to her.

However, that's when the book started to lose me. There was no sense of culture shock. She just settled in and started being the resident nurse at a castle, with no real emotional turmoil.

The thing that really bugged me, though, was the treatment of rape in the book. It was used as a plot device way too often, and it was just really creepy and uncomfortable to read.

I managed to get through a lot of the book, but I finally had to stop. I just couldn't take it anymore. I hope that future books in this series will be better and will handle sensitive topics like rape more carefully.

Overall, I was disappointed with this book, but I'm still willing to give the author another chance. Maybe her other books will be better.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Just as swoon-worthy as the first read. <3

*****************

When my real life, long distance book club selected Outlander as our next read, I was a bit nervous. Indeed, I had intended to read this series for the past decade. However, the extremely large volumes were intimidating to me. Additionally, I'm not well-versed in the historical fiction genre. I had heard strong opinions about this installment, both positive and negative. So, I finally had to read it (or rather, listen to it) myself to form my own thoughts. I'm so glad that I didn't skip this one and let the intimidation make the decision for me. If I had, I would have missed out on a wonderful novel filled with romance, both gentle and rough, and adventure like none I've read before.

Yes, there are brutal acts in this novel that are related to the terrifying times people lived in during the 1700s. And while "that scene" with Jamie made me cringe and boil with a fury I didn't know I had, I still appreciated its inclusion in the story. If you're looking for a light, historical romance, you won't find it here. This story is full of rape, murder, and every type of violence you can imagine, towards both women and men. Although it's sometimes difficult to read, it was done so well. I believe the purpose of including all this was to evoke a well of emotions in the reader, and by golly, Gabaldon did just that in me.

This book is almost as old as I am, so I feel like there's not much I can add to the numerous reviews here that tell it all much better than I could. But I do want to mention that I chose to listen to the audio, while also using my Goodwill $1 hardcover purchase as a supplement. And the audio is PHENOMENAL. Davina Porter is one of the best narrators I've had the pleasure of listening to. While it's a significant time commitment (my audible version was just over 44 hours in total), it was worth the investment. I highly recommend at least supplementing with this version, as she truly brings the story to life. Her various character voices are diverse, yet not cheesy like some who try to do multiple gender voices too extremely. At the moment, I'm not sure when or if I'll continue with the series, but if I do, it will undoubtedly be with the audio versions.

Buddy Read with Noelle, Nalicia, and Hannah!
July 14,2025
... Show More
Man,

After the pitch I've heard about this book from basically every (female) reader I've ever met, I was expecting something completely different. What I got was fairly offensive, needlessly graphic, and smutty in a rather skeevy way, not the hot way one might hope for. At one point, Jamie punishes Claire for disobeying him by actually spanking her. This was presented as something perfectly understandable and was quickly brushed aside. I know that I cringed throughout the entire scene and found it difficult to believe that any relatively modern woman would tolerate such behavior. Especially considering that Claire is supposed to be extremely well educated, capable, and professional. I truly find it hard to wrap my head around the fact that there are five more books like this and that people actually read them.

That being said, I have read worse romance books. However, the fact that Gabaldon stretched this novel out to nearly 900 pages just makes me annoyed. UGH.
July 14,2025
... Show More
A special note to those who say my review stopped them from reading this book: No no no! Read it! I actually reread the whole series last summer and enjoyed it immensely. Just read it for what it is: ludicrous, well-written, humorous, delicious TRASH. Just don't expect it to be the most brilliant novel ever written and you'll be fine.

How To Commit Adultery Without Being a Cheap Slutty Whore: A Q&A by Diana Gabaldon

Q: I love my husband but I'm feeling kind of restless. But adultery is wrong. So what do I do?
A: Easy! Go back in time!

Q: What do you mean, Ms. Gabaldon?
A: If you go back in time, your husband hasn't been born yet. So you can have wild and crazy S&M sex with impunity.

Q: But won't I still be married to him?
A: Aren't you listening? He hasn't been BORN yet. So you aren't married! But if you are really being such a stickler, then just have someone force you to get married to someone else.

Q: But, but, no one can force me to get married against my will!
A: Okay, let me lay it out for you: You're really hot for this sexy warrior barbarian guy, right? I know this, because you stop thinking about your husband about 24 hours after you've been dropped in this guy's arms. So you get in this situation where some obscure tribal law insists you have to get married, make a little protest, sign some papers, and voila!

Q: But that doesn't mean I have to sleep with him.
A: Oh but you do, because some random dude insists that you have to. Don't worry, the sex will be great even though he's a 23 year old virgin. So you see, you HAVE to do it, so it's okay.

Q; But isn't it a sin?
A: Fine, find a priest at the end of the book to absolve you, whatever. And anyway, it's okay because your husband basically told you it was okay, right before you were whisked back in time. Seriously, go for it. When else will you get the chance? You've been married for years. You deserve a little hot and heavy barbarian action.

Q: So what's this hot barbarian guy like?
A: Well, watch out, because he loves to reminisce about how his dad used to beat him and how wonderful that was. And he really gets off on beating you, but it's just the once. Oh, and it seems that he wants you so badly he can't restrain from ramming you repeatedly with his male member while telling you how much he can't restrain himself and that gets seriously annoying after the twentieth time. But otherwise, it's all good.

Q: Anything else I should be aware of?
A: Surprise! Buttsex! But not for you, so it's okay.

Oddly, I'm going to read the next one in the series. Because I'm bizarrely fascinated. It's like a train wreck.

Edit 1:
Someone in the comments said I should copy this into the review, so here you go:

Plot Summary

Claire: I love my husband! I love sex!
Frank: But it's okay if you have sex with someone else, in certain circumstances.
Standing Stones: SUCK! Ha ha, you're in another time!
The Anti-Frank: Ooooh, I think I will rape you.
Claire: Eeek!
Clansmen: Scots to the rescue! Here, meet Jamie and his manly manhood.
Jamie: Och, aye, I'm a tough laddie. And I'm going to kill the Anti-Frank for beating the shit outta of me and raping my sister.
Claire: Ooooh, he's cute. Hey, wasn't I married?
Dougal: Ye have to marry the laddie to get away from the Anti-Frank.
Claire: Okay.
Dougal: And ye have to have sex wit' him.
Claire: Mmmmm.... but.... well, okay.
Jamie: I'm a virgin. Oooh, but I love sticking my manhood in ye. It's like a sacrament and all.
Claire: I should get back to Frank, I think I will take this opportunity to run away... I guess... sort of... meh.
The Anti-Frank: Ha ha! Found you. Now to rape you!
Jamie: Och, that's my wee lassie. First I'm going to rescue her, then I'm going to beat her for disobeying me. And then I'm going to tell her about how me Da beat me and how much I liked it.
Jealous wench: The village witch is looking for you.
Claire: Okay!
Villagers: She's a witch! Burn her!
Jamie: Over my dead body!
Claire: Honey, I have something to tell you. I'm not a witch but...
Jamie: Ye must go back!
Claire: I can't. I long for your manhood too much. It's a manhood like no other.
The Anti-Frank: I too long for your manhood. I think I will bugger you right after I crush your hand with a hammer. But, I love you. You remind me of my dead brother. Here's some grease.
Jamie: Ouch. Oooh, but that feels sort of good. Och, I'm so ashamed.
Claire: We must rescue Jamie! Send in the cows!
Jamie: OCH! Me hand! Just let me die!
Claire: Never! Let's go to France.
Jamie: Och, aye lassie, I feel much better now.
Father Anselm: God says it's okay that you're a bigamist.
Claire: Awesome. Time to use my foreknowledge of past events for good!
Diana Gabaldon: The sequel will be 900 pages.

Finis

This review provides a humorous and somewhat irreverent take on Diana Gabaldon's work. The Q&A format adds a touch of playfulness, while the plot summary highlights the more outlandish aspects of the story. Despite the criticism, the reviewer admits to being strangely compelled to read the next book in the series, perhaps due to the very qualities that they mock. Overall, it's a lighthearted and entertaining read that will likely appeal to fans of the Outlander series as well as those who enjoy a bit of tongue-in-cheek humor.

The use of vivid language and exaggerated descriptions makes the review engaging and memorable. It also gives potential readers a good sense of what to expect from the book, both in terms of its content and its tone. Whether you agree with the reviewer's assessment or not, it's clear that Gabaldon's work has sparked a strong reaction, and this review is just one example of the many discussions that it has inspired.

In conclusion, while this review may not be for everyone, it offers a unique perspective on a popular series. It's a reminder that sometimes, even the most unlikely books can have a certain charm, and that it's okay to enjoy something that might not be considered "highbrow" literature. So, if you're looking for a fun and slightly naughty read, you might just want to give Outlander a try. Who knows? You might find yourself as hooked as the reviewer.
July 14,2025
... Show More

Ok, to be honest, historical romance has never been my favorite genre. I ended up reading this book in a rather strange way. After a concert, I got a bit tipsy and somehow found myself in a bookstore. On a whim, I bought a whole bunch of "Highland-hunk" romance novels and even tweeted about it. So, I felt obligated to read them all. Ugh! I endured 4 other really terrible books, and then this one was highly recommended to me by many people on Twitter and Facebook as the best of the lot. I was extremely skeptical.


However, I have to admit that this is a truly LOVELY book. While I'm not overly excited to read the rest of the series (which consists of 5 books), it really does have some amazing aspects. The characters are fantastic, and it's clear that a lot of research went into creating them. The romance is not at all predictable, which is a refreshing change. The plot is exciting and keeps you on the edge of your seat, and the main character is wonderful. Again, it's not exactly the kind of book I would usually choose, but the quality of the storytelling is simply undeniable. I wholeheartedly recommend this book. It's similar to "Gone With the Wind", unapologetically epic, sweeping, and dramatic.

July 14,2025
... Show More

Here are a bunch of pics from the TV show being filmed right now :D

The filming of this TV show is currently in full swing, and these pictures offer a fascinating glimpse into the action. Each image captures a unique moment, whether it's the set design, the actors in character, or the behind-the-scenes preparations. The first picture shows a detailed set with intricate props and a captivating backdrop. The second image features an actor in a dramatic pose, bringing the character to life. The third picture showcases a different angle of the set, highlighting the creativity and attention to detail of the production team. The fourth picture captures a moment of interaction between two actors, adding to the story's narrative. And the fifth picture provides a final look at the set, leaving viewers eager to see more of what this TV show has in store.






July 14,2025
... Show More
This was a rather challenging book to rate. Out of the total 630 pages, approximately 200 of them were not up to par. They seemed a bit strange, excessive, and deserved only a rating of 1 to 2 stars. There were a couple of instances when I found myself wondering why I was still persevering with the reading and didn't have the inclination to continue.

However, the remaining 430 pages were extremely interesting and well-written. The premise of the story was truly fascinating and left me engaged in deep thought, constantly pondering various "what if" scenarios. It was a work of historical fiction that had been very thoroughly researched, and I am indeed a fan of good-quality historical fiction. If those 200 pages or so that I wasn't particularly fond of could have been edited out or abbreviated, I might very well have given it a full 5-star rating.

In conclusion, it appears that the author has an interest in historical fiction, as well as gratuitous sex, rape/S&M fantasies, and homo-erotic torture. In the first area, she shows proficiency. The second aspect wasn't too bad initially, but after about 100 consecutive pages of it, it became a bit overwhelming. The last two elements were somewhat disturbing.

If you have an interest in historical fiction and a relatively high tolerance for questionable sexual content, it might be worth giving this book a try!
July 14,2025
... Show More
Hallelujah!

After four and a half months, I have finally completed this book. If I were to continue at this pace, my shameful rate of reading around 12 books a year would plummet to fewer than three!

To say that I was not completely engrossed by this book would be an understatement. However, that does not mean that I disliked it.

I approached this book with the wrong expectations. I had seen a film called Outlander, which features a future man with a spaceship crashing near a Viking settlement. I had assumed that this book was the inspiration for the film.

Instead, I found a historical romance with a touch of time travel.

I persevered with it for several reasons. Firstly, it is well-written. The author has a talent for creating vivid characters and a richly detailed world. Secondly, I felt that I should not always read the same type of books. This book offered a new and different experience. Thirdly, it is a huge bestseller, and I was curious to see what made it so popular.

I have never been a fan of romance novels. I am fine with a romantic thread in a book, but I have always wondered where the line is drawn between a book with a romantic element and a full-fledged romance novel.

Outlander demonstrates many of the characteristics of a romance novel. The main character, Claire, is focused on her relationship for most of the book. She is constantly aware of the physical details of her partner, Jamie, and there is a significant amount of sexual content. However, there is also a well-developed emotional relationship between the two characters, and a lot of exploration of their pasts and traumas.

Jamie is the perfect example of the "new man" in 18th century Scotland. He is tall, strong, sensitive, and gentle, yet also headstrong and passionate. He is not afraid to express his emotions, and he is always willing to open up to Claire.

One of the things that I found most interesting about the book was the portrayal of life and medicine in 18th century Scotland. Claire is a nurse, and she brings her modern medical knowledge to the past. We see her treating all kinds of ailments and injuries, and we learn about the herbs and remedies that were used at the time.

The book also explores the political tensions between the English and the Scots. There are scenes of violence and conflict, as well as escapes and captures. The plot is somewhat meandering, but it is never dull.

Overall, I enjoyed reading Outlander. It is a well-written and engaging book that offers a unique blend of historical romance and time travel. However, it is not without its flaws. The sexual content may be too much for some readers, and the plot could have been more tightly focused. Nevertheless, I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical romance or time travel novels.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Okay, there are countless reviews on this book, and it seems there isn't much more I can add that hasn't already been said. However, I made a promise to write a review for every book I read, so I'll approach this in a different way. How about a Q&A session about this book?


Question and Answer Session With Danielle Regarding Outlander by Diana Gabaldon


1. So, you finally read it. How does it feel to read this 850-page magnum opus?
I feel an overwhelming sense of accomplishment. I'm truly glad that I had the courage to take on this extremely long book. It's the longest one I've ever read (aside from the Bible, which I've read in parts but haven't completed yet). I'm very, very glad I chose this book for a challenge and had to read it within a specific time period. Otherwise, I might have postponed it even longer and missed out on this remarkable book.


2. What do you think of Jamie Fraser?
Words can hardly do justice to describe him. He is simply amazing. I can't fathom how D. Gabaldon managed to create such a wonderful, wonderful character. I have certain standards for my "heroes to die for," and he meets every single one of them. What a beautiful, wonderful man! Claire is indeed a lucky woman.


3. Was this a difficult read?
Surprisingly, it wasn't. I did have to focus and apply myself, mainly because I don't usually prefer long books. I like to read shorter ones so I can quickly move on to the next one. This book felt like it could be divided into 2 1/2 books. Nevertheless, it wasn't boring at all. It was fascinating to see life in that era and how Claire, a woman from the 20th century, reacted to it. I have a passion for books about Scotland and Scottish people. Their way of life somehow speaks to me. The characters were incredibly vivid and captivating, and the romance was simply to die for. And Jamie is just awesome!!!


4. What was your favorite aspect of this book?
Jamie Fraser, of course! My second favorite aspect was the powerful love story between Claire and Jamie. They are undeniably a couple meant to be together. I initially thought that the fact that she was married in the future would bother me, but it didn't. I regarded Frank as being from her past life, and although she truly loved him, he wasn't her soulmate like Jamie was (apparently, I can't write a review without using that'soulmate' word). I so wanted her to stay with Jamie. There was no competition. Claire was accustomed to rustic living since she'd grown up on digs with her uncle. I also enjoyed seeing her perform medical treatments (I have a love for medicine). I also liked the adventure and the fighting.


5. What didn't you like about this book?
Well, I despised Randall, but that was the intention! He was a truly sick individual! I can't imagine how Claire felt upon meeting her husband's ancestor and realizing what an awful man he was. I hated some of the situations that Jamie and Claire had to face and the things they had to do. It made me sad that one evil man could cause so much pain.


6. Would you recommend this book to other readers?
Absolutely, as long as the reader is committed to reading a book that is nearly 900 pages long and enjoys historical fiction. No book is suitable for everyone's taste, but I believe those who might be interested in a story with a fantastic hero like Jamie, an outstanding heroine like Claire, and those who are passionate about Scottish subject matter should definitely read it.


7. Has the bar been raised for Scottish Highlander romance?
Most definitely. I try not to compare books because it's not fair. However, now that I've read Outlander, I know that an image of Jamie will pop up in the back of my mind whenever I read future Highlander books.


8. Were parts of this book hard to read?
Oh, there were a couple of parts that made me cringe. One part nearly broke my heart, but Claire really came through for Jamie, and it almost made me cry. It was beautifully written. I tend to read romance books more for the hero than the heroine, but I love a great heroine, and Claire is definitely that.


9. Okay, what if I don't like romance, and I think it's sappy nonsense. Can I still enjoy this book?
Well, I think this book might change your perspective on romance if you don't usually enjoy it. Even if it doesn't, I still believe you'd enjoy this book. Not only is it a great romance, but it's also excellent historical fiction. And the time travel element, although not a major part, is very intriguing. So, give it a try.


10. Danielle, what are you going to do now that you've read Outlander?
Go to Disney World???? Just kidding! Honestly, I'm going to continue my reading adventures in my massive, ever-expanding to-be-read pile. I know that eventually, I will be drawn back to this series. But for now, I think I'll read some shorter books for a while. I might take a break from Scottish Highlander romance for a bit. I don't want to be disappointed because a book isn't as good as Outlander.


11. It's about time to wrap this up. Anything you want to add?
Just a few things: The praise for Jamie Fraser is well-deserved. Ms. Gabaldon wrote a fantastic book, and I'm very glad I read it. I can now give myself a pat on the back for reading this book. I'll consider it my War and Peace, in fact. I hope that those who are hesitant to read this book will take the plunge. It was definitely worth the time spent on it.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Um YES. This is what I like.

It took me a while to really get into and read this book as I was simultaneously engaged in school work and holiday festivities. However, it was most definitely worth the wait and the effort.

If you have a penchant for historical fiction, the concept of time travel, and/or a good romance, then I highly recommend that you pick this up. You will not be disappointed.

Moreover, you also get to experience the presence of the beautiful and perfect specimen that is Jamie. His character adds an extra layer of charm and allure to the story.

Overall, this book has it all - an engaging plot, well-developed characters, and a touch of magic. It's a must-read for anyone who enjoys a good story.
July 14,2025
... Show More
"Ye are blood of my blood, and bone of my bone
I give ye my body, that we two might be one.
I give ye my spirit, 'til our life shall be done."

This is a truly captivating read. The plot is super interesting, involving time traveling and historical romance, with well-developed characters. The author did a brilliant job at writing and researching. However, it wasn't a 5-star read for me. The pacing was a major issue. The beginning was great, with even-paced chapters and beautiful world building and character introduction. But as the book progressed, the chapters got long and the pace slowed down incredibly. It's not a book for binge reading.

Claire is a strong and independent character, but I had questions about why she was the one to travel through time. Jamie is a complex and lovable character, and his love for Claire is swoon-worthy. The supporting characters were there, but none really stood out. The violence against women in the book is a big issue, but it's important to remember the historical context. Claire's infidelity was also a problem for me. Overall, the book was still enjoyable, but it could have been shorter and less descriptive in some parts. I would recommend it if you can overlook the above issues, and I will continue with the series.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I delved into the first 300 or so pages of the book. The initial 200 pages truly had me captivated, drawing me in with their engaging storyline and well-developed characters.

However, things took a rather unexpected turn when the sex scenes began to dominate. Now, I have no issue with an occasional sex scene to add a bit of spice or to explore the relationships between the characters. But in this case, it seemed as if the main characters were engaging in sexual activities almost constantly.

What really crossed the line for me was when it escalated to include violence. There was one particular scene that I can only describe as rape. The female character clearly said no, but the male character forced her to have sex against her will. This was a major red flag for me, and I immediately closed the book and made the decision not to read any further.

I have always been a fan of historical fiction, but I suppose this particular type just isn't for me. It's a shame, really, because the beginning had so much potential. But sometimes, a book takes a turn that is just too uncomfortable to continue with.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.