Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
38(38%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
While reading this, I found myself falling in love with F. Scott Fitzgerald all over again. His words have this magical charm that just draws you in and makes you feel every emotion he is trying to convey.

I couldn't help but feel a deep sense of sadness for how Ginerva treated him. The way she led him on and then broke his heart was truly heart-wrenching. It made me want to reach into the pages and protect him from the pain.

As I got closer to the ending, I had to do everything in my might not to cry. The story had such a powerful impact on me that I was completely overcome with emotion.

I really suggest reading this. It is a beautiful and poignant tale that will stay with you long after you have turned the last page. Whether you are a fan of Fitzgerald or not, this is a story that is definitely worth your time.
July 14,2025
... Show More
F. Scott Fitzgerald's first love was a woman who became the inspiration for many of his female characters. A well-written novel has been penned about her, imagining her as "Ginevra Perry."

Ginevra King had a profound impact on Fitzgerald, and this book delves into their relationship. It provides a fascinating look at how Fitzgerald incorporated aspects of her into his works.

Readers will enjoy this exploration of Fitzgerald's first love and its connection to his literary output. It offers a good introduction to many of his works and is a fun read overall. Whether you're a fan of Fitzgerald or simply interested in a captivating story, this novel is sure to engage you.

Discover the allure of Ginevra King and how she influenced one of the greatest American writers of the 20th century.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I thoroughly enjoyed reading "Gatsby's Girl." The story is indeed sad in multiple aspects. It reflects on the course of F. Scott Fitzgerald's life and a significant part of Ginevra Perry Granger Pullman's life as well. However, what I truly liked was the way Ginevra evolved as a character throughout the book. She came to recognize her errors and flaws, whether or not this accurately represents the real Ginevra King on whom the character is based.


I admired that she not only kept track of Scott's work, initially out of curiosity regarding what he had said "about" her, but also genuinely cared about his well-being. Additionally, Fitzgerald's ability to appraise himself with a fair degree of objectivity was remarkable. He was extraordinarily talented, yet also saw himself as a "cracked plate."


I couldn't quite fathom Fitzgerald's lifelong fascination with Ginevra. Was it mere lust? The allure of the unattainable? Or perhaps an illusion he wished to uphold in his own increasingly disappointing and dissipated life? But then again, the question of why one person is fascinated by another is a complex and often unanswerable one.


The author did an excellent job of depicting the reality of relationships. It展现了 married life's inevitable mundaneness, the distractions and temptations that come with it, as well as the dichotomy of poor parenting and the deep love parents have for their children.


Although I was a college English major, I didn't read a great deal of Fitzgerald. However, "Gatsby's Girl" has inspired me to delve deeper into his works.


July 14,2025
... Show More

Enjoyable and easy read.

Unlike many of the reviewers here, I did grow to like and sympathize with the main character, Ginevra Perry (based on Fitzgerald's young love Ginevra King).

It seems that a significant number of reviewers were anticipating a life-altering piece of literature, but this is not the case.

However, it is an entertaining, fictionalized account of the woman who served as the inspiration for some of Fitzgerald's most memorable heroines.

The story provides an interesting perspective on the relationship between Ginevra Perry and Fitzgerald, and how it may have influenced his writing.

While it may not be a profound or earth-shattering work, it is still an engaging read that offers a glimpse into the world of Fitzgerald and his muses.

Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or is interested in the life and works of F. Scott Fitzgerald.

July 14,2025
... Show More
What I learned from this book, as if "War and Peace" didn't already teach me, is that I have a profound love for historical fiction.

Historical fiction allows me to step into the shoes of characters from different eras, experiencing their joys, sorrows, and struggles. It provides a unique window into the past, enabling me to understand the social, cultural, and political contexts that shaped those times.

Through reading historical fiction, I can explore the lives of ordinary people and the extraordinary events that influenced them. I can witness the rise and fall of empires, the impact of wars and revolutions, and the evolution of human relationships.

This genre not only entertains but also educates, expanding my knowledge and broadening my perspective. It makes history come alive in a way that textbooks never can.

Whether it's a sweeping epic or a more intimate story, historical fiction has the power to transport me to another time and place, leaving a lasting impression on my heart and mind.
July 14,2025
... Show More

A fictionalized account of Ginerva King, the muse and character basis for Daisy Buchanan from The Great Gatsby, offers an interesting perspective. Fitzgerald, in his portrayal, made her seem more cruel and shallow than perhaps she really was. She was just a 17-year-old girl who ended things with a dreamer who was struggling in geometry and had a drinking problem. Yes, she was careless, but that's not uncommon for a teenager.


This book has the charm that it doesn't require the reader to have devoured all of Fitzgerald's works or be well-versed in his biography to enjoy it. However, being a die-hard Fitzgerald fan myself, I absolutely loved it and found it utterly fascinating.


The writer's prose is quite good, which added to my enjoyment. I picked up this book mainly because of my admiration for Fitzgerald. I wasn't really anticipating a great novel, but I was pleasantly surprised. It offers a unique look at the inspiration behind one of Fitzgerald's most iconic characters, and it's a must-read for any fan of his works or those interested in the literary world.

July 14,2025
... Show More
DNF. Second strikeout last night.

Ginerva was truly bland. It was about as exciting as watching paint dry. There was far too much telling and not nearly enough showing.

Seriously, who in their right mind would write something like: "'I guess so,' I said in a soft, sad voice." It just lacks the vividness and engagement that good writing should have.

Readers want to be drawn into the story, to experience it for themselves, not be simply told what is happening.

The author really needs to work on their craft and find a more effective way to bring the characters and the plot to life.

Until then, Ginerva will continue to be a disappointment.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This is a FANTASTIC book.

It is truly a fun read that grabs your attention from the very beginning.

The story is engaging and filled with exciting twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat.

The characters are well-developed and you can't help but become invested in their lives and adventures.

The author has a unique writing style that makes the book a joy to read.

Whether you're looking for a lighthearted escape or a thrilling adventure, this book has something for everyone.

I highly recommend it to anyone who loves a good book.

You won't be disappointed!
July 14,2025
... Show More
The story of the girl F Scott Fitzgerald did not marry is a fascinating one.

Fitzgerald, a renowned American author, had a complex love life. There was a particular girl who held a special place in his heart but ultimately, they did not end up together.

Perhaps it was due to the circumstances of their lives, the pressures of society, or the differences in their personalities. Whatever the reason, the story of this girl has intrigued many.

It makes us wonder what could have been if things had been different. Would Fitzgerald's life and work have taken a different turn?

The girl who Fitzgerald did not marry remains an enigma, a figure in the background of his life who left an indelible mark.

Her story serves as a reminder that sometimes, the paths we choose and the people we meet along the way can have a profound impact on our lives.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Caroline Preston's writing style is remarkably easy going and pleasant.

She masterfully allows her readers to delve deep into Ginerva's character. Despite being an incredibly self-centered girl, by the end, you find yourself liking her a great deal. She brings to mind those individuals who are an absolute joy to converse with at dinner parties. They have sharp and witty observations, are extremely clever, yet you can't form a genuine relationship with them as they are overly self-absorbed.

Preston also offers another astute insight. Ginerva has no clue about the kind of person she truly is. There are times when she admits to being self-centered, but then she rationalizes it with a plethora of good reasons why she isn't a terrible person. I think most self-centered people are indeed like this. They fail to understand why others turn away from them.

This book presents a fictionalized account of a woman whom F. Scott Fitzgerald dated during his college years. She embodies everything he desires to be, yet she remains out of his grasp as she doesn't love him. Her personality and choices lead to drama in her life, but she emerges in a much better state than Fitzgerald did. This is because she had faith in herself, while Fitzgerald did not. Of course, her self-belief stemmed from the fact that all she truly cared about was herself.

July 14,2025
... Show More
This is a truly remarkable historical fiction novel that is sure to captivate readers, especially those who have a penchant for The Great Gatsby.

The story weaves a fascinating web of characters and events that transport the reader back in time.

What makes this novel even more engaging is the presence of some interesting connections between Fitzgerald's life and these characters.

It's as if Fitzgerald has infused his own experiences and emotions into the fictional world he has created.

The detailed descriptions and vivid imagery bring the story to life, allowing the reader to immerse themselves fully in the narrative.

Whether you're a fan of historical fiction or simply looking for a great read, this novel is well worth your time.

It offers a unique perspective on a bygone era and a deeper understanding of the complex human psyche.

So, pick up this book and prepare to be transported to a world of glamour, tragedy, and unforgettable characters.

July 14,2025
... Show More

Certainly, and this is openly admitted by the author, it is a work of fiction that is loosely based on a few facts and filled with the broad strokes of imagination to round it out. I have to say that if even a fraction of this story is actually true, it provides an explanation for why I always found "The Great Gatsby" to be so lonely and depressing. If Daisy was Ginevra and Gatsby was Fitzgerald himself, it becomes obvious what a profound impact Ginevra had on him, an impact that resounded throughout the remainder of his much too short life. Both Scott and Ginevra were barely likable and far more pitiable than anything else. I found that the book kept me turning the pages, not because of entertainment or a fantastically woven tale, but rather in the way that one can't help but look at a wreckage. At the end, I just felt...sad.

 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.