Came for the portrait of life in a guerilla band, stayed for the cool molotov shotgun diagram.

A treatise on the importance of discipline and moral rigour (to the point of asceticism) in establishing a relationship of trust and security between the guerilla band and the rural population on which they depend (and whom they aspire to liberate). This is the sine qua non of guerilla warfare and that makes this work primarily a book of practical ethics. It delves into various aspects, down to its (briefly outlined) dictums around romantic relationships, paying one’s debts, economy in the use of resources (ammunition, energy, people), etc. Combat is seen as glorious but not in an ecstatic way. Violence is regarded with highly tempered enthusiasm. Terrorism is strictly proscribed, the enemy is to be treated with humanity (often allowed to escape after a lecture), and the wealthier classes are to be given “bonds of hope” rather than merely expropriated. In short, this is a cool-headed and somewhat boring read. However, it is precisely this aspect that made me enjoy it all the more. It presents a rational and thoughtful approach to guerilla warfare and the associated ethical considerations.

Might elaborate later but that’s about all I have to say for now.

From the beginning of my reading in the book, I decided not to finish it as it is not of the kind of books that can be read by the general public but only by military men who understand military tactics and the like.

This book seems to be highly specialized and targeted at a specific audience. It likely contains detailed and technical information about military strategies, operations, and perhaps even classified knowledge.

For the average person, it may be difficult to understand and appreciate the content.

However, for those in the military or with a deep interest in military affairs, it could be a valuable resource.

It might offer insights and perspectives that can enhance their understanding of warfare and help them in their professional development.

Overall, while this book may not be suitable for everyone, it has its place in the realm of military literature and can contribute to the knowledge and expertise of those in the relevant field.

Guerrilla Warfare: The Ultimate Guide to Camping

This instruction manual on guerrilla warfare clearly accomplishes its purpose and has evidently endured the tests of battle. I comprehend the book's objective and the ideologies of its writers, along with the intended indoctrination. However, the rules it presents can potentially be applied in combat against any form of government.

When compared to counter methods such as the highly touted hearts and minds strategy, which aims to undermine the factors that make resistance movements popular, like education and hospitals, it becomes quite interesting.

Also, by looking at it through the perspective of other conflicts and groups that have deviated from the methods proposed in the book, for instance by using terrorism, lacking proper schooling, and excluding women from combat, and have consequently been pushed into retreat.

One significant aspect that is missing, as pointed out in 'Learning to eat soup with a knife' (if my memory serves me correctly), is the 'Area of rest'. This implies that all major conflicts won by guerrillas have occurred in territory with a sympathetic or at least an indifferent neighbor.

Overall, this book offers valuable insights into the complex world of guerrilla warfare, but it also highlights the importance of considering various factors and strategies in different contexts.